Camden Leaseholders’ Forum homepage › Discussion Board › Major Works + Estimates › C Major works invoice
- This topic has 8 replies, 10 voices, and was last updated 4 years, 7 months ago by Zloto.
-
AuthorPosts
-
4th February 2022 at 07:45 #6120
I represent a number of leaseholders at Norbiton House in Camden and we have received an invoice for works carried out by Camden Council
(Freeholder). The works took approximately two (2) years to complete from the date of commencement and we have received notice for
payment totalling just under £40k each, which we strongly feel is extortionate.
Communication from Camden council has been patchy at best and any questions regarding the estimates have had standard canned responses, not addressing the actual issues.In this matter, there are several points of concern / contention:
1. We believe Camden Council has failed to follow due process and properly consult with leaseholders. We were not properly informed of
the costs, timings and the work that would have been carried out. There was no clear outline of what and when the works would be – and despite us asking for the same, we were not informed and the builders simply showed up one day. During the process there were several issues but again, the council was not involved at all.
2. Cost calculations appear inconsistent and incorrect
3. A number of the works appear vastly over-inflated in cost and
were (we believe) unnecessary
4. We feel the cost of some works should be the sole responsibility of the Freeholder and/or covered by the Freeholder’s insurance policy, and therefore not chargeable to Leaseholders (i.e. roof works, etc)
5. We have had no consistent communication with the council. We have had to chase up the council to agree a way forward and to discuss the
charges and they do not get back to us for months.This has been going on for a few years and the council has used the cover of COVID to not answer for months.
Just reaching out here to see if others have been in a similar situation and what was the result – who was contacted/engaged? Since the work was done in 2015-2017 (yes, took around 2 years) – and we were sent the bill in January of 2020. They are now chasing for payments but we don’t have clear answers to our questions regarding the charges.
Any help/guidance will be much appreciated.4th February 2022 at 14:17 #6122Hi, we (as leaseholders) are in a very similar situation. The council (freeholder) is carrying out major work in our building since July 2021. However, there are lots of concerns:
1. The Camden council has never consulted the leaseholders. We are not informed about the scope of work, timing, etc. The builders just showed up one day, eracted the scaffolding all around the house, removed the rendering round the walls, cut pieces off the window sills, etc. Then they left and did not return for a few months.
2. We asked the council numerous times but never get anything in writing. We never did get the scope of the works. They always use the cover of COVID to delay our enquiry.
3. The manager from the council reassured us that because these were emergency works, and also because the disrepair was Camden’s fault due to its own neglect in maintaining the house, we would not have to pay for the work. Again, we do not get anything in writing. Meanwhile they did nothing else.
4. The building is left in such frustratingly bad state for 7 months — full of scaffoding, with walls and windows damaged. There was no sign of the manager.We are worried that we would end up with the same situation like the leaseholders at Norbiton House.
- This reply was modified 4 years, 9 months ago by thomasccp.
8th February 2022 at 18:01 #6124The leaseholders of Bourne Estate have started legal proceedings through the First-tier Tribunal for huge bills to change windows that didn’t need changing, roof works and scaffolding costs. Each leaseholder is being billed around £20k (give or take a few k). Best thing to do is give notice of taking similar action then start the action.
20th February 2022 at 12:41 #6175Unfortunately, this is a recurring issues across virtually all Camden Freehold properties. Appeals are quite difficult and rarely publicised. The only public case I found was this – https://anthonygold.co.uk/latest/blog/florries-law-council-major-works-charges/.
I got in contact with the Anthony Gold they are not very interested in individual cases. I think they would quite interested if it was a larger case, combining multiple disgruntled leaseholders.
Overall though, we are in the same situation as you are. In fact, almost identical by the sounds of it. We have have piles of evidence to show how incompetent Camden have been throughout the major works project and evidence to show that the proposed cost isn’t reflective of the scope of work, the quality of the output and isn’t even competitive vs local tradesmen.
As this seems to be a re-occurring issue year after year, I am surprised that there isn’t a well trodden appeals process. The amounts of money are very material in absolute and in relative terms.
If you know of a decent appeals process or framework please let us know!
23rd March 2022 at 16:46 #6189I am also interested in disputing the costs for proposed major works to Richbell on Tybalds Estate. If there are any leaseholders in this block please let me now.
The costs are approx £19k which I am expected to pay in installments over a year, I cannot understand why what they are proposing can cost so much.
[MANAGER adds: to respond directly to Charlotte please log in and use ‘Send a Message’ on left of post]- This reply was modified 4 years, 8 months ago by Pilot.
23rd March 2022 at 17:43 #6191Yes I’m in simlar situation in the Weedington Estate (details here if interested: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/Discussion-Board/discussion-post/weedington-estate-heating-and-hot-water/
The main problem is really just the arrogance of the council. I have no problem in paying for works to be done if a) they can explain why they are necessary and b) justify the cost. But they just ignore me.
They only got in touch to explain some of the payment options!
I’ve put my MP on the case and they have asked the council for answers and written to the Camden New Journal but I don’t hold out much hope beyond legal action.
1st April 2022 at 23:15 #6195I have the same issue with major works invoices regarding Rodmell. Over the last couple of years I have been billed close to £20,000 for works to roof, asbestos removal, painting of communal stairwells and now new lifts. None of the work carried out so far has made any material or noticeable difference to how my flat looks like or feels. The walls have not been painted for over 10 years, the railings are all rusty, as are the drain pipes. It literally feels like money down the drain. Any challenge to Camden is met with complete silence, until they send you a letter threatening legal action. There does not seem to be any accountability. I am surprised that not more leaseholders are complaining about this. There is no other area of life when one could be billed £20,000 for no value and no justification.
7th April 2022 at 14:51 #6197Hi to leaseholders.
If there are any leaseholders who wish to get together and get free legal advice on what to do about these capital works charges then please do email me with your email address and let us see what we can do. Spread the word and we can take it from there. Sam. Chancellors.[MANAGER adds: to respond directly to Sam please log in and use ‘Send a Message’ on left of post]
7th April 2022 at 15:53 #6200Hi Sam
we got together last year and have a whapp group of CAmden leaseholders. Some of us are also members of the Forum and currently trying to address these issues.
We had legal advice from 2 companies last year.
If you wish to join the group please email me at giuliabertoncini88@gmail.com, with name and phone number. We will add you and someone can summarize the outcome of our conversations with lawyersbest,
Giulia7th April 2022 at 22:03 #6201The process of charging huge amounts of money for Major Works lacks transparency. Camden often likes to send out masses of paperwork but when it comes to a demand for tens of thousands of pounds there is no detail, no timeline, no accountability. Truly shocking.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.