Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
I’ve complained twice about excessive charges for fire safety related works and both times my complaints have been rejected (included when appealed.) I’m at a loss of what else to do. I was planning to attend Cllr Meric Apac’s drop in surgery tomorrow as it seems we don’t even have a cabinet member representing leaseholders anymore…
Is there a joint complaint we can put in about the ongoing maintenance charge which was not made clear at the time these overspecced systems were installed?
Hi everyone,
I’ve just received my service charge adjustment for 2025/26 and can see this issue hasn’t gone away.
The charges for smoke alarm testing seem to vary significantly, ranging from around £21 to £53 for what appears to be exactly the same thing. We also had two smoke alarm tests carried out just four days apart in August 2025.
Has anyone managed to get a clear answer from Camden about:
1. How often these inspections are supposed to take place?
2. Why the charges vary so much from visit to visit?My biggest concern, however, is the “Ventro Fire Alarm Monitoring Annual Charge”, which on my bill totals £313.59. This is on top of the separate charges for smoke alarm testing and maintenance visits.
Has anyone else been charged this annual monitoring fee? In total I’m being asked to pay about £650 for fire safety related work for 2025-26, not including the initial £250 charge for the installation of the eye sore in our communal hallway and other risk assessment charges billed as major works.
I’m concerned we were never told about this ongoing charge when the new fire detection systems were installed. In our block, several of us questioned whether the system was proportionate for a building of this size and repeatedly asked what impact it would have on future service charges. We never received a clear answer, and the annual monitoring charge was never mentioned.
I’d be interested to know whether other leaseholders are seeing the same charges and whether anyone has had a satisfactory explanation from Camden, and whether the ongoing monitoring charge is something we should challenge?
Thanks
- This reply was modified 2 months, 1 week ago by IzzyW.
Hi Bee,
I am in a similar situation and it is indeed stressful! I have arranged a call with the Leaseholder Advisory Service to talk through options and suggest you do the same. It seems the gov reforms have been in the works for some time and it’s unclear when any new laws might pass, so the safest option is probably to extend now rather than hope for the best. I’ll let you know if I hear anything else.
Izzy
Hi Frederick and David,
Have either of you had any luck getting clarification from Camden regarding how the inspection charges are calculated?
Looking at my service charge statement for 2023 – 2024, I can see that the three flats in our street property incurred a grand total of £584 just for communal smoke alarm checks and fire risk assessments. This is quite a staggering figure, and doesn’t include any of the installation costs for the new Grade A system, doors etc, which no doubt will run into the thousands of pounds.
Izzy
Hi Carolyn,
Very happy to share over email the various bits of correspondence I’ve had with Camden assuring me the fire safety programme of works will cost no more than £250.
I’ve also spoken to the Leaseholder Advisory Service about the charges for the Fire Safety Works. They suggested the first course of action is to make a joint formal complaint to Camden from all those affected, stating the following:
– Requirements under Section 20: if major works will exceed the sum of £250, then Camden is required by law to consult with leaseholders. If they are related works and have to be completed as a package (as we’ve been told these fire works are) then it’s one programme of work and should therefore not exceed £250 if no consultation is carried out.
– Camden themselves in correspondence with leaseholders have described the Fire Safety Works as a programme of work, which implies one set of related works.
– Cite lack of transparency around charges and use any correspondence from Camden stating the works won’t exceed £250 per leasehold property as evidence.
– Refer to the Service Charge Residential Management Code (RICS code of practice) and specifically the transparency guidance.
– Also refer to Cllr Slater’s report and the clauses related to communication and transparency.
We could also copy in Cllr Slater as leverage. If we’re not satisfied with the outcome of the formal complaint, we can then recourse to the housing ombudsman and involve Cllr Slater and local MPs.
@CarolynM do you think we should hold off until the 4 Dec CLF meeting to see if it can be resolved there?Izzy
Hi everyone. I’ve been informed that the cost of the fire safety works (replacement doors, automatic lighting in communal hallway, hideous rocket launcher aka LD2 ‘fire safety system’ connecting to the fire alarms in the flats) is not, as has been repeatedly stated by Camden, capped at £250. This is what I received by email stating that it’s only capped at £250 per contractor:
FRA works are capped at a maximum of £250 per leaseholder, per contractor. For example if contractor 1 is undertaking 3 FRA activities the charge will be £250 maximum per leaseholder. If there are other FRA works taking place at the same address by contractor 2 & 3, the leaseholder will be charged a maximum of £250 per contractor. If section 20 was applied and consultation took place the maximum leaseholder contribution would be significantly more. If these works were procured outside of capital works FRA works i.e. meter cupboards then there isn’t a cap on leaseholder contributions.
I feel grossly misled by the repeated claims of Camden staff and contractors when I’ve expressed concern about the cost of the fire safety works that “it won’t cost more than £250”. In our street property we’ve had about 4 different contractors doing different elements of all this over-specced nonsense, so I’m expecting a bill of minimum £1,000. I have also never heard of this distinction between capital works and major works which apparently also means the cap doesn’t apply.
Yet again Camden seem to be taking leaseholders for mugs thinking they can charge whatever they hell they want. I’ll be seeking legal advice from the Leaseholder Advisory Service to understand if there are legal grounds for challenge.
Once again it seems leaseholders are being used as cash cows. The same work is being proposed in our converted town house (2 leaseholder flats, one council flat in a 3 story building with one small communal hallway). I challenged the necessity of having this eye wateringly expensive ‘fire detection system’ installed from the moment we were told about it (by letter, dated 25 April.) Despite the fact our fire alarms were replaced in 2021, with leaseholders picking up the bill, apparently the fire safety inspection recommended that this new fire detection system needed to be replaced. Jeremy visited our building and confirmed that our existing alarms were in full working order and met regulatory standards, to which I responded with the obvious question – why on earth then do we need new ones, during a cost of living crisis when £250 “plus fees” is totally unaffordable for some people!
Worst of all, they didn’t conduct a Section 151 consultation asking for our views on the proposed fire safety upgrade work, and despite my numerous emails challenging the necessity of this work (citing the adequacy of the existing alarms), Jeremy is insistent on this work continuing. I have told him I’ll be writing to my local Ward Councillor to put a stop to this work going ahead, so that funds can be redirected to where they’re most needed in the borough. I recommend others do the same, or if you’d like to co-sign my letter please reply to this thread and I’ll add you as signatories. Keep fighting the good fight everyone xThanks for this – I have paid the outstanding charge as you suggested (and as advised by the Leaseholder Advisory Service), but ‘in protest’ so they know that I am continuing to pursue. Camden have now agreed to review the costs and i will try and get some like for like comparison quotes to prove that the costs are excessive. Thanks again for your help!
Thanks both for your responses – really helpful!
I’ve sent several emails to leaseholder services asking for the charges to be reviewed and to formally dispute the costs, but every response I get just says ‘this debt has now been referred to our solicitors.’ – so, so frustrating. As a wasn’t getting answers over email, I phoned the leaseholder services number yesterday, spent an hour on hold before finally getting through to someone who told me that no-one was willing to speak to me and that I should “just email”. This was even after I demanded to speak to a manager!
I am at a total loss.I’m writing to my local councillor now but the deadline for payment before I get fined a further £100 is tomorrow. I feel totally demoralised, but I will keep pushing.
Thanks again,
Izzy
-
AuthorPosts