Birdsnest

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Birdsnest
    Participant

      Thanks Manager. That sounds reassuring. I still don’t feel I understand it as well as I would like to, despite having read everything I can find. The information linked in the Finance Team’s message is too high-level to be useful. Hopefully the draft new regulations will include a requirement to make it all a bit more transparent and publish a full annual breakdown of costs, charges and adjustments online for all heat networks.

      The fact remains that the 2023-24 heating charge for the unmetered property I have an interest in was double the national average for a property of that size. If it isn’t subsidising tenants via the heating pool, then the huge charge is likely to be a combination of a forecast price that was way too high, and the fact that residents in unmetered properties have no incentive to conserve energy, and that a lack of room thermostats make it hard for them to do so even if they wanted to. I’m glad to hear there’s an adjustment on its way in September 2024, but that will be 18 months after the huge 2023-24 charge was incurred.

      Many leasehold properties in Camden are rented out to private tenants, and some leaseholders pass their forecast heating charges on to their private tenants in full. Most private tenants won’t realise that their landlord will get an adjustment in September 2024, and those on a 1 year fixed=term contract may have moved out by the time the adjustment has been paid. If gas was being supplied, rather than heat, Ofgem’s resale rules would legally oblige landlords to pass the adjustments on. Hopefully Ofgem’s new regulations for heat networks will cover this point too.

      Birdsnest
      Participant

        With reference to my original post, someone has kindly pointed out in an offline conversation that the Jan 2024 recommendation of the Housing Scrutiny Committee was to freeze tenants’ heating charges at the same level being paid in 2023/24. It is silent on whether leaseholder heating charges would also be frozen. See paragraph 3.22 of the public report pack for 23rd Jan 2024 at https://democracy.camden.gov.uk/ieListMeetings.aspx?CommitteeId=624.

        It is not clear from the committee paper whether the frozen heating pool financial summary on page 45, and the 2024-25 heating pool charges on page 49, are applicable to leaseholders as well as tenants.

        I’ve therefore asked the site administrator to change the title of this discussion thread from a statement to a question: “Are leaseholders subsidising council tenants’ heating bills?”. More information will be needed before that question can be answered.

        This page of Camden’s website gives details of what is included in leaseholders’ heating bills: https://www.camden.gov.uk/heating-hot-water-and-gas-supply-service-charge. It doesn’t say whether subsidies and bad debt are included but, if they were, they would fall into the category of “indirect costs”.

        The fact remains that, although Camden claim to be buying heat-network energy at a discount, their 2023-24 heating charge was approximately double what an average household paid for the same sized property nationally, so something doesn’t add up!

        Another valid question that has been raised offline is – “If leaseholders are subsidising council tenants’ heating bills, should leaseholders be concerned?”. The major energy providers such as EDF, Octopus and British Gas pool the costs of bad debt and grants/subsidies to struggling households, so why shouldn’t Camden Council? The answer may lie in the ratio of leaseholders to council tenants. On my estate of interest, leaseholders are very much in a minority.

        Birdsnest
        Participant

          Thanks Patrick – I will forward the FOIs to you by email as I know there can sometimes be a lag in publishing them.

          The thing I notice from reading the scrutiny committee documents is that it can be difficult to follow which Heating Pool decisions apply to all residents and which decisions apply only to tenants. For example this paragraph is from the doc I linked to in my previous post (with my emphasis added):

          “3.20 For 2023/24, had the full price rises been passed onto residents to keep the heating pool reserve in balance, tenants on heating scales would have faced an increase of 175%. In January 2023, Cabinet recognised the significant impact this would have had on tenants and their ability to pay. As such, Cabinet decided to limit the increase to residents to 125% – by applying £3.5m of temporary credits to accounts mitigating the expected high impact to HRA reserve. It was also agreed that the heating pool deficit (created by heating charges being less than actual costs to the HRA of gas and electricity during 2022/23) would be carried forward and recovered in later years.”

          This makes it sound as if the credits were applied to all residents’ accounts, yet my FOI CAM7107 confirmed that the £3.5m of temporary credits were only applied to council tenants accounts. My suspicion is that that even the committee members making the decisions probably don’t fully understand this distinction and its potential consequences to leaseholders in the same heating pool.

          I would also like to understand how “the general policy that leaseholders pay only for their own heating costs” that you mentioned works in relation to bad debt. Appendix B of the doc I linked to in my previous post shows that 5% of the heating pool expenditure is “bad debt”. There is no distinction between council tenants’ bad debt and leaseholders’ bad debt, which implies that all of the bad debt costs are pooled.

          For context Oakshott Court (my estate of interest) has no metering, or any plans to get metering (I asked this question too), so there is no way to distinguish what an individual resident’s “own heating costs” are.

          Birdsnest
          Participant

            Patrick, fyi Appendix B on page 45 of this document gives the latest heating pool financial position as of Jan 2024: https://democracy.camden.gov.uk/documents/g10546/Public%20reports%20pack%2023rd-Jan-2024%2018.30%20Housing%20Scrutiny%20Committee.pdf?T=10.

            (Apologies for the typo in your name in my earlier post)

            Birdsnest
            Participant

              Just to add, it seems to me that if Camden supplied the properties with gas then Ofgem’s reseller rules would apply and there would need to be a clear and transparent relationship between the cost of gas and what residents pay. However, because they are re-selling “heat” instead, those rules don’t apply, and the council is free to do jiggery-pokery with the numbers. They are passing on the heat network’s cost + X, where the mysterious X is dependent on cost-of-living politics and the need to balance the books to stop the ring-fenced heating pool account going into deficit.

              • This reply was modified 2 years, 6 months ago by Birdsnest.
              Birdsnest
              Participant

                Hi Patricia. I haven’t raised it with Camden. I was really just trying to understand how the massive 2023-24 service charge was calculated, which led me to read some of the decision-making documents and put in the FOIs. At this stage the cross-subsidy is a strong suspicion, rather than a fact, and some of the information is quite difficult to follow, so I wanted to socialise it here first to see what others think and make sure I haven’t misinterpreted. It’s a bit of a jigsaw, and some of the pieces are probably still missing.
                Below are the FOI references (I don’t know if they are online yet):

                CAM7107 – Question 2: On 18th January 2023, Camden Cabinet made the following decision: “It be agreed to increase the heating pool scales by 175%, to defer repayment of the 2022/23 heating pool deficit into future years and apply credits to bring the net increase down to 125%.” This decision was in reference to a Housing Scrutiny Committee Supplementary Report 17th January 2023 which worded their recommended option as follows: “Option 3: 125% increase (175% increase with one-off credit to limit increase to 125%) The Council could take the base case of 175% increase then cap this increase temporarily for 2023/24 to a 125% increase. This would be funded by applying one-off funding of £3.5m in credits to tenants’ rent accounts.” The final sentence refers to “tenants’ rent accounts”, but not to leaseholders’ Service Charge accounts. For the avoidance of doubt, please can you confirm whether the credits were applied only to tenants’ rent accounts, or whether they were also applied to leaseholders’ service charge
                accounts?
                Answer: This decision did not apply to charges to leaseholders for heating/hot water.

                CAM7107 – Question 3: Please can you confirm whether funding for the £3.5m credit came from the Heating Pool budget or the wider HRA budget? If it came from neither, please can you tell me which budget it came from?
                Answer: £3.5m of credits were applied to rent accounts as agreed by Cabinet. As the prices of fuel dropped during the year lower than originally forecasted, it was effectively managed within the heating pool.

                The FOI with the actual numbers for Oakshott Court is CAM7138. They initially refused this request, but it went to internal review and the decision to refuse it was overturned.

                CAM7138 – For the leaseholder properties and council-tenant occupied properties respectively at Oakshott Court (NW1 1ST and NW1 1SS), please send me:
                a). Their mean average estimated property service charge for Heating/Hot Water/Gas Supply for the years ending: 31st March 2024, 31st March 2023, 31st March 2022
                b) Their mean average actual adjustment for Heating/Hot Water/Gas Supply for the same period.

                The answers are given in a mixture of formats which makes them very confusing to follow, but my interpretation for 3-bed properties in 2023-24 is:
                – Leaseholders were billed an average estimated charge of £2,880.75.
                – Council Tenants were billed an average estimated charge of 2952.04, which had a concession applied of -£536.64, bringing it down to to £2,415.40 (I said in my original post above that the concession was -£1843.40, but now that I’m looking at it again, I believe I mis-read it due to the inconsistent presentation of the tables).

                Also, those numbers are averages rather than charges for individual properties, which makes them even more difficult to interpret. The estimated heating service charge for the individual 3-bed property I have an interest in at Oakshott Court was £3659 for 2023-24, so I don’t understand why the average for all 3-bed properties is so much lower. In short, I don’t trust the figures I’ve been given, but they do seem to show that the bills for council tenants and leaseholders are being calculated differently, and that concessions are being given to council tenants from the heating pool fund, which both tenants and leaseholders contribute to.

                Another FOI request (CAM6205) gave me the following stats for Oakshott Court, but they don’t really help to untangle the average heat charges:
                There are 114 residential properties in total, of which 70 are occupied by council tenants and 44 are leased to private ownership under the Right to Buy scheme.
                There are 68 one-bed properties, 2 two-bed properties, and 44 3-bed properties.

                Birdsnest
                Participant

                  @leaseholder1 with regard to your question (i) about whether council tenants will receive any subsidy for their 2024/2025 heating charges, this extract is from the Housing Scrutiny Committee minutes from 23/1/24:
                  “Current supply gas prices (Oct 23 – Sep 24) are showing a decrease of 21.5% … but electricity prices continue to increase between 8 to 9% higher than previous contract period. The Council continues to benefit from purchasing energy at wholesale prices in advance – the Council has purchased all energy required up to September 2024 and this price is fixed. However, the Council still needs to purchase energy from October 2024 to September 2025 (six months of which falls within the 2024/25 financial year) and is therefore exposed to the ongoing price volatility for that period.
                  It is therefore recommended to freeze heating charges to tenants at the same level being paid in 2023/24 (i.e. net of credits but the charges will reset at this lower level) … This is necessary to recover the deficit incurred in previous years to the HRA reserve and to avoid a negative heating pool reserve. It is also recommended that where eligible and applicable to refund surpluses generated by residents in “Bulk gas” Heating sites so that annual charges reflect expenditure incurred on these blocks.”

                  I think the key phrase in the extract is “net of credits but the charges will reset at this lower level”. I understand this to mean that the council tenants will continue to pay the same as last year – i.e. a much lower rate than the leaseholders (who will continue to pay the same very high rate as last year). The reduction won’t be applied as a “credit” like in the previous year – they will simply be charged at a low rate. If that is the correct interpretation, then the answer to your question is ‘yes’ – council tenants will continue to be subsidised by leaseholders in 2024-25.

                  I don’t know the answer to your other questions. It might be possible to work it out by analysing more documents or by putting in another FOI request.

                  I agree that metered estates might be less exposed to this problem, especially if they are being supplied with gas rather than “heat”, because then Ofgem’s resale rules apply. Our estate is supplied with heat, and there are no current plans for it to be metered.

                  in reply to: Service Charge Credit Question #7249
                  Birdsnest
                  Participant

                    Thanks for the tip about Cllr Slater and the Housing Scrutiny Committee @CarolynM. I found his report online here: https://democracy.camden.gov.uk/documents/s116815/Cllr%20Slater%20Cabinet%20Advisor%20Report%20on%20Leaseholder%20Services.pdf. The meeting will be broadcast live and the recording will be accessible after the event too: See here: https://www.civico.net/camden/18542-Housing-Scrutiny-Committee.

                    in reply to: Extortionate service charges #7250
                    Birdsnest
                    Participant

                      For anyone interested in reading reports from Camden’s Housing Scrutiny Committee there are links to agendas an minutes here: https://democracy.camden.gov.uk/ieListMeetings.aspx?CId=624&Year=0. I’m just having a skim through myself, searching the minutes for info about the Service Charges for heating. For example, the below extract is from page 32 of the minutes of Jan 23rd 2024. Paragraph 3.20 caught my eye because it seems ambiguous about whether a ‘£3.5 million of temporary credits” applied to accounts to mitigate the increase in the 2023-24 service charge for heating was only applied to council tenants’ accounts or also to leaseholders’ accounts. I guess I’ll have to go a bit further back in time to find out more information about that.
                      <<
                      Heating Pool
                      3.19. The heating pool is a ring-fenced self-financing account within the HRA. About half of Camden’s tenanted properties and just over 40% of leasehold properties receive district-heating services and/or gas supplies from the Council. The Council’s procurement strategy for gas supplies includes buying gas in advance from the wholesale markets, to even out fluctuations in wholesale prices. This has been a successful strategy for many years, but in times of significant gas price increases driven by factors such as geopolitical uncertainty and war in Ukraine, it affects the price Camden has to pay, which in turn needs to be recovered from tenants and leaseholders.
                      3.20. For 2023/24, had the full price rises been passed onto residents to keep the heating pool reserve in balance, tenants on heating scales would have faced an increase of 175%. In January 2023, Cabinet recognised the significant weekly rental charges to residents 2023/24 2024/25 Increase 7.7% Cleaning £57.03 £61.42 £4.39 Cleaning self-contained £36.25 £39.04 £2.79 Concierge (where applicable) £90.22 £97.17 £6.95 Amenity Charge Single £17.28 £18.61 £1.33 Amenity Charge Couple £29.65 £31.93 £2.28 Amenity Charge Communal £4.54 £4.89 £0.35 Sheltered Housing Enhanced Management Charge £50.76 £54.67 £3.91 impact this would have had on tenants and their ability to pay. As such, Cabinet decided to limit the increase to residents to 125% – by applying £3.5m of temporary credits to accounts mitigating the expected high impact to HRA reserve. It was also agreed that the heating pool deficit (created by heating charges being less than actual costs to the HRA of gas and electricity during 2022/23) would be carried forward and recovered in later years.
                      3.21. Current supply gas prices (Oct 23 – Sep 24) are showing a decrease of 21.5% (or 16.5% including EBRS (Energy Bill Relief Scheme) and EBDS (Energy Bill Discount Scheme) discounts), but electricity prices continue to increase between 8 to 9% higher than previous contract period. The Council continues to benefit from purchasing energy at wholesale prices in advance – the Council has purchased all energy required up to September 2024 and this price is fixed. However, the Council still needs to purchase energy from October 2024 to September 2025 (six months of which falls within the 2024/25 financial year) and is therefore exposed to the ongoing price volatility for that period.
                      3.22. It is therefore recommended to freeze heating charges to tenants at the same level being paid in 2023/24 (i.e. net of credits but the charges will reset at this lower level) as shown in Appendix B. As an illustration, a tenant on scale A1 in a two-bedroom home on the highest heating charge level (for heating, hot water and cooking gas) would continue to pay £44.35 per week from April 2024. This is necessary to recover the deficit incurred in previous years to the HRA reserve and to avoid a negative heating pool reserve. It is also recommended that where eligible and applicable to refund surpluses generated by residents in “Bulk gas” Heating sites so that annual charges reflect expenditure incurred on these blocks. (Appendix B).
                      >>

                      in reply to: Extortionate service charges #7237
                      Birdsnest
                      Participant

                        Thanks 1Allingham. Was it a generic letter sent to all leaseholders, or personalised to you? If it was generic I’m wondering if there’s a copy online anywhere as I haven’t seen one.

                        in reply to: Extortionate service charges #7233
                        Birdsnest
                        Participant

                          … p.s. I just noticed that there is an additional quote on the second website that is relevant. As well as the relatively modest 4% increase for electricity, there seems to be a 14% DECREASE for gas!: “The price we have secured for gas is 7.3 pence/kWh, which is a decrease from 8.5 pence/kWh paid from October 2022 to September 2023”

                          in reply to: Extortionate service charges #7232
                          Birdsnest
                          Participant

                            Hi all – I was pleased to find this forum. I’m late to the party, but I’ve read through previous posts. Can anyone confirm whether or not I’m interpreting this correctly? I’m comparing two web pages:
                            1. https://www.camden.gov.uk/estimated-service-charge
                            2. https://www.camden.gov.uk/energy-costs

                            The first web page says that “To calculate the estimated service charge for the 2023/24, we recalculated the expected outturn for the 2022/23 financial year based on two sets of prices sent to us by LASER. For the period from April 2022 to September 2022 we used the 2021/22 prices (October 2021 to September 2022) they sent us in November 2021. For the period from October 2022 to March 2023 we used the 2022/23 prices (October 2022 to September 2023) which LASER sent to us in December 2022. We then added 50% to the expected 2022/23 out turn as a means of forecasting the prices for 2023/24.”
                            In simple terms, I interpret this to mean that Camden expected the energy price for 2023-24 to be 50% higher than it was for 2022-23, and charged leaseholders on this basis, yes?

                            However, the second website says: “From October 2023 to September 2024 Camden is paying 29.4 pence/kWh for electricity which is an increase from 28.3 pence/kWh from October 2022 to September 2023”.
                            This is an increase of less than 4%, i.e. much less than the 50% increase that they predicted.

                            Does this mean that Camden will almost certainly owe leaseholders a sizeable adjustment to their March 2023-2024 service charge when they do their reconciliation in September 2024?

                          Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)