Communal gardens

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #7504
    Chouchou
    Participant

      Hi

      I have just seen my test message go up. I realise the post I sent to you about a week ago was not pending moderation. Therefore, it probably never got posted. Shame, I did not copy a copy into a Word document.

      I will keep this brief, just in case, I lose it again. Hopefully, I won’t, and I will use the forum.

      This forum has been useful to me over the years. I have gleaned so much information, which helped me to understand communal areas.

      Flat A new leaseholders have obtained half the communal garden at the back. They have half the area just under the garden (taken but not on the plan). They say, they have the communal front door hallway is on their plans (their new plans are not up on the Land Registry). The previous leaseholder thought the hallway was on their lease; it wasn’t. The garden has been a struggle since the flat was sold. Each leaseholder has built on it and tried their utmost to obstruct me from using it, for the only reason the increase the value of their flat. It has been gruelling putting up with it all.

      Personally, I try my utmost to keep out of the way of nuisance neighbours. I don’t get upset about them. Most people get nuisance neighbours sometimes. If this house had a unique private management company, things would be clear and meetings would be minuted. Sorry, to say, but over the years, I can only describe the leaseholder department as the Wild West. It seems lawless. Leaseholders of Flat A have a long the way: converted a window into a door, built a bridge to the garden, constructed a business workshop/factory/demolished original fencing, put weedkiller over flowers and shrubs etc belonging to me etc etc etc. Each new leaseholder applies for retrospective planning permission, and they get it.

      Why am I wasting your time moaning about this?

      At present, about three months ago, I applied for a lease extension as I am retiring next year, and I want to make sure my lease does not run out during my retirement. It will not increase the value of my flat. It should have been a straight forward procedure. There is a hitch. The leaseholders solicitors asked for a high price for the lease extension (usual procedure). My solicitor replied that the value of the flat did not reflect the price they were asking for. The leaseholders solicitors came back with a lower correct price for the lease extension. Now for the hitch, they sent a new plan of the communal garden at the back. They have allocated a half of it to Flat A. Nothing has been allocated to me. I have looked after the garden for about 34 years. My photos show that I had a substantial professionally made two floor children’s house (adult height) and veranda with adult chairs and a table. An extra large pool for riding on inflatable dinosaurs. On the other half of the garden, it can be seen it had a rusty old swing and weeds. It seems incredulous that I have maintained the front garden and back garden (half under duress) for numerous years. Flat A are professional at flipping properties for quick profits by upgrading them. I have to admit, they are making everything look lovely, so I do appreciate what they are doing. The half of the garden, which has been allocated to them now looks stunning.

      For my lease extension to go ahead, I have been told I have to agree to Flat A owning half the garden. My reply via my solicitor is that I should logically have the other half of the garden. There are two council rented flats, which have never used the gardens or cleaned the stairs, or taken out the rubbish; it has never bothered me. I was the first resident after the conversion. We all got on so well, and we all shared so nicely. Thanks to reading years ago on this forum, about communal areas and the ‘right to buy’ paragraph about shared communal areas, I know that I do have right of access, whereas the Wild West department are again doffing their hats to another wealthy leaseholder in Flat A by allocating to them, what they need to increase the value of the property. I can tell already that the half of the garden I am using is on their agenda to include it on their lease. It has been the same for the last three leaseholders of that flat. I am sure the Wild West will give the next Flat A or this one the half of the garden I have always used, if I do not have the garden on the plans or the right to use the garden or communal areas around the house.

      It looks like this matter will have to go the First Tribunal, as I will be in my flat after the new Flat A (moved in about 3-4 months ago) have sold/flipped it for enough money to buy a house locally. This garden issue will not go away. Greed to increase the value of Flat A regardless of who is leasing it, means constant harassment for me not to use the garden at all. By allocating half of the garden to me on the plans of the building it will ensure that, whoever is in Flat A, they will have to accept a fait a accompli, and I can have peaceful retirement days in the garden without daily harassment.

      Has anyone had a problem like this?
      Has anyone taking the Wild West to the First Tribunal?

      Kind regards,
      Frazzled Anastasia

      PS
      I do love Camden Council, I volunteer for it. I will contact the local councillor soon. Miss Frank Dobson, he helped me with a bogus bill once.

      #7515
      daugs
      Participant

        on my lease the demise of my flat has a red outline, I’m on the G and LG of a street property, and there are communal areas on the G level leading to the flats upstairs as you would expect, and also the LG floor with old historic LG entrance blocked off making a small room only accessible from outside which has the various utility meters. Both are not within the red line, all very clear. The Garden is shaded on the plan in red with an accompanying note stating in the demise of my flat. Again very clear. Since the only access to the garden is through my flat nothing else would make sense.

        I presume in your case the access to the garden is from the communal area, so it may not be clear, but I would think that if part of the garden was for the sole use of any of the flats then it should be on the various leases. On mine, it’s not clear from b&w photocopies, I have the coloured version.

        None of this stopped one of the tenants trying to gain access to the garden, and when I pointed out the lack of access they demanded rights of access through my flat. This was robustly defended and they gave up after I threatened them with legal action.

        My lease dates from 1990, its an old A type lease and even then Camden did not leave any ambiguity in my case. While I cannot advise as not a lawyer I would ask them for copy of the plan that shows the demise and seek clarification from Camden. However if the garden is not shown in your demise then it may well be communal or demised to one of the other flats.

        It is not clear from your post as to who is demanding you accept the demise of half of the garden to Flat A, if it is Camden, is this part of their negotiating to seek to resolve outstanding the issue of their demising part of the garden that was communal to another flat effectively removing it from something you enjoyed ?

        David

        PS yes, I’ve been to tribunal on service charge issues, see my other posts

        • This reply was modified 1 year, 11 months ago by daugs.
        #7519
        Chouchou
        Participant

          Hi David,

          Next door, the council put in external stairs for all flats to access the garden. This house has communal areas around the house with an external passageway and door from the front garden to the back garden.

          My new neighbours are kind and reasonable. They has vastly improved both gardens and other communal areas at their expense, so I think it is acceptable, that they have half the garden, which leads from the bridge from the window/now French doors. They are separate steps leading up to the garden for the other half.

          Please excuse me not getting back to you sooner. I kept looking for responses. I have now come on the site to see.

          My solicitor is in the process of communicating with the council.

          I have been given all the details to purchase half the garden for myself. It is an expense long-winded process, that will take 10 years to become law. The process is an ‘Adverse Possession Claim’.

          It states in my lease, that I have access to all gardens, and that the garden should be shared equally between all four flats. Camden have acknowledged this with my solicitor. As long as, this clause goes in my lease extension, my solicitor can go forward. These things take time. It does seem that there is a route, which I have mentioned.

          I will up date the post, as soon as, I know.

          As for neighbours going through your flat to access the garden, that is dangerous. It is totally crazy. It sounds more like a police matter for harassment. The police have always been supportive of me, when I have had harassment from the other leasehold flat in the past. I am grateful to have my new neighbours in Flat A. Home feels like home, at last.

        Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
        • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.