Actual Service Charge 2023-24

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #7423
    Birdsnest
    Participant

      Hi all. This web page says that “each September [Camden] send an adjustment to the estimated service charge that [leaseholders] received the previous year”, so the adjustment for 2023-24 should arrive very soon. Does anyone know whether it usually arrives near the beginning, middle or end of September? I’m expecting it will include a significant rebate for that year’s over-inflated heating charge estimate.

      #7429
      KitMid
      Participant

        Last years Actual adjustment was dated 11 September. It will probably be available to view online in the next few days. Hope you get that rebate. I won’t be holding my breath on that, but definitely on the increase in charges I’ve frequently seen in recent years.

        #7439
        Harvinho
        Participant

          I’ve just checked my invoices and I have received one dated 11th September which seems to suggest that they over charged me £964. Does anyone know how to get this money off Camden as quickly as possible?

          #7441
          MsMo
          Participant

            My account is thousands in credit due to a major works refund, when I asked for it back I was told by Leaseholder Services

            “If there is a credit on a property account the system will automatically transfer this to an outstanding invoice to clear the balance.

            This ensures that the account is maintained up to date and avoids sending refunds which are due to be returned to pay balances.”

            #7442
            Ursulahuws
            Participant

              In typical Camden Council fashion, the link to the website which should in principle tell you what these ‘actual’ charges are (https://contact.camden.gov.uk/housing) is not working. I have been trying to access it for the last week and all I get is a message that says ‘There appears to be a temporary technical problem. Please try again later. We apologise for any inconvenience. You can contact us via our support form .’
              Needless to say there is no link to this ‘support form’. I have emailed them about it but only got a standard reply that said: ‘Thank you for your enquiry. We aim to respond within 10 working days.’ 10 working days will take us to the end of the month – beyond the deadline for adjusting the payments, methinks. And that word ‘aim’ is slippery. Perhaps a letter will come in the post in the meanwhile but this is clearly NOT an efficient way of communicating with leaseholders.

              • This reply was modified 2 years, 2 months ago by Ursulahuws.
              #7440
              Anonymous

                They post the refund on to the next years SC or add it to the existing one if you are behind with payments
                You can try asking for the refund to be paid into your bank account but ….I’ve done it in the past

                #7445
                Harvinho
                Participant

                  Fantastic. When there has been an error with their system that makes them think that I might not pay their service charge on time they instantly send me a threatening e-mail, however, they’re happy for the money they owe me to sit in their account accruing interest for them for an indeterminate amount of time.

                  #7446
                  MsMo
                  Participant

                    Pretty much, my account goes further into credit each month as they agreed to my credit plan for this years service charge invoice even though it had a 0 balance, I don’t want to get used to having the service charge money. All Leaseholder Services processes are aimed at taking money, giving it back is an anathema

                    #7452
                    Polymath
                    Participant

                      Just received the actual amount for 23/24 and they’ve calculated our heating/hot water/gas as £2209.83 and though we’ve paid £3170.19 already they have asked for an additional £245.58. This seems over the top – I was expecting a rebate!!! Anyone else got similar invoices? Anything we can do to challenge this?

                      #7456
                      VR
                      Participant

                        Hi, I contacted Camden about this and it’s appalling the bill I have received. My annual estimate was £3300 and now I have been asked for a further £1500 plus £630 for major works. This is appalling! I have emailed leaseholder services for clear answers but have heard nothing back and being sent reminders to pay. My building has communal heating but we have been put on individual meters now to make it fair and I have been charged £3000 just for myself, I only have 3 radiators in a one bedroom flat. Can anyone help or advise? This is so much money essentailly another annual service charge that is being expected for me to pay.

                        #7457
                        daugs
                        Participant

                          There are legal mechanisms to challenge service charges, and a full answer is beyond what can be done here, LEASE can advise of rights, and I am not a lawyer but I have been a Camden leaseholder for over 25 years, and while my circumstances will not be the same, if I can share what I have done, that may be helpful.

                          I took legal advice over 20 years ago and was referred to my lease and the relevant legislation applicable, particularly the 1985 Act and 2002 Act. Please note I am in a street property and the “estate” is only our building, so it’s much simpler. No communal heating.

                          I sought a detailed understanding of what exactly Camden had charged and how the individual amounts were calculated. I also looked at breaches of the lease by Camden and gained understanding of how I might claim against Camden. External redecoration was long overdue. Richard Oleszewski was a Regents Park Ward councillor but no help as he was rather easily fobbed off by Council Officers. I put Camden on notice of their breaches and my right to claim equitable set off against service charges. Camden eventually filed claims in County Court for unpaid service charges before I took the matter to the Leasehold Valuation Tribunal (LVT) now Lands Tribunal which is the jurisdiction for challenging unreasonable service charges. This has happened 4 times, ie 4 separate legal claims filed in Court by Camden. The last was about 2018.

                          For each, in response to Camden’s claim for unpaid service charges I filed a Defence and Counterclaim in court. Camden then filed or should have filed a Reply (to my defence) combined with a Defence to my Counterclaim. I then filed a Reply (to Camden’s Defence to Counterclaim). Not all my cases got this far. The first 2 cases (over 15 years ago) got as far as directions hearings where I argued successfully that the cases should be stayed and transferred to LVT to consider the reasonableness of the service charges in the first instance. This was after various motions to the Court.

                          A brief word on this experience. At this point we had had to move out and lived in Hampshire. The case had been transferred from Central London County Court to Basingstoke. It was in front of a Judge. Camden turned up with 2 staff and solicitor and a Barrister. I was on my own which annoyed the Judge who thought I should have a lawyer etc but accepted I had a right to act as a litigant in person. Camden said their bit trying to keep the LVT out of it and in County Court no doubt so they could force the issue of costs etc. I argued specific points of law as to purpose of LVT and accessibility to people in an informal setting without lawyers and played on fact I was on my own etc. The Judge said it pained him to admit that I was right and according he did transfer it to the LVT. Meanwhile Camden were quite happy to tell me of their ever spiralling legal costs, to which I pointed out that legal costs fighting legal motions that they lost would hardly be considered reasonable, they should have known better.

                          My early cases were complicated by the fact we were forced to move out due to disrepair and matters escalated. In my first two cases, Camden dropped their initial claims entirely, but only just before the LVT hearing, and the court cases (now combined and transferred to Chancery Division of the High Court) just continued with my Counterclaim and Camden ultimately settled my counterclaim as well as all my legal costs after we made a Part 36 Offer. By this time the unpaid service charges were dwarfed by my alternative living costs and legal fees.

                          The third case was a negotiated settlement (with considerable write offs by Camden and some service charges paid by me) just before the directions hearing, and my 4th case again was settled before court appearances, all claims and counterclaims were withdrawn. It’s been expensive for Camden and extremely time consuming for me. I acted as a litigant in person for all of the 3rd and 4th cases. This was partly because it became clear to me and my lawyer that Camden were more than happy to engage my solicitor in endless pointless correspondence and wait for me to suffer fee fatigue as the legal costs I was incurring mounted. As I have said previously on this forum, I also became aware that Camden was happy to engage in correspondence with a position they knew had no basis in law just to try and wear me down. I was also lucky in that my legal fees in the first 2 cases had been significant, and by this time my lawyer and I knew each other quite well, so in the latter cases I acted as a litigant in person but had access to legal advice on an ad hoc basis on specific points of law but avoided the cost of having a lawyer draft a 20 page “Defence and Counterclaim” document for example. Of course the downside is that I had to draft the 20 page document, even if double spaced.

                          My experience was that Camden’s departments were very bad a talking to each other, and it was only late on in the legal process that Camden actually looked at what had been done and charged rather than just relying on departments saying they had done it properly and the service charges were reasonable. I have always made sure of my facts before filing anything in court to minimise the risk of being hit with Camden’s legal costs.

                          If service charges are not paid then my experience is that Camden do take legal action and it gets unpleasant. The alternative I was told is to get in first with a legal ruling from the LVT / Lands Tribunal that the service charges are unreasonable before Camden start the legal process, and if successful, court action by Camden is avoided. Camden also threatened me with “huge” legal fees.

                          For 23/24 I am going through my final bill from Camden on a line by line basis using the data from the online account and asking myself:

                          1) Was the repair actually done ? One item so far definitely not.

                          2) Was the repair carried out to a reasonable standard ? One item so far definitely not.

                          3) Was the cost of the repair reasonable ? this is a legal thing and may be so even it seems huge, how has it been calculated ?

                          4) Was any s20 consultation done properly in accordance with rules

                          5) When did Camden incur costs if item is old, does 18m rule apply

                          6) How have management and supervision fees been calculated, and getting a copy of the calculation from Camden

                          7) When were meter readings obtained and what were they ? while for me it’s only communal electricity, but why not check ?

                          And finally what claims do I have. Moorjani v Durban Estates 2015 in Court of Appeal makes interesting reading for “shabby” communal areas for example. Some might argue that finding claims against Camden to reduce large service charge bills is somehow unreasonable but after what Camden has put us through, I have absolutely no problem in insisting that Camden honours its legal commitments given when it signed the lease and I respond very badly to Camden’s “bully” tactics that we have experienced.

                          I appreciate all this is possibly a bit daunting, but ultimately my thinking is that I can pay or I can challenge, and the first step is a clear picture of exactly what the charges are and how have they been calculated. This is what I have done, your circumstances will be different and realistically proper advice needs to consider your situation.

                          #7458
                          VR
                          Participant

                            Daugs-oh wow, you really have gone head to head with Camden! Good on you but equally sounds like a nightmare! Honestly, I don’t know if I have it in me to go through all that, I just want simple answers but nobody is replying yet there are expecting me to pay. I always get general/vague answers and then they refer to leaseholder terms and they say I am in breech and I just want to scream at this point. They don’t take responsibly as a freeholder, our block did not have hot water for 10days and Camden just put it on us to contact GEM, basically do their job. I’ve even emailed to set up an appointment to speak to a leaseholder agent as I saw this in a leaflet included in my service charge pack but I have not had a reply. Apologies, I’m going off track now.

                            So is what you’re saying is I can hold off payment and go to LVT / Lands Tribunal that the service charges are unreasonable before Camden? How do I get advice on this, no clue where to even start. I thought about setting up a minimum payment plan until I get a clear answer but equally I don’t think I should have to do this until I get a clear answer. Had I known having the council as a freeholder was so painful, I never would have bought this flat! I’ve only had battles with Camden.

                            Thank you so much for taking the time to write this reply, I’m sure others will feel the same frustrations.

                            #7459
                            daugs
                            Participant

                              VR, I am not saying you can or cannot do anything, this will depend on specifics relating to your service charges, terms of your lease and I cannot advise on that. One thing my lawyer told me was to make sure I always paid the ground rent whatever, mine is only £10pa.

                              Not paying service charges is a breach of the lease but there may be legal arguments that can be used. The question I asked myself was what I would say when in court to defend my position. The Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 (as amended) states that a service charge is only recoverable by a landlord so far as the costs have been reasonably incurred. Also, it states that it is only recoverable if works carried out for the charge are of a reasonable standard. The reasonableness can be challenged at Lands Tribunal (was LVT). see LEASE https://www.lease-advice.org/fact-sheet/service-charges/. When I was challenged by the Judge as to why transfer to LVT, this was my answer, to seek a determination of reasonableness. It should be noted that if an unsuccessful challenge is made at LVT, then Camden could seek to recover its legal costs !

                              Completely separately, in my case I had a claim for damages against Camden for their breaches. I was very confident of the legal interpretation as I was fortunate to have got a copy of Camden’s own legal analysis for some of it at least, but any claim would need to demonstrate not only the breach but also quantify what the damages are and how do they compare to Camden’s demands. Hence the equitable set off in my case, but my annual charges are less than £1,000 pa in a street property, the big bills are the periodic redecoration/repairs. Last one was nearly £40k split between 3 flats, my share 40%.

                              But as I said before the first steps are to understand what you are being charged and what your lease says. Any estimated charges depend again on the terms of the lease. I had legal advice on this, as in my case, how Camden raise their invoices, annually with quarterly payments is not reflected by how Camden asked for the money, which was annually and what’s in my lease which refers to quarterly on account payments. I had missed this particular nuance but my barrister picked it up when he came on board for my first case, and we were refiling my defence and counterclaim document to take account of more recent events in the case.

                              s22 of The Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 (as amended) details ability to ask for supporting documentation, again the LEASE website has some info and templates. Asking for the information costs nothing.

                              As the old saying goes about eating an elephant, one bite at a time. Lots of the lawyers/barristers websites have interesting articles. Gatehouse Chambers is one and one of their articles notes “I was recently involved in LB Camden v Olaniyan and Oshibote, Central London County Court, January 2014 which concerned a leasehold property which suffered from water penetration shortly after the leaseholders exercised their right to buy. The claim settled for £40,000 which was approximately 18% of the notional market rent for the 9 year period.” Well done them.

                              The sad reality is that in many cases, using a lawyer to challenge service charges unless a group of you is not economically worthwhile as it costs as much as the disputed charges. Which is why I did most of it myself. Yes, a nightmare but the alternative was to pay some large unjustifiable bills as well as the other impact on our lives, so for us, not really an option. While Camden definitely lost at least 3 of the cases, I wouldn’t say I won, although I definitely didn’t lose. In some respects I was fortunate as the effort was spread over many years and for part of that I either had a job where I spent a lot of time travelling, mainly to US, and I did a lot on the plane or in the airport, or I wasn’t working so I had time. So again any decision is based on personal circumstances. It also depends on whether other leaseholders can or will help. I have met a number of leaseholders who have ended up accepting that they are going to pay their charges, despite concerns as they don’t have the time or resources to fight. This is fine and one of the reasons I share my story, because I fear the worst result is going through the challenge but being ill prepared or badly advised, and then losing. But it is very possible to do. It does take time and a logical mind definitely helps.

                              Feel free to send me a PM if anything specific occurs to you.

                              David

                              #7460
                              VR
                              Participant

                                Daugs, thank you so much for the information you provided and for sharing your experience. I will be in touch if needed.

                                #7463
                                CarolynM
                                Participant

                                  If you haven’t the energy for a legal battle, a first step would be to make an online complaint https://www.camden.gov.uk/en/complaints-form, then email your local councillor and copy Cllr James Slater, Associate Cabinet member for leaseholders. Include as much detail as you can on why you think the charges are unreasonable. I have received “legal” letters after querying estimated SC bills and then called them up. If you are firm, they back down on the legal action until the query is resolved.

                                Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
                                • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.