Camden Leaseholders’ Forum homepage › Discussion Board › General/Other Issues › Status of Guides
- This topic has 2 replies, 2 voices, and was last updated 3 years, 11 months ago by FlyingRider.
-
AuthorPosts
-
13th December 2022 at 18:43 #6621
Hi.
Could somebody from this forum please clarify for me what weight they might expect the standards outlined in the Guides on this site to carry?
Were they worked out in consultation with Camden? Did they sign up to be bound by them? Is there any legal basis behind their formulation? Have these standards been accepted by any other body other than this forum? Or is it all just wishful thinking?
In what way might we hope to hold Camden to these standards, if no one else has agreed to them…?
Thanks
23rd December 2022 at 10:05 #6624Dear Flying Rider, I checked with Peter Wright, Vice-Chair of CLF, who was on the CLF in 2017 when the Guides were created (before my time on the Forum). He provided the following response:
The core of ‘Flying Rider’s’ message is “In what way might we hope to hold Camden to these standards”.
The answer is that Camden is only formally bound to follow clear-cut legislation, whether an act of Parliament, statutory regulations or directions given under statute. Where there is any doubt, decisions of courts above the First-Tier Tribunal (Property Tribunal) create precedents for courts beneath them. All court decisions can be varied on appeal up to the Supreme Court. These two sources of law are constantly changing, so any advice has to be reviewed at the point it is used. In addition, of course, Camden is bound by the terms of the lease in any particular case. A number of different types of lease have been issued to right to buy leaseholders over the years, and Camden now has some 300 leaseholders in new properties on entirely different leases and this number is growing faster than new applications under the right to buy legislation. Finally, like many social landlords Camden treats leaseholders who live in their property differently in some ways to those who do not.
Camden Leaseholders’ Forum is independent of Camden Council, which is not bound by anything the Forum says, and Forum documents are not approved by Camden, apart from the minutes of the four meetings a year the Forum holds on council premises which are taken to represent a correct record of the meeting.
The guidance material published on the website represents accumulated experience over some 20 years it has existed. Experience of the issues leaseholders have raised and how they have been resolved. In some cases, they represent decisions Camden has made at a particular point in time, but without any guarantee that a situation that now arises would be dealt with in the same way, or that new law means that Camden could deal with it in the same way. It has been drawn up by resident volunteers for other residents and cannot replace qualified legal advice for any individual case.
Ultimately the decision on whether a service charge has been reasonably incurred and is a reasonable cost lives with the first-tier Tribunal mentioned above. In broad terms, Tribunal and higher decisions imply that the judiciary believe landlords are entitled to recover costs specified in leases and the onus is on the leaseholder to prove that they are not, and that the leaseholder has materially suffered as a result.
23rd December 2022 at 10:37 #6625Hi Thankyou for the very detailed response, which it sounds to me could probably be summarised as “Not in the slightest…”. In other words, the guides published here are basically “wishful thinking” to all practical intents & purposes….!
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.