Camden Leaseholders’ Forum homepage › Discussion Board › Service Charges › Extortionate service charges
- This topic has 111 replies, 36 voices, and was last updated 2 years, 9 months ago by checko.
-
AuthorPosts
-
11th February 2023 at 10:34 #6644
Hi everyone,
I’m being chased by Camden Council to pay £550 in service charge fees for 2021/2022, which is significantly higher than previous years. I live in a 1 bedroom flat in a renovated house with three flats in total. I requested a breakdown of costs which revealed a charge of £1920 for ‘repairs and maintenance’. From what I could make out, this charge was for installing a few fire evacuation point signs and no smoking signs, testing the fire alarms, and putting a lock on the (inaccessible) electricity meter cupboard.
Could anyone advise how I go about disputing these charges on the basis that they’re unreasonable? I’d rather not go to tribunal as I’ve heard you end up paying even more…
Any advice greatly appreciated,
Izzy
11th February 2023 at 12:15 #6647Hi Izzy,
I had the same problem, repair charges going up from £25 to over £700!! I live in a bungalow on Fletcher Court, on the Ingestre Road estate and NO repairs relevant to me were carried out during that time. I got in touch with the Leaseholder services department who gave me a very unsatisfactory response and it was only after repeated follow-ups and intervention from my local councillor that they admitted an error had been made and they credited my account with £453.08.(I wonder what would have happened if I hadn’t said anything…..I think I can guess the answer!)
So my advice is to keep on at them, find out who the local councillor for your area is and get him or her to look into it for you.Hope this helps.
Let us know how it goes
Jenny15th February 2023 at 05:10 #6648It seems to be the same every year now: when the actual service charge number is finalised it’s considerably more than the estimate. And every year I request the details for the most inflated categories, which is like pulling teeth. (Why Camden can’t simply provide this info with the final demand I don’t know. To me it seems an obvious thing to include.)
This year, as Jennifer also experienced as a fellow Fletcher Court owner, eventually we discovered an error resulting in ~£400 overcharge! This is not the first time I have discovered an error.
It’s a pain, but it pays to dig into the detail when the final bill comes in.
Stuart
16th February 2023 at 13:08 #6649Thanks both for your responses – really helpful!
I’ve sent several emails to leaseholder services asking for the charges to be reviewed and to formally dispute the costs, but every response I get just says ‘this debt has now been referred to our solicitors.’ – so, so frustrating. As a wasn’t getting answers over email, I phoned the leaseholder services number yesterday, spent an hour on hold before finally getting through to someone who told me that no-one was willing to speak to me and that I should “just email”. This was even after I demanded to speak to a manager!
I am at a total loss.I’m writing to my local councillor now but the deadline for payment before I get fined a further £100 is tomorrow. I feel totally demoralised, but I will keep pushing.
Thanks again,
Izzy
16th February 2023 at 15:44 #6650Hello Izzy
If you accept that the works to which the disputed charge relates were reasonably necessary then you should pay what you consider to be a reasonable amount as a payment on account. You are likely to be found in breach of the terms of your lease if you make no payment at all.
What you might consider to be a reasonable amount will probably depend to a large extent on what information Camden has provided to you.
It sounds as if this is a demand for Actual costs incurred, rather than estimated costs. When I receive the demand for Actual costs (in September) I always ask, straightaway for an opportunity to inspect the accounts for the charges to which the summary relates. For Major Works, I ask for a detailed breakdown and invoices. I am entitled to see this but of course Camden cannot provide it so I have an opportunity to make my own reasonable assessment and make that payment on account – pending the final account. In that case the invoiced should be placed on hold for the outstanding amount.
Do make sure to keep a careful chronological record of all communications with Camden. In you current situation, this may prove vital for your case.
16th February 2023 at 16:37 #6651Hello Izzy, as a rider to my last note – if I had made no payment at all in respect of the charge and as it is now being pursued as a debt I would now make payment in full. I would continue to investigate and to challenge the amount if it has been unreasonably incurred or not properly consulted.
17th February 2023 at 11:19 #6652Thanks for this – I have paid the outstanding charge as you suggested (and as advised by the Leaseholder Advisory Service), but ‘in protest’ so they know that I am continuing to pursue. Camden have now agreed to review the costs and i will try and get some like for like comparison quotes to prove that the costs are excessive. Thanks again for your help!
17th February 2023 at 14:43 #6653Dear Izzy, I would suggest that you also post an online complaint on this link stating that there was not adequate explanation about the higher service charges. https://www.camden.gov.uk/en/complaints-form
Even if it doesn’t change this bill, it logs this as an issue with Camden.
At CLF we have raised a general issue with Geraldine Littlechild on providing more detail on service charges so knowing about cases like this is useful.16th March 2023 at 13:31 #6731I’ve just received an eye-watering Service Charge bill for £3388.81 which is about double the previous amount. For a 3 bedroom flat in Helston on Camden Street. This is crippling in a cost of living crisis. My mortgage is more than doubling this month too, at an extra cost of £1000p/m.
Thanks for the complaints link above. I have submitted a complaint which I will copy below, but I expect that it will be ignored.
What can we do?
We are being treated as cash cows and being bled dry by Camden Council who seem to simply double our bills unjustifiably to earn money from us. These are not real costs. The cost of providing ‘services’ has not gone up that much.Here is the complaint I submitted:
SERVICE CHARGE BILL FOR FLAT 7 HELSTON NW1 1TS
The Service Charge Bill I have just received for y/e 31 March 2024 is outrageously high and I will find the payments crippling. How can such a massive hike be justified?Why is the Block Cost for Caretaking Services £6454.28? Is the caretaker being paid so much more this year? If I was to ask him, would he actually confirm that this isn’t the case? And I know that the caretaking hours were cut a few years ago which has led to neglect of our block. So why am I being billed more when there is less work being carried out?
THIS IS UNJUSTIFIABLE, particularly in a Cost of Living Crisis and with mortgage rates more than doubling.
Leaseholders cannot be treated as cash cows for Camden Council, which seems to be what is happening across the borough.Why is there a Block Charge of £431.10 for Door Entry Systems when there is NO Door Entry System in the block?
Why is there a Block Charge for Grounds/Tree Maintenance of £619.76 when there is one sad, neglected tree that has never had any maintenance? The grounds are also neglected, with rubbish and weeds everywhere and a playground that hasn’t been maintained.
Why are there charges of £2000 and £500 for Repairs and Maintenance – Block and Estate? The eye-watering Caretaker charge should cover this. I am being charged twice for a service which doesn’t seem to exist.
Why is there a Refuse Block Charge of £514? Surely rubbish collection is covered by our exorbitant Council Tax? We have an inadequate number of bins that are often overflowing, leading to vermin problems. We don’t even have recycling bins. What exactly is it that I am being charged for?
Helston is a free standing building with access directly from Camden Street. It is not physically on an estate.
So why are there Block Charges for
Estate Caretaking £2047.68?
Estate Electricity £242.23?
Estate Roads and Footpaths £274.90?
Lighting Maintenance £9.86?
Repairs and Maintenance £500?
Can you tell me, specifically what these charges are for? They do not, in any way, relate to the free-standing building of Helston which is not physically on an estate, even if it is counted as part of one on the council’s paperwork. What estate electricity am I paying for? What is being maintained on the estate on my behalf? There are no Roads and Pavements – so what roads and pavements am I being charged for? Etc, etc.In answer to what would resolve my complaint:
A seriously reduced bill over all.
Significantly reduced Caretaking charges.
Removal of all ‘Estate’ charges.
Removal of Door Entry System charge , as it doesn’t exist.
Removal of spurious Grounds/Tree maintenance as there is no maintenance and the Caretaking charge is already way too high.
removal of Refuse charge.16th March 2023 at 15:46 #6732I’ve just received an eye-watering Service Charge bill for £3388.81 which is about double the previous amount. For a 3 bedroom flat in Helston on Camden Street. This is crippling in a cost of living crisis. My mortgage is more than doubling this month too, at an extra cost of £1000p/m.
This is painful. I have also just received my service charge. It is, shockingly, £3875.26 for a ONE bedroom flat (Rodmell, Regent Square). It is almost double last year’s figure. About £2050 is for heating/hot water/gas.
On top of this, there is a demand for £3344.50 for major works as well.
I will be making further enquiries. It is good to see that overcharges have been identified.
This year, as Jennifer also experienced as a fellow Fletcher Court owner, eventually we discovered an error resulting in ~£400 overcharge! This is not the first time I have discovered an error.
16th March 2023 at 16:30 #6733Good luck with your enquiries.
Sorry to hear about your shocking bill and that you’ve been hit with a Major Works one as well.
We have to push back.
Where do they think all this extra money can come from?16th March 2023 at 18:14 #6735Just received an estimate for next year, new line items and repeat of similar items that have already been challenged. This should not be surprising given Camden’s statements at the rent setting meeting that they are seeking recovery of more from leaseholders. This would seem to include the charging of allocated overheads for contracts that are not even relevant (grounds / tree maintenance where street property and Camden don’t maintain and there are no trees!) even if amounts small. And don’t get me started on how much it costs to maintain an electricity meter. Our “switchroom” has 2 switches, one for the light and one on the electricity meter but somehow it costs £114 to maintain.
In my experience Camden are quite happy to charge even when they know uncollectibe and accept payment if paid as was the case a few years back when I showed the charges were uncollectable due to 18m rule (which meant the poor quality and over pricing no longer relevant) but my fellow leaseholder had already paid.
Has anyone had estimated capital works invoices in the last few years and know the basis of preparation. I would be interested as looking at relationship between estimates invoiced and whats on the stock condition survey?
All this means that in challenging bills ultimately everyone has to be prepared to go to Tribunal or seek transfer thereto if Camden lodge claim at County Court. The First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) considers reasonableness of service charges amongst other things.
A few years back when ACCL was active we used to have regular meetings going through how to do this. Maybe we need another similar meeting. I would be quite happy to go through my experience and share some insights if people were interested. Was any of this covered at meeting earlier this week ?
David
16th March 2023 at 18:19 #6734Same here. I just received a service charge bill for £3,813 for my one-bed flat on an estate, an increase of about £1,700 or 80% compared to last year. It appears the majority of this can be attributed to the Heating / Hot Water / Gas Supply charge. I don’t even use that much as a single person, and barely turn the heating on, but it’s gone up from £800.66 to £2,197.73 in a year. I expected some sort of rise given the crisis, but this seems arbitrary and excessive. All they’ve included is a paragraph in the homeowners’ newsletter about increased gas and electricity costs. I don’t understand how they can drop this on people in such a casual way. What can we do? Do I even bother to complain? Is there any sort of single person discount like there is with the council tax?
16th March 2023 at 18:35 #6737Per the lease, costs incurred by Camden can be recharged, and the basis is set out in the lease. However sometimes how Camden split the costs are “questionable”. Finding out what Camden has done can be challenging…..but not unrewarding.
It’s worth checking out the breakdowns in the online account for leaseholders/tenants that Camden has online. Lots of detail how repairs etc broken down by item and direct/indirect costs.
Unfortunately the legal defences that ultimately can be successful are that costs are “unreaseonable” as determined by tribunal based on quality and/or quantity and whether legally enforceable under the lease or statute eg 18 month rule under s20B(1) LTA 1985.
As to gas bills, I’d be checking out what all the various meter readings were and how costs apportioned between flats, whether flats have meters and if not working then when notified etc and why not repaired. Unfortunately where individual properties are not metered there is limited incentive if some people’s bills not based on usage for people to be mindful of wasteful behaviour.
17th March 2023 at 10:51 #6740Hi All
I have a 1 bed flat in Mutton Place. My estimated service charge for this year is £3620. Last year it was £2300. This is huge. Anyone else facing the same ? I’d like to hear from you. Is there a route to appeal ? Grateful for your reply.17th March 2023 at 11:03 #6742There is something clearly wrong with gas bills being hiked up by so much. As we can see here, the average gas bill for a UK household is £930 (annually, for a 1-2 bedroom flat). https://www.britishgas.co.uk/energy/guides/average-bill.html
The fact that they are charging in excess of £2,000 (more than double the national average) is truly extortionate and unjustifiable. If we do not do anything, then there will be no further investigation into the decisions and the incompetence behind such an assessment. It seems that no reasons have been given and this sum has simply been presented to us.
Where was the government help on energy? What is it that should have been done? Did they not bother to make such an application? If not, then we would have been left out due to negligent omission.
17th March 2023 at 12:16 #6743Hi everyone,
Really interested in Mahanprem’s comments and thorough and detailed complaints letter, speaking for all of us I think when he speaks of the exhobitant and often irrelevant charges made by Camden.
Several remarks: The £453 “error” for repairs in the actual 2022 service charges was only rectified after contesting it, as I’ve already mentioned in a previous post. Even so the total still amounts to £250, for NO repairs being carried out concerning me. And the 2023 and 2024 estimates are now back down to £25…will the actual 2023 reflect this?
And what is the justification for a £1000 hike in the bulk gas supply charges for 2024?I am still waiting for a proper clearance of the accumulating leaves and rubbish on the flat roof of my Fletcher Court property as well as a satisfactory response to my query about the responsibility for replacement of a rotted-away front gate…if the responsibility is indeed the leaseholder’s as maintained why was the gate painted green by the council some years ago just after I had painted it black myself?
I attended the online forum on Tuesday and was pleased with Geraldine Littlechild’s seeming willingness to engage with leaseholders and respond to complaints, as mails to various councillors (who I will not name) often go unanswered or responded to with platitudes.
There is a councillor’s surgery on the Ingestre Road estate tomorrow which I will attend in the hope of getting some answers to these concerns.
I would just like to add that as I am based abroad and cannot always be physically present I really appreciate the work of the forum (Caroline you are an excellent chair!) and the chance to communicate and exchange with other leaseholders.
Thanks and good luck to you all!
Jennifer
17th March 2023 at 14:29 #6745I missed the online forum. Is the best route to challenge these things still via the leaseholder services email?
That British Gas/average bill resource is great. I’ve forwarded to Camden asking why my estimated bill for 23/24 is four times as much!
Stuart
17th March 2023 at 18:02 #6744Just to add my voice to the growing crowd of outrage and concern. 2 bed flat on the Harben Road estate.
Service Charge 22/23: £2469 Service Charge 23/24: £5237
I simply can’t fund this kind of increase, and it all but makes my flat unsaleable so I can’t even get out that way, should I be forced to leave my home.
Seems I’ve just missed the last meeting but will sure be active from now on. This is a terrifying situation.
17th March 2023 at 18:03 #6746Hi
Got service charge for £9000 ,heating £7000…. That is 4 times to what I paid last year.
Send an email to leaseholders services but no response….
Barbara17th March 2023 at 18:20 #6754Similarly have just received a service charge bill for the coming year that has more than doubled, largely as a result of the gas/heating rising from £1186 to £3196! Small 2 bed flat and all the flats on the estate are fairly well insulated and south facing. No way the figure should be this high. Also concerned that the council are going to try to charge us the same amount for gas for the year just gone, when they figure out the shortfall (normally in September). Would be great if someone with a bit of experience in challenging the council could suggest the best way to do this. I would also be interested in joining any joint action being planned.
Adrian
Charlton Court Estate17th March 2023 at 19:20 #6755Strange coincidence that bills land just after the forum….
Where does the £2,500 cap fit in here?
Energy prices are falling, and may have been significantly higher when these bills were prepared. Bearing in mind this unique and desperate situation, is there any means by which we could jointly request an extraordinary ad hoc re-assessment after say 4 months? Or can we only resort to a petition of some kind?
17th March 2023 at 22:50 #6756It just needs one person to word the petition . Im in to sign it. All leaseholders will.
18th March 2023 at 05:14 #6757Good question about the price cap.
Here’s Camden’s page with the rationale:
https://www.camden.gov.uk/service-charge-insurance-and-freeholders#vmcnosuwThe estimated consumption per site for 2023/24 was calculated in the same way as previous years, by using an average consumption over the previous 2-3 years.
…
To calculate the estimated service charge for the 2023/24, we recalculated the expected outturn for the 2022/23 financial year based on two sets of prices sent to us by LASER. For the period from April 2022 to September 2022 we used the 2021/22 prices (October 2021 to September 2022) they sent us in November 2021. For the period from October 2022 to March 2023 we used the 2022/23 prices (October 2022 to September 2023) which LASER sent to us in December 2022. We then added 50% to the expected 2022/23 out turn as a means of forecasting the prices for 2023/24.
18th March 2023 at 08:33 #6758@ BILLMURRAY I am going to wtite to my local MP with a breakdown of this year and last years charges asking for an investigation. No surprises people are getting nowhere with the council directly.
18th March 2023 at 11:36 #6759Many thanks gingerbbm.
“We then added 50% to the expected 2022/23 out turn as a means of forecasting the prices for 2023/24.”
Since energy prices are falling, does anyone know an experienced solicitor who could represent leaseholders, for a fee, in seeking the Council’s removal of the 50% addition from the “expected 2022/23 out turn” and the revision of our Service Charge bills?
Or any other ideas?
18th March 2023 at 11:49 #6760Or will our Councillors (sp?) do this effectively?
18th March 2023 at 22:50 #6767Dee,
You are right.
We need to:
Contact our local MP.
Start a petition.
and…
What if we all refuse to pay until the charges are brought down to a reasonable and justifiable amount to cover the services provided?
I have not been involved in the Leaseholders Forum previously, but for those that have been…
Is this worth an emergency meeting? I will be there.19th March 2023 at 07:04 #6769Echoing what others have said about gas charges, I have been billed an estimated £2733.88 for gas, IN ADDITION TO the charges for heating/hot water/gas. I am happy to pay the latter, as I do actually use the hot water and heating, albeit sparingly. However I use no gas whatsoever! my hob and oven are both electric (and I pay separately for this via a metered supply from Octopus Energy). How can they charge this huge amount of money for a service that is not used at all? I did take this up with them in a phone call last year (when the gas charges were a bit lower) only to be told that the gas was there if I needed it and, by implication, it was my own silly fault for not using it. (in fact when I moved in, during the pandemic, there was no information available from the Council about the gas supply, nobody could tell me where the meter was – I didn’t realise there wasn’t one – and my builder couldn’t find where the supply came in. I was already aware that gas is less ‘green’ than electricity so thought it made sense to go all-electric). I am a pensioner and just did the calculation that if I add the whole of my service charges (£5142.21) to my council tax bill, this means that Camden Council is in effect taking 89.5% of my state pension! And I am still having to pay privately for electricity!
19th March 2023 at 10:28 #6770I would definitely be in favour of calling an emergency meeting -accessible to leaseholders online – and even withholding payment until Camden listens to and is willing to address our concerns. For the latter to be effective we would of course have to be a good number agreeing to do this.
Reading the list of complaints above I can see that there are many of us who might be willing to undertake some drastic action of this kind.
What do other leaseholders think? -
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.