Maiden Lane heating major works – working together

Camden Leaseholders’ Forum homepage › Discussion Board › Major Works + Estimates › Maiden Lane heating major works – working together

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #7370
    emmersch
    Participant

      Many people on Maiden Lane Estate will have been receiving correspondence from Camden for some years regarding major works around district heating. The question of what will actually happen seems to have gone through multiple versions. An options paper was produced in 2016 and then, as far as I can see, sat on the shelf. A new options report was produced in 2022. What it proposed was radically different from what had been proposed before. It’s not clear to me whether the council was entitled to proceed on the basis of consultations held many years before.

      What is being proposed now, with a consultation process that feels more like going through the motions than anything else, seems even more invasive, and takes no real account of reasonable leaseholder concerns about works which they will pay for but which, as currently conceived, will reduce the value of their homes, are likely to cause large scale damage for which there is no envisaged compensation, run pipes in places different to where they are now thereby reducing the usable space of the properties, and be highly unsightly.

      I have attended a consultation on this. It was highly disappointing in terms of information provided. Both leaseholders and tenants had very reasonable concerns. They were clearly voiced. These are, I think, being fully disregarded by the council.

      I would like to be in direct touch with other leaseholders on this issue. My email is emmersoncharles@yahoo.co.uk

      I do believe there are multiple ways of getting Camden Council to think again about aspects of their design here, including ultimately a legal challenge to the basis of the works.

      The Council’s current approach seems to be to give themselves a blanket licence to more or less do whatever they like in people’s homes, including Leaseholders, with some assurances things will be done sensitively when the time comes which, however well meaning, are not convincing for as long as they are not written into the actual design specifications of the work.

      The council has offered some home visits to individual leaseholders and others to try to allay concerns. I can see those are welcome on one level. I have been requesting one for some months without success.

      I do have a worry, however, that the offer of individual visits is a way of trying to avoid confronting more fundamental flaws in the heating works as currently conceived: e.g. the council’s plan not to replace old pipework where it is, but to run entirely new pipework in plastic casing around people’s flats, above the floor, irrespective of where current, modern pipework is, and without any real regard to investments and decorations undertaken by leaseholders which will be made redundant or destroyed as a result.

      I’d greatly appreciate the advice of any CLF member with experience on this, or anyone else who is similarly concerned. If any leaseholder on Maiden Lane would like to be in touch, please drop me a line and we can discuss your concerns and how best to take this forward. I don’t see the council doing anything positive on our behalf.

      I’d also be very happy to join anyone else who is more advanced in thinking about how to adjust what the council is doing so it is fairer, better and less wasteful.

      #7371
      imogenisabelle
      Participant

        We had the same heating works already done on the St Silas Estate (and others have been done before and since; I think they’re in Denton now). When they visit you, they will produce drawings of the work/piping, and there is some latitude to find better solutions.

        The works have to be done because of new(ish) Heat Network (Metering and Billing) Regulations https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5fce3739e90e07562aba0de7/heat-networks-guidance-on-metering-and-billing-regulations-2014.pdf

        It’s not possible for them to go into the floors, nor use the existing pipework, as the problem is the pipework has all the flats linked together, which is exactly what they’re undoing. The external pipework is generally not as obstructive or ugly as I was worried about, though it’s not ideal and there are certain places I dislike it. Most of the piping is not boxed in, but painted white, and most of it runs at skirting level, and on relatively few walls, depending on the layout and number of radiators in your home.

        The make good was quite poorly done in our home – our walls are all white, so that was easy, but I went into labour during the heating works (yes, really) and my sister-in-law had to oversee the works for us while I was in hospital, and when I came back they obviously wanted to clear out as quickly as possible as I had a newborn. It’s something I’m sure we could have been more dogged about getting people back to fix the last few things, but generally speaking they’re things we can fix with a bit of DIY.

        I really empathise, it’s a huge pain and hugely disruptive at the time, but the result is less bad than I feared.

        #7372
        emmersch
        Participant

          Hi Imogen, thanks for your note. It is mildly reassuring. Dealing with all this while having a newborn sounds truly nightmarish!

          I’d be super interested to see how Camden have done it in your block, if that’s possible at all. I’ll drop you a line separately.

          That said, I’m not sure how comparable the works on St Silas and those planned on the Maiden Lane estate are: the layouts and specifications are I think different, and there seem to be different contractors/heating engineers involved?

          At the moment, for Maiden Lane, Camden have staked out an entirely unreasonable maximalist position with no commitment to make good or compensate. I can’t see how they will deal with new pipework going behind built in kitchen units, fully tiled bathrooms – very little guidance has been given. The council has a requirement to repair and renew and indeed replace existing pipework on a like for like basis; but placing pipework in an entirely new place within people’s properties without due consultation and, in many cases, in situations where it is not technically necessary, is not reasonable.

          In my particular case the pipework is entirely new from 2020 and already has thermostatic valves and other controls, which was put in to renovate a flat which had become uninhabitable, and where the council was entirely aware of its condition and work required.

          I’d be interested to have any experience of Maiden Lane leaseholders on this, to see what scope there is for working together. Do drop me a line here or directly.

          Like other leaseholders, not only I am concerned that I will potentially receive a very large bill for work, but that in addition the work done will reduce the value of properties, reduce usable space, wastefully ignore existing work, and cause substantial further renovation costs to rectify damage caused by the council’s work.

          #7380
          imogenisabelle
          Participant

            Hi emmersch, I’d be happy to send you a video of how the pipework has been done in our flat, and alongside that I could send you the drawing (to which there was one fairly major change in execution, which I can outline). I can’t see how Camden have not committed to make good? In carrying out the work, they have to knock through walls etc to run pipework, so have to fill all that back in. For us, they could make good but only with white paint, though said if the resident still had specific paint that matches a room, the workmen should be fine to use that instead.

          Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
          • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.