Are leaseholders subsidising council tenants’ heating bills?

Camden Leaseholders’ Forum homepage › Discussion Board › Service Charges › Are leaseholders subsidising council tenants’ heating bills?

Viewing 16 posts - 1 through 16 (of 16 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #7300
    Birdsnest
    Participant

      If you thought that your heating service charge was solely related to what Camden Council pay to the heat network for energy, you’d be wrong, because the council decide how to divide the heat network costs amongst their tenants and leaseholders. Decision-making can be followed online by reading Camden’s Housing Scrutiny Committee and Cabinet documents. Because I was shocked by the extremely high 2023-24 heating charges, I wanted to find out how they were calculated, so I did a bit of research. This is what I found out (with apologies if you knew it already) …

      About half of Camden’s tenanted properties and just over 40% of leasehold properties receive district-heating services and/or gas supplies from the Council. Their heating service charges are paid into the heating pool, which is a ring-fenced self-financing account within Camden’s Housing Revenue Account. In 2023-24 council tenants were given a one-off cost of living adjustment, and therefore paid far less than leaseholders for their heating. As it is a ring-fenced account, it appears that the council tenants’ adjustment was subsidised by leaseholders. Furthermore, the 2023-24 adjustments for council tenants will continue to be subsidised by leaseholders in 2024-25 because the council need to prevent the account going into deficit.

      The fuller history is:

      17th Jan 2023: Camden’s Housing Scrutiny Committee forecasted a deficit in the heating pool for 2022/23 of £4.9m which would require a 220% increase in heating bills. All reserves had been used in the previous year (2021-22) to shield council tenants from the start of extremely high energy prices and limit their increase to 15%. For 2022/23, due to cost-of-living factors, the Housing Committee recommended that council tenants’ heating charge increases should be capped at 125%. This would be funded by applying one-off funding of £3.5m in credits to tenants’ rent accounts as a cost-of-living adjustment (effectively putting the heating pool into deficit). I have put in a freedom of information request (CAM7107) which confirms that the £3.5m subsidy came from the heating pool rather than from another budget.
      18th Jan 2023: Camden’s cabinet approved the Housing Committee’s proposal for 2023/24.

      23rd Jan 2024: Camden’s Housing Scrutiny Committee notes that current supply gas prices (Oct 23 – Sep 24) are showing a decrease of 21.5%, and electricity prices an increase of 8 to 9%. Nevertheless, their recommendation is to freeze heating charges at the same level being paid in 2023/24 in order to “recover the deficit incurred in previous years to the HRA reserve and to avoid a negative heating pool reserve”.
      24th Jan 2023: Camden’s cabinet approved the Housing Committee’s proposal for 2024/25.

      So, it appears that:
      1. In 2023-24 council tenants got a subsidy from the heating pool and leaseholders didn’t.
      2. In 2024/25 the leaseholder charges will be held artificially high to subsidise deficits from previous years.

      I put in another freedom of information request to get some actual numbers. For 3-bed properties on our estate, the average 2023/24 heating service charge was £2,880.75. Council tenants in 3-bed properties were given an average subsidy of £1843.40. Leaseholders weren’t.

      If Camden supplied residents with gas rather than ‘heat’, then they would be governed by Ofgem’s resale rules (https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/sites/default/files/docs/2003/01/1970-mrp_5.pdf) which would require the calculation of our service charge to be much more transparent and fair. Sadly, there is no such protection for the resale of heat.

      • This topic was modified 2 years, 6 months ago by Birdsnest.
      • This topic was modified 2 years, 6 months ago by Pilot.
      #7302
      Leaseholder1
      Participant

        Hi Birdsnest

        Thank you very much for all of your research on this topic and sharing your significant findings.

        It would be interesting to know whether (i) council tenants will receive any subsidy for their 2024/2025 heating charges as well as their 2023/2024 heating charges, (ii) what proportion of leaseholders’ contributions to the heating pool for 2023/2024 were applied to subsidise council tenants’ heating charges, eg did leaseholders contribute £7 million to the heating pool so 50% of our bills were applied as a subsidy? and (iii) what proportion of leaseholders’ contributions to the heating pool for 2024/2025 will be applied to subsidise council tenants’ heating charges.

        It is not clear to me how under my lease Camden is entitled to inflate my heating charges so that it can use the excess money to subsidise tenants’ heating charges. My lease provides that I have to pay Camden a proportionate part of maintaining the heating system and the cost of gas and electricity to supply it. The proportion I pay is a specific percentage (based on the old rateable value system). If that percentage is, eg 1.5%, I don’t see how Camden can charge me eg 3% so that it can use the excess money to subsidise tenants’ heating charges. It would be interesting to know how your and other leaseholders’ leases work?

        Having said that, when I look at my service charge bills, for all services except heating/hot water/gas supply, the block cost is specified and then my cost, so that I can see what percentage of the block cost I am paying. However, in the case of heating/hot water/gas supply, no block cost is specified. Instead, I only see a number specifying my cost and an insurance premium. So I cannot see what the block heating costs are and I cannot verify what percentage of the block heating costs I am paying. I assume other leaseholders’ bills are set out in the same way.

        For 2024/2025 some blocks will have heat meters installed and activated and residents should be billed on their metered usage. It may be harder for Camden to extract additional money in subsidies from metered leaseholders, in which case the burden of subsidies may fall on unmetered leaseholders.

        This is a can of worms. If Camden have used leaseholders’ contributions to subsidise tenants’ heating charges I wonder whether Camden use leaseholders’ contributions to subsidise Camden’s share of major works charges.

        #7316
        Birdsnest
        Participant

          @leaseholder1 with regard to your question (i) about whether council tenants will receive any subsidy for their 2024/2025 heating charges, this extract is from the Housing Scrutiny Committee minutes from 23/1/24:
          “Current supply gas prices (Oct 23 – Sep 24) are showing a decrease of 21.5% … but electricity prices continue to increase between 8 to 9% higher than previous contract period. The Council continues to benefit from purchasing energy at wholesale prices in advance – the Council has purchased all energy required up to September 2024 and this price is fixed. However, the Council still needs to purchase energy from October 2024 to September 2025 (six months of which falls within the 2024/25 financial year) and is therefore exposed to the ongoing price volatility for that period.
          It is therefore recommended to freeze heating charges to tenants at the same level being paid in 2023/24 (i.e. net of credits but the charges will reset at this lower level) … This is necessary to recover the deficit incurred in previous years to the HRA reserve and to avoid a negative heating pool reserve. It is also recommended that where eligible and applicable to refund surpluses generated by residents in “Bulk gas” Heating sites so that annual charges reflect expenditure incurred on these blocks.”

          I think the key phrase in the extract is “net of credits but the charges will reset at this lower level”. I understand this to mean that the council tenants will continue to pay the same as last year – i.e. a much lower rate than the leaseholders (who will continue to pay the same very high rate as last year). The reduction won’t be applied as a “credit” like in the previous year – they will simply be charged at a low rate. If that is the correct interpretation, then the answer to your question is ‘yes’ – council tenants will continue to be subsidised by leaseholders in 2024-25.

          I don’t know the answer to your other questions. It might be possible to work it out by analysing more documents or by putting in another FOI request.

          I agree that metered estates might be less exposed to this problem, especially if they are being supplied with gas rather than “heat”, because then Ofgem’s resale rules apply. Our estate is supplied with heat, and there are no current plans for it to be metered.

          #7317
          patrickhagopian
          Participant

            I am a member of the Camden Leaseholders Forum Energy Working Group and I am concerned about the issue that you raised. We (myself and the other member of the group) are currently having an internal discussion trying to work through your argument and evidence. May I ask @birdnest: have you raised the matter directly with Camden? If so, would you be willing to share the exchange of messages with me at patrickhagopian@gmail.com ? If you do contact Camden in future, please feel free to cc the message to me.

            If, however, the CLF decides after our deliberations to contact Camden ourselves, would you give us permission to copy (anonymously) the meat of your message to them: the part that concerns the Cabinet decisions of January and the two-line conclusion that leaseholders appear to be subsidising tenants? I’ll also take a look at the FOI request and response before doing anything.

            It may actually be more constructive for you to address Camden directly, since you seem to be on top of the subject and probably better able than anyone to engage in further dialogue if one develops, but this is also a matter of general concern to many leaseholders. My thought is that Camden might say that only tenants are going to repay the deficit created by the subsidy, if that is true. That seems to be the only mechanism that would mean that your suspicion about the subsidy is wrong. But that seems to me, on its face, to be at odds with your evidence. It does seem worth challenging Camden to explain just how the deficit will be repaid and by whom.

            Can we have a b/c conversation?

            Thanks, Patrick Hagopian, vice chair of the CLF (for another three weeks).

            #7318
            Birdsnest
            Participant

              Hi Patricia. I haven’t raised it with Camden. I was really just trying to understand how the massive 2023-24 service charge was calculated, which led me to read some of the decision-making documents and put in the FOIs. At this stage the cross-subsidy is a strong suspicion, rather than a fact, and some of the information is quite difficult to follow, so I wanted to socialise it here first to see what others think and make sure I haven’t misinterpreted. It’s a bit of a jigsaw, and some of the pieces are probably still missing.
              Below are the FOI references (I don’t know if they are online yet):

              CAM7107 – Question 2: On 18th January 2023, Camden Cabinet made the following decision: “It be agreed to increase the heating pool scales by 175%, to defer repayment of the 2022/23 heating pool deficit into future years and apply credits to bring the net increase down to 125%.” This decision was in reference to a Housing Scrutiny Committee Supplementary Report 17th January 2023 which worded their recommended option as follows: “Option 3: 125% increase (175% increase with one-off credit to limit increase to 125%) The Council could take the base case of 175% increase then cap this increase temporarily for 2023/24 to a 125% increase. This would be funded by applying one-off funding of £3.5m in credits to tenants’ rent accounts.” The final sentence refers to “tenants’ rent accounts”, but not to leaseholders’ Service Charge accounts. For the avoidance of doubt, please can you confirm whether the credits were applied only to tenants’ rent accounts, or whether they were also applied to leaseholders’ service charge
              accounts?
              Answer: This decision did not apply to charges to leaseholders for heating/hot water.

              CAM7107 – Question 3: Please can you confirm whether funding for the £3.5m credit came from the Heating Pool budget or the wider HRA budget? If it came from neither, please can you tell me which budget it came from?
              Answer: £3.5m of credits were applied to rent accounts as agreed by Cabinet. As the prices of fuel dropped during the year lower than originally forecasted, it was effectively managed within the heating pool.

              The FOI with the actual numbers for Oakshott Court is CAM7138. They initially refused this request, but it went to internal review and the decision to refuse it was overturned.

              CAM7138 – For the leaseholder properties and council-tenant occupied properties respectively at Oakshott Court (NW1 1ST and NW1 1SS), please send me:
              a). Their mean average estimated property service charge for Heating/Hot Water/Gas Supply for the years ending: 31st March 2024, 31st March 2023, 31st March 2022
              b) Their mean average actual adjustment for Heating/Hot Water/Gas Supply for the same period.

              The answers are given in a mixture of formats which makes them very confusing to follow, but my interpretation for 3-bed properties in 2023-24 is:
              – Leaseholders were billed an average estimated charge of £2,880.75.
              – Council Tenants were billed an average estimated charge of 2952.04, which had a concession applied of -£536.64, bringing it down to to £2,415.40 (I said in my original post above that the concession was -£1843.40, but now that I’m looking at it again, I believe I mis-read it due to the inconsistent presentation of the tables).

              Also, those numbers are averages rather than charges for individual properties, which makes them even more difficult to interpret. The estimated heating service charge for the individual 3-bed property I have an interest in at Oakshott Court was £3659 for 2023-24, so I don’t understand why the average for all 3-bed properties is so much lower. In short, I don’t trust the figures I’ve been given, but they do seem to show that the bills for council tenants and leaseholders are being calculated differently, and that concessions are being given to council tenants from the heating pool fund, which both tenants and leaseholders contribute to.

              Another FOI request (CAM6205) gave me the following stats for Oakshott Court, but they don’t really help to untangle the average heat charges:
              There are 114 residential properties in total, of which 70 are occupied by council tenants and 44 are leased to private ownership under the Right to Buy scheme.
              There are 68 one-bed properties, 2 two-bed properties, and 44 3-bed properties.

              #7319
              Birdsnest
              Participant

                Just to add, it seems to me that if Camden supplied the properties with gas then Ofgem’s reseller rules would apply and there would need to be a clear and transparent relationship between the cost of gas and what residents pay. However, because they are re-selling “heat” instead, those rules don’t apply, and the council is free to do jiggery-pokery with the numbers. They are passing on the heat network’s cost + X, where the mysterious X is dependent on cost-of-living politics and the need to balance the books to stop the ring-fenced heating pool account going into deficit.

                • This reply was modified 2 years, 6 months ago by Birdsnest.
                #7321
                Birdsnest
                Participant

                  Patrick, fyi Appendix B on page 45 of this document gives the latest heating pool financial position as of Jan 2024: https://democracy.camden.gov.uk/documents/g10546/Public%20reports%20pack%2023rd-Jan-2024%2018.30%20Housing%20Scrutiny%20Committee.pdf?T=10.

                  (Apologies for the typo in your name in my earlier post)

                  #7322
                  patrickhagopian
                  Participant

                    Dear Birdsnest,

                    Thank you for the helpful responses. CLF has sent a query, including one of your messages, to Camden’s Geraldine Littlechild and we’ll await a response.

                    To give you my view of one of the matters you raised early on (and let me make it clear I speak now only for myself, not for the CLF or even for its Energy Working Group): “In 2023-24 council tenants were given a one-off cost of living adjustment, and therefore paid far less than leaseholders for their heating. As it is a ring-fenced account, it appears that the council tenants’ adjustment was subsidised by leaseholders.”

                    I think “was subsidised” is unproven and doesn’t necessarily follow from the fact of the tenants’ discount. If Camden allowed the tenants’ contribution to the heating pool accounts (and therefore the heating pool itself) to run at a deficit, it must have been cross-subsidised somehow, but that could have been, as an extraordinary measure, by funds outside the Housing Revenue Account. Ring-fencing or not, there are lots of ways an organisation can run a deficit into the next year: it is basically an accounting exercise.

                    What eventually determines who will have subsidised the tenants’ heating costs depends on who ultimately pays off the deficit. That is what will determine whether it is true that leaseholders subsidised tenants’ heating costs.

                    It seems to me that if the discounted amount (hence the deficit) is allocated solely to tenants in current and future accounting, and is therefore paid off gradually through a supplementary tenants’ contribution to the heating pool account, then the issue is resolved: tenants’ heating costs would have been discounted in one year and deferred to future years’ tenant contributions. Agreed? Alternatively, as an extraordinary measure, Camden could write off the deficit using funds from outside the Housing Revenue Account. I don’t think this would be an attractive option, but it is possible at least in principle. If neither of these mechanisms is used, then the only alternative left is the conclusion you came to, perhaps prematurely: that leaseholders will retrospectively subsidise the discount that tenants were given.

                    If that is all a bit complicated, it comes down to a very simple question: who will pay off the deficit that Camden ran up when it allowed tenants a discount on their heating costs?

                    I am not sure that question was as posed as clearly as it might have been to Geraldine Littlechild. It is possible accordingly Geraldine Littlechild will miss the point and will simply recite truisms: the general policy that leaseholders pay only for their own heating costs. The issue is whether that principle is respected or breached in this particular case. The way to get the answer will be by asking specific questions and addressing the specific facts of the case.

                    Again, as a personal view: my worry is that there are ways that a subsidy could be disguised. If we all make a higher-than-usual contribution to replenish the reserve fund, and then at some stage the reserve fund is used to wipe out the deficit, that will amount to a covert way of smuggling a leaseholder subsidy into the accounts. To avoid that obfuscation, one has to keep a laser-like focus on the question above: who pays off the deficit?

                    The issue you raised gives onto a larger issue: we rely on Camden’s accounting for apportioning fair costs to everything, from heating costs to the costs of repairs and of Major Works. All of these decisions are riven by a conflict of interest. That is not just a risk; it is a fact. Camden is the accountant and we hope it behaves as an honest broker, but it is also one of the parties that has to pay whatever costs are not met by leaseholders. It has a clear — and legitimate — interest to collect every penny that can be fairly attributed to leaseholders but it also has a duty not to collect a penny more than that. It is therefore vital that the accounting processes be honest and transparent, and that leaseholders and their local and borough-wide organisations keep Camden honest. We have an equally clear and legitimate interest in demanding accountability. Careful scrutiny like the exercise you have performed is vital for that purpose.

                    #7323
                    Birdsnest
                    Participant

                      Thanks Patrick – I will forward the FOIs to you by email as I know there can sometimes be a lag in publishing them.

                      The thing I notice from reading the scrutiny committee documents is that it can be difficult to follow which Heating Pool decisions apply to all residents and which decisions apply only to tenants. For example this paragraph is from the doc I linked to in my previous post (with my emphasis added):

                      “3.20 For 2023/24, had the full price rises been passed onto residents to keep the heating pool reserve in balance, tenants on heating scales would have faced an increase of 175%. In January 2023, Cabinet recognised the significant impact this would have had on tenants and their ability to pay. As such, Cabinet decided to limit the increase to residents to 125% – by applying £3.5m of temporary credits to accounts mitigating the expected high impact to HRA reserve. It was also agreed that the heating pool deficit (created by heating charges being less than actual costs to the HRA of gas and electricity during 2022/23) would be carried forward and recovered in later years.”

                      This makes it sound as if the credits were applied to all residents’ accounts, yet my FOI CAM7107 confirmed that the £3.5m of temporary credits were only applied to council tenants accounts. My suspicion is that that even the committee members making the decisions probably don’t fully understand this distinction and its potential consequences to leaseholders in the same heating pool.

                      I would also like to understand how “the general policy that leaseholders pay only for their own heating costs” that you mentioned works in relation to bad debt. Appendix B of the doc I linked to in my previous post shows that 5% of the heating pool expenditure is “bad debt”. There is no distinction between council tenants’ bad debt and leaseholders’ bad debt, which implies that all of the bad debt costs are pooled.

                      For context Oakshott Court (my estate of interest) has no metering, or any plans to get metering (I asked this question too), so there is no way to distinguish what an individual resident’s “own heating costs” are.

                      #7325
                      Birdsnest
                      Participant

                        With reference to my original post, someone has kindly pointed out in an offline conversation that the Jan 2024 recommendation of the Housing Scrutiny Committee was to freeze tenants’ heating charges at the same level being paid in 2023/24. It is silent on whether leaseholder heating charges would also be frozen. See paragraph 3.22 of the public report pack for 23rd Jan 2024 at https://democracy.camden.gov.uk/ieListMeetings.aspx?CommitteeId=624.

                        It is not clear from the committee paper whether the frozen heating pool financial summary on page 45, and the 2024-25 heating pool charges on page 49, are applicable to leaseholders as well as tenants.

                        I’ve therefore asked the site administrator to change the title of this discussion thread from a statement to a question: “Are leaseholders subsidising council tenants’ heating bills?”. More information will be needed before that question can be answered.

                        This page of Camden’s website gives details of what is included in leaseholders’ heating bills: https://www.camden.gov.uk/heating-hot-water-and-gas-supply-service-charge. It doesn’t say whether subsidies and bad debt are included but, if they were, they would fall into the category of “indirect costs”.

                        The fact remains that, although Camden claim to be buying heat-network energy at a discount, their 2023-24 heating charge was approximately double what an average household paid for the same sized property nationally, so something doesn’t add up!

                        Another valid question that has been raised offline is – “If leaseholders are subsidising council tenants’ heating bills, should leaseholders be concerned?”. The major energy providers such as EDF, Octopus and British Gas pool the costs of bad debt and grants/subsidies to struggling households, so why shouldn’t Camden Council? The answer may lie in the ratio of leaseholders to council tenants. On my estate of interest, leaseholders are very much in a minority.

                        #7328
                        Pilot
                        Keymaster

                          The CLF Energy working group asked Camden to respond to the suggestion that leaseholders might be subsidising Camden tenants and to provide some clarity. We are sharing this response from Leaseholder Services and Camden’s Finance team:

                          Leaseholders are not subsidising tenants heating bills. This is a misunderstanding in the thread.

                          Leaseholders net contribution to the heating pool is nil. Tenant and leaseholder charges are apportioned differently in the sense that leaseholders pay an apportionment of the running costs for the network they are connected to. Whereas for tenants, the costs of all the un-metered heating networks are pooled together and then apportioned across the relevant tenants. Costs for both leaseholders and tenants who do not have heat meters are apportioned to properties based on heating type and number of bedrooms.

                          For illustration purposes, imagine a heating network containing 10 1-bed flats all receiving the same type of heating, and two of the flats are leaseholders. The leaseholders would pay 20% (2 X 100%/10) of the total running costs and the remaining 80% of the costs relating to the tenants would go into the heating pool.
                          As leaseholders make no net contribution to the heating pool any surplus or deficit held in the heating pool belongs to tenants only.

                          Each heating system is separately metered and costed. So leaseholders are only charged for fuel used on their specific heating system. Leaseholders are charged an estimate bill for heating ahead of the relevant financial year which is based on forecasts around price and usage. Once actual costs are known leaseholders receive a revised bill (usually within 6 months of the end of the relevant financial year) containing a credit where the costs were less than estimated or an additional invoice where the estimate was too low.

                          At the time of estimating leaseholder charges for 2023/24 the projections on likely future gas prices were higher than actual prices received during the year. So leaseholders should see a downward revision in the gas element of their heating charges when the 2023/24 actuals are issued in September, assuming the usage hasn’t increased significantly. To clarify, the costs per kWh during 2023/24 were lower than expected but if the amount of energy used was significantly higher than expected this will have an impact on the charge for the year.

                          Leaseholder heating charges also include a charge in respect of repairs and maintenance of the heating network they are connected. This is not included in tenants’ heating charges and instead forms part of their rent.

                          Information on how leaseholders’ heating charges are apportioned can be found on our website at https://www.camden.gov.uk/service-charges.

                          Finally, Camden will be regulated by Ofgem who are working with the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (DESNZ) to draft new regulations to include heat networks.

                          #7330
                          Birdsnest
                          Participant

                            Thanks Manager. That sounds reassuring. I still don’t feel I understand it as well as I would like to, despite having read everything I can find. The information linked in the Finance Team’s message is too high-level to be useful. Hopefully the draft new regulations will include a requirement to make it all a bit more transparent and publish a full annual breakdown of costs, charges and adjustments online for all heat networks.

                            The fact remains that the 2023-24 heating charge for the unmetered property I have an interest in was double the national average for a property of that size. If it isn’t subsidising tenants via the heating pool, then the huge charge is likely to be a combination of a forecast price that was way too high, and the fact that residents in unmetered properties have no incentive to conserve energy, and that a lack of room thermostats make it hard for them to do so even if they wanted to. I’m glad to hear there’s an adjustment on its way in September 2024, but that will be 18 months after the huge 2023-24 charge was incurred.

                            Many leasehold properties in Camden are rented out to private tenants, and some leaseholders pass their forecast heating charges on to their private tenants in full. Most private tenants won’t realise that their landlord will get an adjustment in September 2024, and those on a 1 year fixed=term contract may have moved out by the time the adjustment has been paid. If gas was being supplied, rather than heat, Ofgem’s resale rules would legally oblige landlords to pass the adjustments on. Hopefully Ofgem’s new regulations for heat networks will cover this point too.

                            #7342
                            Pilot
                            Keymaster

                              An officer from Camden’s Finance team will be attending the Forum meeting on 28 May and will be available to answer questions on the allocation of heating costs.

                              In case you are not signed up to receive our email updates, you will find the latest news update on this link. This includes information about the forthcoming meeting.

                              #7367
                              MelanieR
                              Participant

                                I did not attend the recent Forum meeting in May so do not know if any further light has been shed on this topic. I have however been reading the above posts with interest as I am also extremely concerned about the very high service we are charged particularly the portion charged for bulk gas that is rapidly becoming unaffordable. Several contributors have spent huge amounts of valuable time trying to get to the bottom of why our gas charges are so high and have received in response long detailed explanations from leaseholder services. I believe that we leaseholders must stick to the basic facts which are that the charges are too high and not get lost in the reasons why. These remain are unclear.

                                After consulting the British Gas website I discovered that I am paying double the average estimated for gas supply for my small flat. The fact remains that there is something very wrong with a system whereby we leaseholders are charged 100% more than other consumers nationally. We are unable to switch supply to a cheaper option. On my estate Kingsland, gas meters were installed on individual flats several years ago but they are never read. Camden has no interest in doing so. If they did then we would be charged for what we consume only.

                                We have no recourse to Camden and have to accept whatever amount they choose to charge us. We have not enjoyed any discount or relief on costs as have tenants. It is unfair, unjust and may even not be legal. In fact is, I even go as far as saying, that we are exploited. Is there anyone else who feels the same? Does anyone know our legal position?

                                #7369
                                emmersch
                                Participant

                                  Thank you @Birdsnest and @Pilot.

                                  I had a similar concern about the way Camden Council was calculating the prices it charges to leaseholders for heat, not least given government support offered in respect of heating.

                                  The question I asked in October 2023 to leaseholder services was as follows: “1. How was any government support for high energy bills passed on from the council to consumers? Obviously the Council is obliged to pass on all support in full to its tenants/leaseholders. How has that happened for leaseholders of Camden Council?”

                                  The answer I received, which I couldn’t really make head or tail of, was: “In regards to your first point, the energy support scheme was available for anyone with a domestic electricity connection in England, Scotland or Wales. This was paid out to customers through their private electricity accounts and not through Camden Council.
                                  The government had introduced support for businesses purchasing wholesale gas with a cap on the price charged per kilowatt hour. However because we have used LASER, the cost is predicted to be below that cap. LASER is a public-sector organisation which purchases gas and electricity on the wholesale market for local authorities and other public bodies. Since 2011, Camden has procured gas and electricity through a framework operated by LASER. Wholesale prices are lower than retail prices. Also, the purchasing scheme allows the purchase of energy before the supply period, meaning energy can be purchased when prices are most favourable. Therefore by using LASER to purchase energy at wholesale prices, the cost of your energy is lower than those buying at domestic market prices.”

                                  That answer wasn’t really clear to me. Maybe it is clearer to you. Maybe it is moot.

                                  But it would seem wrong to me if the council apportioned costs differentially to leaseholders and to council tenants, either directly by charging different amounts, or indirectly by giving council tenants a rebate, particularly one in effect financed by leaseholders. I just don’t see that how that accords with any basic principle of fairness or reasonableness, which would be a legal requirement.

                                  The note from @Pilot suggests that maybe fears around this are misplaced, even if the costs seem insanely high. It is certainly to be hoped that there will be some kind of rebate in September when the actual costs are calculated.

                                  #7375
                                  CarolynM
                                  Participant

                                    The minutes of the 28 May CLF have now been published. Below is the extract with the explanation given for the calculation of tenants and leaseholders energy bills. The person who attended said that leaseholders were not subsidising tenants.

                                    What this does not address is the level of the charges. You rightly point out that there should be an adjustment in September for actual costs rather than estimated. If once you receive this it still looks too high/ above market rate then post here or email camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk and we can raise at future meetings with Camden officers. Also worth raising with your local councillor.

                                    12. ENERGY
                                    David Hart provided the Forum with some background information, advising that the issue with energy bills had come about when a leaseholder had queried whether tenants heating bills had been subsidised by leaseholders. The Leaseholder had put in a number of Freedom of Information requests to the Council, the Council’s response had appeared to alleviate those concerns.

                                    The Leaseholder Services Manager explained that Leaseholders connected to a communal heating system received bills which included a number of items such as, gas and electricity consumption, insurance for the boiler, any ad hoc repairs and maintenance. Gas and electricity consumption was based on the actual bills received from the Energy Company for the system Leaseholders were connected to. Leaseholders did not subsidise any other heating systems or any other residents connected to the heating systems. Leaseholders paid their share of the cost of any gas, electricity and repairs used for that heating system.

                                    Emma Cardoso (Strategic Finance Lead) explained that tenants charges were calculated in a different way and the confusion may have been due to the report she wrote to cabinet where she referred to residents rather than tenants. She informed the Forum that some tenants were connected to the district heating system who were on meters. Those tenants not on meters were part of a pool, where all the gas, electricity and some running costs were lumped together and apportioned out based on tenant’s bedroom sizes and also whether or not their system was 24 hours a day.

                                    There were different scales which could be found at the back of the Cabinet report which explained how much they were charged.

                                    Tenants did not get actualisation like leaseholders, once they had been given their scale, they paid according to that which was not changed until the following year.

                                    Carolyn
                                    Chair, CLF

                                  Viewing 16 posts - 1 through 16 (of 16 total)
                                  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.