Charges for Smoke alarm safety checks/inspections

Camden Leaseholders’ Forum homepage › Discussion Board › Service Charges › Charges for Smoke alarm safety checks/inspections

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #7488
    daugs
    Participant

      Just wondering if anyone has asked Camden for details and whether they have had any response ?

      The inspections at mine (street property split into 3 flats) seem to range in block cost from £16, £32, £48 and £113 for 2022/23, while 2023/24 had 3 quarterly inspections, £64 x2 plus £32 (no not multiples of £16 ?). Sometimes it seems more for yet another sign ?

      Still trying to find source of must be done quarterly, the only “independent” recommendation I’ve seen is for annual, but also seen monthly and even weekly which clearly Camden couldn’t do at least financially.

      David

      • This topic was modified 2 years ago by daugs.
      • This topic was modified 2 years ago by daugs.
      • This topic was modified 2 years ago by daugs.
      #7522
      frederickprice
      Participant

        Yesterday I emailed Camden, indicating I needed more information in order to consider the implications of a recent letter as to installation of a connected alarm system, as follows:
        ********************************************************
        I would be grateful for Camden to provide me with:
        – a copy of the recommendations from the inspection mentioned;
        – a list of Camden properties where this process is considered ‘very effective’; for instance, how the systems reacted to fires, or whether there were false alarms;
        – copies (with names / details redacted if necessary) of feedback from leaseholders on the installation process and the outcome;
        – photographs and specifications of the proposed alarms and the visible technology to be placed in both my home and the building common parts / hallway;
        – a copy of the contract with TJA Electrical;
        – the building / local authority regulations which mandate the connected system;
        – details of the technology connecting the various alarms together;
        – assurances and protections against false alarms and noise pollution;
        – the provisions of the various leases which allow for the proposed course of action to take place;
        – the proposed timescale for this work to be carried out;
        – an explanation as to why my own smoke alarm is considered insufficient; and
        – any incident reports involving the various connected systems already in place in similar buildings in Camden.

        #7548
        IzzyW
        Participant

          Hi Frederick and David,

          Have either of you had any luck getting clarification from Camden regarding how the inspection charges are calculated?

          Looking at my service charge statement for 2023 – 2024, I can see that the three flats in our street property incurred a grand total of £584 just for communal smoke alarm checks and fire risk assessments. This is quite a staggering figure, and doesn’t include any of the installation costs for the new Grade A system, doors etc, which no doubt will run into the thousands of pounds.

          Izzy

          #7549
          daugs
          Participant

            short answer no, Camden are busy demonstrating that their complaints process has not improved despite the warm words to the ombudsman

            David

            #7762
            IzzyW
            Participant

              Hi everyone,

              I’ve just received my service charge adjustment for 2025/26 and can see this issue hasn’t gone away.

              The charges for smoke alarm testing seem to vary significantly, ranging from around £21 to £53 for what appears to be exactly the same thing. We also had two smoke alarm tests carried out just four days apart in August 2025.

              Has anyone managed to get a clear answer from Camden about:
              1. How often these inspections are supposed to take place?
              2. Why the charges vary so much from visit to visit?

              My biggest concern, however, is the “Ventro Fire Alarm Monitoring Annual Charge”, which on my bill totals £313.59. This is on top of the separate charges for smoke alarm testing and maintenance visits.

              Has anyone else been charged this annual monitoring fee? In total I’m being asked to pay about £650 for fire safety related work for 2025-26, not including the initial £250 charge for the installation of the eye sore in our communal hallway and other risk assessment charges billed as major works.

              I’m concerned we were never told about this ongoing charge when the new fire detection systems were installed. In our block, several of us questioned whether the system was proportionate for a building of this size and repeatedly asked what impact it would have on future service charges. We never received a clear answer, and the annual monitoring charge was never mentioned.

              I’d be interested to know whether other leaseholders are seeing the same charges and whether anyone has had a satisfactory explanation from Camden, and whether the ongoing monitoring charge is something we should challenge?

              Thanks

              • This reply was modified 2 months, 1 week ago by IzzyW.
              #7765
              CarolynM
              Participant

                My service charge is on the Camden Account.
                One particularly egregious charge is £336.19 pa for “Fire alarm monitoring” – this is for a small street property with two flats. The visits take 5 mins once a quarter, so this is over £84 per visit!
                This charge is on top of the £134.97 for quarterly visits by Camden to check that the corridor is empty (spoiler, it is)
                So that is £471.16 for completely unnecessary 5 min visits of which I am charged 50%
                CLF raised a concern about these multiple visits over a year ago, and have had no response, despite reminders.
                If you are seeing these charges on your bill, please raise a complaint or talk to your local councillor.
                I have queried this with leaseholder services but no response as yet.
                Can’t wait till Sagal comes canvassing to my doorstep….

                #7767
                IzzyW
                Participant

                  I’ve complained twice about excessive charges for fire safety related works and both times my complaints have been rejected (included when appealed.) I’m at a loss of what else to do. I was planning to attend Cllr Meric Apac’s drop in surgery tomorrow as it seems we don’t even have a cabinet member representing leaseholders anymore…

                  Is there a joint complaint we can put in about the ongoing maintenance charge which was not made clear at the time these overspecced systems were installed?

                  #7770
                  daugs
                  Participant

                    I would suggest s22 requests once the paper bills arrive, last year I had one inspection costing £300 for the block ! Challenged at the FTT, that’s another story…

                  Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
                  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.