Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Hi Martyn,
Your report of events is appalling but sadly not surprising.
I have actually moved out of my flat in camden due to the escalating costs and also due to attitudes I encountered increasingly over the years.
I did encounter one quite specific thing of bullying although it was some time ago.
It was a project officer from Camden coming into my home after me complaining about the standard of work carried out by Lakehouse.
He came in with the project manager of the firm and said that the problem was- if people complained about work it made the council
start to look at them. He went onto itemise issues in the flat which could lose me the right to the property ( tiles not fixed, linoleum
flooring ). It was very intimidating.The system of charging first and challenging later means that Camden always have the upper hand in terms of the threat to the security of your lease/home. Added to which LEASE the advisory firm have just been identified as an organisation who is doing more to arm the landlords than support the leaseholders.
Before I left I called for a Leaeseholder representative to be on every budgeting/ building/ billing decision made as the only way to have
a voice. The process of consultation is laughable and I would have thought issues of procurement would have been more carefully shared post Grenfell. But then again the whole system is about a large fragmented organisation bulldozing its way through the lives of many many individuals.Good luck with getting Keir Starmer to look into it.
I would be happy to help if I can.hi Paul,
in a previous mail I was told this:
“We changed the way we bill for major works following feedback we received from Leaseholders.”.when I questioned this the above response came.
The responses I got from camden clearly claim the change in payment arrangements for Capital Works
came from ” listening” to leaseholders.
On questioning this statement which I found very unlikely this was the response I got.I just thought it was interesting that Camden are now quoting this forum as a source of information
for their decisions.Perhaps a warning to those of us posting here too.W
Dear All,
This came back from the Assignment Team ( which is the team dealing with sales of properties ). They seem to say this forum is actually where leaseholders were calling out for paying their service charge in advance. Is there evidence of this please? Quote below.“The feedback we received from leaseholders (more often than not from the leaseholders’ forum) is that they want more regular updates about leaseholders’ liability for major works. I think it’s partly in response to cases where major works final accounts represent a big increase on the original S20 estimate. As a result, we’ve now taken the step of billing leaseholders each year for their share of any major works expenditure we expect to incur and we’ve checked that the lease allows us to do so.”
quick update. I have just been told by the Assignments Team that the decision
to bill the capital works as service charges in advance was made as leaseholders
had requested it.
I will just leave that here.Sorry to chip in. The big problem is that the repairs service does not know about the capital works service.
Therefore they don’t know whether something is under guarantee or not.
Seeing as how repairs don’t care about the cause of the issue they will never know , nor do we a lot of the time,
whether the cause was bad workmanship on the initial work or just another ongoing problem.
I have had to go to Freedom of Information to find out guarantees ( or lack of ) on for instance
a large boiler that was installed and broke within a few years but it only cost a million quid
so not to worry. I imagine the leaseholders will manage to cover some of the costs in time.wh.
Ah yes. I imagined there would be a prompt and totally sealed answer as usual.
Everything places the onus on individuals to effectively become project managers
and also understand million pound budgets which , even after having looked at a few
of them – are so complicated that I would defy anyone to have the time to do any of this
work.
I still think paying for a service can been seen as agreeing to the cost .
Here below from the government website is the section.
https://www.gov.uk/leasehold-property/service-charges-and-other-expensesDisputing a charge
You may be able to apply to a tribunal if you pay a charge and you:think it’s unreasonable
think the standard of work it relates to is unsatisfactory
don’t think you should be paying it at all
Contact Leasehold Advisory Service for advice.You can’t apply to the tribunal if:
NB THIS ONE : you’ve agreed to pay the charge
————————————————
the dispute is already being dealt with, eg by the court
you pay a fixed chargeWill then the new bills have a clause mentioning that paying does not constitute
agreeing to the bill?
I also got a message from leaseholder services saying that Camden wouldn’t necessarily
be paying in advance for the work. Meaning really that Camden are using leaseholder
money for some other purpose before the final payment.
It is notoriously near on impossible to prove bad workmanship even with the shoddiest of jobs.
Lakehouse for instance came and painted our doors when they were shut, installed unnecessary
aerials and the times I listened in to the workmen there were cases of plaster board being
put up before electrical works had been agreed. I won’t go on.
Its interesting Mike got back so quick. I wonder why?wh
dear all,
After having looked at the government website advice to leaseholders it states that if you have already agreed to the charges ( which
payment would be counted as ) then you cannot challenge wrong billing, unsatisfactory work or the need to pay the bill at the tribunal.
I have just written to Camden stating that their new idea of charging ahead of completion of work stops us being able to legally
challenge our bills or work.
They always come back with some clever answer which has been run past their lawyers I know which is why being a leaseholder for a large
bureaucracy is getting more like living in a Kafka novel but you never know.Wendy H
I read of negative affects on charges at the Kiln Estate regarding Heat Meters. I am wary of charges for one thing wrapped up in another project as there are ways of merging responsibility for costs. I am also wary when one project is rolled out across the borough as it smacks of one firm taking the same approach to really different estates.
7th October 2015 at 14:11 in reply to: External Wall Insulation – Rendering nightmare and huge bills #1895and why is camden in such a hurry?
7th October 2015 at 14:04 in reply to: External Wall Insulation – Rendering nightmare and huge bills #1894does anyone know the firm that carries out the cladding work?
get an independent quote. it is your right to do this.
i live on the holly lodge estate- my block was a trial block for work
which was done badly. subsequently other blocks got a smaller firm in
who did the work much better – and cost less. -
AuthorPosts