Communal Fire Alarm

Viewing 23 posts - 1 through 23 (of 23 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #7014
    atimoracky
    Participant

      Hi,
      Camden as a freeholder has recently conducted a fire safety assessment in our converted building and wants me as a leaseholder to allow Mayfair Developers, a contracted private company to install new “LD2 fire alarms” in my flat that connect to the communal hallway for £250 charge.

      After enquiring about details I was told this is a requirement but there is no mention about the existing fire alarms in our flat.

      Whilst I am all for safety I do not want to pay for additional alarms if that makes sense.

      Does anyone have any experience with this and do you know if as a leaseholder I can refuse these to be installed in my flat?

      Thank you.
      Andrej

      [Manager – this was posted on 8 June]

      #7050
      CarolynM
      Participant

        I have had a similar experience. I am in a street property with just two flats (me plus a tenant). I got a form letter which was clearly written more for larger properties. This was a different contractor, OpenView. They showed up one morning without bothering to contact me for an appointment and installed an enormous unit which looks like it was designed for a block of 20 flats. Also lots of very ugly piping and intrusive switches. I complained to Jeremy Do (Project Manager) and asked for a copy of the specific fire assessment for my property. No answer yet. Of course I am now being charged £250 for this monstrosity. And on top they are claiming about £290pa for the electricity and fire checks/maintenance. In the corridor, dear reader, there is just one light on a timer and an external street door light on a motion sensor. The electricity bill for my entire flat including cooker, appliances, multiple rooms (which I pay privately) is £800pa so if I am being charged 50% then that means a total cost of almost £600pa for two lights on timers and this fire panel. The approach is over-specced, and costs are just being imposed on leaseholders.

        #7105
        CarolynM
        Participant

          I received a copy of the fire assessment which was done back in Nov 2021. They didn’t bother to talk to me or see in my flat. They have rated the building as medium risk from looking from the outside. I am challenging this. If it has happened to me and I am now being charged £00s for an overspecced fire system it could happen to others. A nice little earner for the contractors.

          #7106
          IzzyW
          Participant

            Once again it seems leaseholders are being used as cash cows. The same work is being proposed in our converted town house (2 leaseholder flats, one council flat in a 3 story building with one small communal hallway). I challenged the necessity of having this eye wateringly expensive ‘fire detection system’ installed from the moment we were told about it (by letter, dated 25 April.) Despite the fact our fire alarms were replaced in 2021, with leaseholders picking up the bill, apparently the fire safety inspection recommended that this new fire detection system needed to be replaced. Jeremy visited our building and confirmed that our existing alarms were in full working order and met regulatory standards, to which I responded with the obvious question – why on earth then do we need new ones, during a cost of living crisis when £250 “plus fees” is totally unaffordable for some people!
            Worst of all, they didn’t conduct a Section 151 consultation asking for our views on the proposed fire safety upgrade work, and despite my numerous emails challenging the necessity of this work (citing the adequacy of the existing alarms), Jeremy is insistent on this work continuing. I have told him I’ll be writing to my local Ward Councillor to put a stop to this work going ahead, so that funds can be redirected to where they’re most needed in the borough. I recommend others do the same, or if you’d like to co-sign my letter please reply to this thread and I’ll add you as signatories. Keep fighting the good fight everyone x

            #7107
            bourneestate
            Participant

              Carefully go through the clauses in your lease. Fire safety checks and installation of devices might not be a rechargeable expense for leaseholders.

              #7108
              CarolynM
              Participant

                Hi Izzy, I have raised the issue with James Slater (councillor for leaseholders). Do get in touch as if several leaseholders have had the same experience this will help our negotiations. carolynm.clf@gmail.com

                #7109
                CarolynM
                Participant

                  Hi Izzy, I have raised the issue with James Slater (councillor for leaseholders). Do get in touch as if several leaseholders have had the same experience this will help our negotiations. carolynm.clf@gmail.com

                  #7125
                  CarolynM
                  Participant

                    Update: Today I spoke to Jeremy Do (project manager). When pressed he said that a decision had been made “by a director” to install these over-specced fire alarms in all street properties with three or more stories (ie ground, first floor, second floor). I have asked him for documents to confirm this. Ultimately the cost, which must be more than £250, will be retrieved from us via service charges or council tax in the end.

                    #7433
                    IzzyW
                    Participant

                      Hi everyone. I’ve been informed that the cost of the fire safety works (replacement doors, automatic lighting in communal hallway, hideous rocket launcher aka LD2 ‘fire safety system’ connecting to the fire alarms in the flats) is not, as has been repeatedly stated by Camden, capped at £250. This is what I received by email stating that it’s only capped at £250 per contractor:

                      FRA works are capped at a maximum of £250 per leaseholder, per contractor. For example if contractor 1 is undertaking 3 FRA activities the charge will be £250 maximum per leaseholder. If there are other FRA works taking place at the same address by contractor 2 & 3, the leaseholder will be charged a maximum of £250 per contractor. If section 20 was applied and consultation took place the maximum leaseholder contribution would be significantly more. If these works were procured outside of capital works FRA works i.e. meter cupboards then there isn’t a cap on leaseholder contributions.

                      I feel grossly misled by the repeated claims of Camden staff and contractors when I’ve expressed concern about the cost of the fire safety works that “it won’t cost more than £250”. In our street property we’ve had about 4 different contractors doing different elements of all this over-specced nonsense, so I’m expecting a bill of minimum £1,000. I have also never heard of this distinction between capital works and major works which apparently also means the cap doesn’t apply.

                      Yet again Camden seem to be taking leaseholders for mugs thinking they can charge whatever they hell they want. I’ll be seeking legal advice from the Leaseholder Advisory Service to understand if there are legal grounds for challenge.

                      #7434
                      HarrietG
                      Participant

                        This fire safety refurbishment has been going on for over a year in my building (Victorian terrace with two flats) with endless different contractors turning up (usually unannounced) to do the work — I have lost track. The massive fire safety system alarm that was installed last year malfunctioned within two months, going off at 4am waking all the neighbours & with no instructions for how to turn it off. We had to call out the fire service in the end & they were none the wiser but we did find a way to silence the actual sounders. No contact from Camden even though it was reported & then someone turned up about six weeks later, unannounced & with no ID, fiddled around & (I suppose) fixed it. The automatic lighting that’s been fitted is excessive for use & was so bright & continually on (too sensitive) over the front door we had to have it turned off as it was an irritant to the neighbours. We have had three lots of people come round to do an asbestos assessment as the first report was lost. The replacement fire doors were measured at the beginning of the year, but not yet fitted. We seem to have been through at least three lots of different contractors too (I’ve lost track) & I am dreading the service charge bill based on what IssyW says — I have received notification today that the 2023/24 charges are imminent & must be paid within 28 days.

                        #7435
                        daugs
                        Participant

                          firstly it has been my personal experience that Camden, on occasion, lies about it’s obligations and interpretations of the lease. I caught them at it blatantly in 2003 and never trusted them since.

                          I was told that I too would need a wired alarm in our flat. We are the G and LG of a street property, with a bedsit flat on 1st and a third flat on the 2nd and 3rd floors. It’s a period building converted in 1976. The proposal was surface wiring and to cut through the mouldings and period features. To cut a long saga short I insisted on being provided the details of the legislation requiring this. Eventually I received the below….

                          “Please see attached info you requested regarding flat front door (fire door) and domestic alarms.

                          Your flat is classed as being in a building converted into self-contained flats so Lacors guidance is used.

                          See page 25

                          Three- to six-storey house converted to self-contained flats (prior to Building Regulations 1991, approved document B standard)

                          GRADE A LD2 coverage in the common areas and a heat detector in each flat in the room/lobby opening onto the escape route (interlinked)

                          Grade D LD3 coverage in each flat (non interlinked) smoke alarm in the room/lobby opening onto the escape route) to protect the sleeping occupants”

                          ie there was no legal requirement for a wired LD2 system in my flat.

                          My advice would be to politely demand details of what rules they are using and their interpretation. It’s a reasonable request. Obviously your flat may have different circumstances.

                          There have been similar discussions about the flat door. They have demanded access to do annual safety checks but this is a necessity for buildings in excess of 11m, so I have asked for how and when they assessed the height, since our estimates are around 9m, not even close, but the way the exact measurement is complicated with where the measurements are taken from and to.

                          One last thing, don’t be surprised if you get various threats including forfeiture, I have. This is obviously escalating the stakes but there are several hurdles. Make sure you get discussions in writing so you can demonstrate everything you have done is reasonable.

                          David

                          #7450
                          WHkingdom
                          Participant

                            Can’t agree more with this. It’s been a nightmare. I can’t believe that on street property are basically treated as if we were massive blocks. Why waste money on a massive 20 zone alarm system for a two flats house!

                            People are still turning up installing more and more things (a new extra box this month) with absolutely no notice. Supposedly some if not all of this was supposed to be free, but I am dreading the price of maintenance and extra electricity for all of this.

                            Like you, door is still not installed. We got told they are still being manufactured (when was supposed to be installed 2 months after their visit).

                            This year on 2023/2024 service charge we’re already paying for two different fire risk assessment (one on service charge, one on major works), I can’ even imagine what it’s going to be next year…

                            #7451
                            CarolynM
                            Participant

                              I have had a similar experience. I had an email from Susanne Afra (Head of capital works) stating that no leaseholder would pay more than £250 for all the fire safety works. However my charges (SC + MW) total c£750. If this affects other people you know please post here and then we can raise this as an issue with Camden, local councillors and the new Cllr for Leaseholders, James Slater.

                              #7468
                              CarolynM
                              Participant

                                Evening all, I’m keen to collate examples of excessive service charges to leaseholders as part of the fire safety programme. We have Susanne Afra attending the 4 Dec CLF and I want to raise this as an issue. Personally I am being charged c£750 plus 10% management fee ie c£800 for three elements of the same programme, all in a tiny corridor of a street property, zero consultation. If @IzzyW @HarrietG @WHKingdom are willing to send me their emails I can compile some cases – can anonymise if you prefer. I already have @daugs email thank you. Will also raise this with James Slater. My email is carolynm.clf@gmail.com

                                • This reply was modified 2 years ago by CarolynM.
                                #7471
                                IzzyW
                                Participant

                                  Hi Carolyn,

                                  Very happy to share over email the various bits of correspondence I’ve had with Camden assuring me the fire safety programme of works will cost no more than £250.

                                  I’ve also spoken to the Leaseholder Advisory Service about the charges for the Fire Safety Works. They suggested the first course of action is to make a joint formal complaint to Camden from all those affected, stating the following:

                                  – Requirements under Section 20: if major works will exceed the sum of £250, then Camden is required by law to consult with leaseholders. If they are related works and have to be completed as a package (as we’ve been told these fire works are) then it’s one programme of work and should therefore not exceed £250 if no consultation is carried out.

                                  – Camden themselves in correspondence with leaseholders have described the Fire Safety Works as a programme of work, which implies one set of related works.

                                  – Cite lack of transparency around charges and use any correspondence from Camden stating the works won’t exceed £250 per leasehold property as evidence.

                                  – Refer to the Service Charge Residential Management Code (RICS code of practice) and specifically the transparency guidance.

                                  – Also refer to Cllr Slater’s report and the clauses related to communication and transparency.

                                  We could also copy in Cllr Slater as leverage. If we’re not satisfied with the outcome of the formal complaint, we can then recourse to the housing ombudsman and involve Cllr Slater and local MPs.


                                  @CarolynM
                                  do you think we should hold off until the 4 Dec CLF meeting to see if it can be resolved there?

                                  Izzy

                                  #7473
                                  CarolynM
                                  Participant

                                    Hi Izzy,

                                    Agree with your suggestions. I have a handful of examples of excessive charges already and may receive more.

                                    Please email me on carolynm.clf@gmail.com and I will keep you in the loop.

                                    My plan is to compile a “dossier” of anonymised examples of overcharging, then first approach Cllr Slater who I have met a few times.

                                    If we can get his support I’d then like to raise it with Susanne Afra (Head of Capital Works) before the 4 Dec meeting. She has agreed to attend the meeting – I’d rather ask her to respond to the issue at the meeting than just confront her cold and then we won’t get a response till 2025.

                                    If 9000 leaseholders have been charged £800 each (like me) then Camden is extracting £7.2m from us for the fire safety works.

                                    • This reply was modified 2 years ago by CarolynM.
                                    #7477
                                    CarolynM
                                    Participant

                                      Hello All, I’m expecting to have a short meeting with Cllr James Slater next week (day tbc) and would be keen to be able to share (anonymised) examples of fire safety programme overcharging. Do please email me on carolynm.clf@gmail.com with details. Don’t stop complaining directly to Leaseholder services or anyone else – I just want to prove that this is widespread, not just isolated cases.
                                      @Izzyw

                                      @whkingdom


                                      @harrietg

                                      • This reply was modified 2 years ago by CarolynM.
                                      • This reply was modified 2 years ago by CarolynM.
                                      #7485
                                      CarolynM
                                      Participant

                                        Update: I have a meeting with James Slater on Thursday. I also dug out two letters I received in April 2023 and Sep 2023 which both stated that the £250 fee was per property. Worth checking your own pile of letters from Camden.

                                        #7486
                                        johnwhenry
                                        Participant

                                          My experience on fire alarms has been an utter disgrace.

                                          I own a flat across the first and second floors of a property. Ground floor is council Tennant.

                                          They have installed a *huge* fire control box in the communal hallway which can accommodated TWENTY apartments. This has to be a huge waste of money – not to mention making the hallway of a small property look and feel like a factory entrance.

                                          Happy to share photos.

                                          John Henry
                                          Ascham Street, NW5 2PB

                                          #7487
                                          daugs
                                          Participant

                                            John, is it just 2 flats in a street property, sounds like converted period house ? do you know what they have done in the tenanted flat below, wired LD3 or wireless LD2 system. Have they said what they would like to do in yours, since you don’t mention I presume they’ve not done anything yet ?

                                            David

                                            #7494
                                            daugs
                                            Participant

                                              To All

                                              Pictures of new doors, wired alarm systems as well as emergency lighting that has been fitted would be helpful particularly if the building is listed and / or in a conservation area and especially if any period features have been disturbed or removed or impacted. Having seen what’s been installed upstairs I am deeply concerned. Checking with English Heritage something far less damaging that still complies with the legislation is perfectly possible.

                                              thanks

                                              David

                                              #7520
                                              frederickprice
                                              Participant

                                                For info, I’ve also received a letter along similar lines dated 19/11/2024 from hashad pankhania. Is there an update on the various matters mentioned on this forum? Any news from the meeting of 4 December? And do we have a sense of how this roll out is progressing?

                                                Regards.

                                                #7521
                                                frederickprice
                                                Participant

                                                  I have just emailed Camden as follows:
                                                  ********************************************************
                                                  I would be grateful for Camden to provide me with:
                                                  – a copy of the recommendations from the inspection mentioned;
                                                  – a list of Camden properties where this process is considered ‘very effective’; for instance, how the systems reacted to fires, or whether there were false alarms;
                                                  – copies (with names / details redacted if necessary) of feedback from leaseholders on the installation process and the outcome;
                                                  – photographs and specifications of the proposed alarms and the visible technology to be placed in both my home and the building common parts / hallway;
                                                  – a copy of the contract with TJA Electrical;
                                                  – the building / local authority regulations which mandate the connected system;
                                                  – details of the technology connecting the various alarms together;
                                                  – assurances and protections against false alarms and noise pollution;
                                                  – the provisions of the various leases which allow for the proposed course of action to take place;
                                                  – the proposed timescale for this work to be carried out;
                                                  – an explanation as to why my own smoke alarm is considered insufficient; and
                                                  – any incident reports involving the various connected systems already in place in similar buildings in Camden.

                                                Viewing 23 posts - 1 through 23 (of 23 total)
                                                • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.