Camden Leaseholders’ Forum homepage › Discussion Board › Service Charges › Extortionate service charges
- This topic has 111 replies, 36 voices, and was last updated 2 years, 9 months ago by checko.
-
AuthorPosts
-
11th June 2023 at 16:56 #7018
Hi all
I have contacted leaseholder services 6 times now to try to get them to send me the calculations they used to figure out the apportionment for my flat. They have failed to do this so far, however, the person I’m in contact with seems to have attempted the calculation himself and the figure he came up with is £700 less than what I’m actually being charged. When I questioned this he sent me the following response:
This is for the electricity consumption associated with the boiler and includes usage for pumps, boilers, pressurisation units, lighting in the boiler rooms etc.
There are 57 flats on my estate. If they’re all contributing £700 or therabouts to the electricity being used by the boiler, this would suggest that the boiler is using £30000+ worth of electricity in a year. Even taking apportionment into account a figure anywhere near this much would be ridiculous.
I would be interested to know if anyone else has asked them to actually run through the calculations for their apportionment and whether there have been similar discrepancies in the figures received.
14th June 2023 at 18:32 #7019Further progress: I have had a response from someone on Keir Starmer’s team. He mentioned in his response that the council might be considering “some form of exceptional disapplication of the utility element” in regards to the service charge. I don’t really know what that means but it sounds like a good thing and I think it is probably more likely to happen if more people contact him to complain about the service charge. The e-mail address is: keir.starmer.constituency@parliament.uk
12th September 2023 at 18:07 #7134Dear all
I have received the adjustment for my actual service charge for year ending March 2023. I understand that previously based on this Camden were planning to adjust the extortionate estimated service charge for year end March 2024. Does anyone know when this will happen?
The adjustment for year end March 2023 is more than the estimated for that year, but is reasonable given the unexpected rising energy prices. However, with the much higher estimated year end March 2024 bill it is becoming extremely difficult to make payments. This needs to be discussed as the cost of energy is coming down now and should be passed on to leaseholders. can this be discussed at the 19th September leaseholder forum meeting?15th September 2023 at 12:19 #7136I too have received an adjustment demand for year ending March 2023 – it’s £960 which is outrageous. I received a letter saying that they were reducing my service charge estimate for end March 2024 by £334 but when I log onto my account this adjustment is not there. The lack of clarity is so frustrating – how on earth can people budget? I think the amounts are criminal and I don’t understand how they expect us to be able to afford to pay this amounts. Looking at the amounts for other services again the amounts are unreasonable – please can this be discussed at the 19th September meeting – I wonder how people are able to cope with such inflated prices.
19th October 2023 at 15:30 #7154Hi everyone,
Before I pay my actual service charges for y/e March 2023 I understand from the accompanying letter from Camden that leaseholders can withhold payment of the heating element until the March 2024 income/expenditure review. So does this mean that I can deduct £780.40 (bulk gas, estimate £404)from the invoice?
I am also going to contest the repair charges of nearly £900 (the estimate was £125!) as absolutely NO repairs have ben carried out on my part of the estate as far as I can see!
Thanks for your feedback
Jenny20th October 2023 at 07:11 #7159If something is unclear in Camden’s communication I suggest that you ask Leaseholder Services to explain.
In the case of repair charges, ask to see details for the work done.30th October 2023 at 07:15 #7161Service charge doubled to £5500 per annum. This morning, for the second time in a month, we have no heating or hot water on the Harben Estate. Can’t report it online as Camden’s website has a “technical issue” AGAIN. 15 minutes so far on the “emergency” reporting hotline and still holding. Camden Council is an absolute SHAMBLES, and we deserve more than their predatory pricing and shoddy response to leaseholders.
30th November 2023 at 12:56 #7194I just received the following from my local coucillor James Slater:
Good evening,
I hope you are well.
I’m writing to you because you are a leaseholder I have had casework with and I would like to invite you to attend one of the “Listening to Leaseholders” sessions which I will be running throughout Camden this December.
This year I have been appointed as Cabinet Advisor for Improving Services to Camden Leaseholders and, as part of my report, I want to hear from leaseholders across the borough on what is going well, what could change and what needs to improve. These will guide the recommendations I make in my report to Camden Council in the spring.
I will be in attendance as well as members of Camden’s Leaseholder Services team to answer questions and hear feedback.
The sessions will be held on:
Thursday 7 December 2023 – 6:30pm-8pm – Swiss Cottage Library
Tuesday 12 December 2023 – 6:30pm-8pm – Camden Town Hall
Thursday 14 December 2023 – 6:30pm-8pm – The Greenwood Centre, Kentish Town
You must RSVP to the sessions in advance by emailing me at james.slater@camden.gov.uk – please include both your home address and which session you wish to attend. Places will be issued on a first-come, first-served basis.I hope you will be able to attend one of these sessions, and I really look forward to hearing from you – please also pass this on to any other Camden leaseholders you know. And I’m happy to answer any questions.
All the best,
JamesCouncillor James Slater
Labour & Co-operative Councillor for Kentish Town North
Cabinet Advisor on Improving Services to Camden Leaseholders and Advocating for Leaseholders
London Borough of CamdenTel: 020 7974 2792 (Casework support)
Mob: 07971 757241
Email: james.slater@camden.gov.uk
Camden Town Hall, Judd Street, London WC1H 9JEI am going to attend the session at the town Hall. I would suggest that this is a good opportunity for more of us to make our voices heard. At this point Leaseholder services are no longer responding to my requests for a breakdown of the calculation for my apportionment and an explanation of the £700 charge for electricity that makes up part of my charge.
30th November 2023 at 19:36 #7195Good evening everyone,
I also got an email from James, who I have found really helpful in intervening in any problems related to Camden’s service charges and he might be able to elicit an explanation of the charges (I pay my electricity seperately through EonNext, but did get an answer about the exhorbitant bulk gas charges).
Unfortunately I won’t be in London on any of the December dates so feedback from leaseholders attending any of the meetings would be much appreciated.Jennifer
13th December 2023 at 12:07 #7201Harvinho, were u able to attend the Leasholders discussion/meeting on 12th Dec, set up by James Slater? Wud it be possible for you to describe here what transpired and what we can (rather, may be able to) look fwd to? I was unable to attend the 12th Dec one which I wud have preferred. However, I was at the meeting on the 7th where notes regards our grievances were jotted down. Thx.
13th December 2023 at 14:03 #7203Unfortunately I’ve got flu so wasn’t able to attend. I’m going to e-mail James Slater (again) about my issues.
13th December 2023 at 19:05 #7207Hi all, was anyone at the meeting of 12th Dec organised by James Slater, who cud to explain wat happened there, and wat was discussed? Wud appreciate that… it wud help us all I think. I also intend to email my issues to James just so its easy to refer to.
26th January 2024 at 18:16 #7224I received a threatening letter from Camden today, demanding that I pay £783 that is outstanding from my 23-24 service charge. This is the exact amount I was told, by them, to withhold as a result of their having conducted a mid-year review of heating charges and an earlier decision to put a cap on management charges. Has anyone else experienced the same thing? Are these people really this incompetent or is it that they are trying to squeeze every last penny out of us?
This has incentivised me to double down on my attempts to get these extortionate charges investigated.
27th January 2024 at 13:27 #7226Hi Harvinho, I havent recd any ‘threatening letters’ from Camden about monies owed to them -at least not so far, but having checked my accounts with Camden just now I have found that I have over GBP 2000 owed to them for Hotwater and Heating (HnH) which has not (or erractically) been supplied to me for the past 3 months! Like you, I was asked to pay up only a part of the Service charges over 12 months rather than the usual 10 mths. Moreover, a major part of this Service Charge was for HnH. I’m going to wait and see what happens! My main point of contention is that either they give me HnH for which Im paying OR scrap the Communal Boiler and allow me to install my own directly from Thames Mains. Please note–for HnH not provided, their compensation is a pathetic 3.50 (or less) per day –given as ‘charity’ I presume, while they charge me an exorbitant and unaccountable sum of 300 per month.
Would love to get more feedback, and advice on how to move forward on their inefficiency and daylight robbery!7th February 2024 at 06:30 #7232Hi all – I was pleased to find this forum. I’m late to the party, but I’ve read through previous posts. Can anyone confirm whether or not I’m interpreting this correctly? I’m comparing two web pages:
1. https://www.camden.gov.uk/estimated-service-charge
2. https://www.camden.gov.uk/energy-costsThe first web page says that “To calculate the estimated service charge for the 2023/24, we recalculated the expected outturn for the 2022/23 financial year based on two sets of prices sent to us by LASER. For the period from April 2022 to September 2022 we used the 2021/22 prices (October 2021 to September 2022) they sent us in November 2021. For the period from October 2022 to March 2023 we used the 2022/23 prices (October 2022 to September 2023) which LASER sent to us in December 2022. We then added 50% to the expected 2022/23 out turn as a means of forecasting the prices for 2023/24.”
In simple terms, I interpret this to mean that Camden expected the energy price for 2023-24 to be 50% higher than it was for 2022-23, and charged leaseholders on this basis, yes?However, the second website says: “From October 2023 to September 2024 Camden is paying 29.4 pence/kWh for electricity which is an increase from 28.3 pence/kWh from October 2022 to September 2023”.
This is an increase of less than 4%, i.e. much less than the 50% increase that they predicted.Does this mean that Camden will almost certainly owe leaseholders a sizeable adjustment to their March 2023-2024 service charge when they do their reconciliation in September 2024?
7th February 2024 at 06:31 #7233… p.s. I just noticed that there is an additional quote on the second website that is relevant. As well as the relatively modest 4% increase for electricity, there seems to be a 14% DECREASE for gas!: “The price we have secured for gas is 7.3 pence/kWh, which is a decrease from 8.5 pence/kWh paid from October 2022 to September 2023”
7th February 2024 at 09:23 #7236Not sure if this is relevant but I had a letter from Camden in September saying that they were adjusting what I needed to pay in respect for heating and hot water – the amount was reduced by £330 as they had recalculated their figures due to the decrease in wholesale gas – I called Leaseholder services in January of this year and the lady confirmed this was correct so I deducted the £330 from the amount owing – although she did state that the figures may well be “revised” again – it’s all very confusing and I wonder how accurate Camden’s figures are – I think they may well err in the favour of Camden. I’m glad that I pay my service charges in instalments rather than the whole upfront as it’s virtually impossible to get funds back from the council – they will say – we will amend your forthcoming service charges which isn’t helpful if you are on a reduced income and have given them the money in good faith.
7th February 2024 at 19:22 #7237Thanks 1Allingham. Was it a generic letter sent to all leaseholders, or personalised to you? If it was generic I’m wondering if there’s a copy online anywhere as I haven’t seen one.
7th February 2024 at 21:03 #7238I also received the letter (dated August 7th). I would have thought that it would apply to all leaseholders although the letter was personalised. I don’t see why the reduction wouldn’t apply to all. 1Allingham did you withhold the amount detailed in the letter and have you recently received a letter demanding that you pay the withheld amount (if you did withhold it)?
10th February 2024 at 13:33 #7240No – I didn’t withhold the amount – I was more than happy to pay it – however, I called Leaseholder Services in December to discuss the letter I had been sent and spoke to a very helpful lady who told me I didn’t have to pay the amount stipulated in the letter and to deduct from monies owing, she said that the figures wouldn’t show on my account but at the end of the year when the charges were recalculated it would show a zero balance, no way would I withhold payment as I’d be scared that Camden would instigate proceedings against me.
18th February 2024 at 14:28 #7250For anyone interested in reading reports from Camden’s Housing Scrutiny Committee there are links to agendas an minutes here: https://democracy.camden.gov.uk/ieListMeetings.aspx?CId=624&Year=0. I’m just having a skim through myself, searching the minutes for info about the Service Charges for heating. For example, the below extract is from page 32 of the minutes of Jan 23rd 2024. Paragraph 3.20 caught my eye because it seems ambiguous about whether a ‘£3.5 million of temporary credits” applied to accounts to mitigate the increase in the 2023-24 service charge for heating was only applied to council tenants’ accounts or also to leaseholders’ accounts. I guess I’ll have to go a bit further back in time to find out more information about that.
<<
Heating Pool
3.19. The heating pool is a ring-fenced self-financing account within the HRA. About half of Camden’s tenanted properties and just over 40% of leasehold properties receive district-heating services and/or gas supplies from the Council. The Council’s procurement strategy for gas supplies includes buying gas in advance from the wholesale markets, to even out fluctuations in wholesale prices. This has been a successful strategy for many years, but in times of significant gas price increases driven by factors such as geopolitical uncertainty and war in Ukraine, it affects the price Camden has to pay, which in turn needs to be recovered from tenants and leaseholders.
3.20. For 2023/24, had the full price rises been passed onto residents to keep the heating pool reserve in balance, tenants on heating scales would have faced an increase of 175%. In January 2023, Cabinet recognised the significant weekly rental charges to residents 2023/24 2024/25 Increase 7.7% Cleaning £57.03 £61.42 £4.39 Cleaning self-contained £36.25 £39.04 £2.79 Concierge (where applicable) £90.22 £97.17 £6.95 Amenity Charge Single £17.28 £18.61 £1.33 Amenity Charge Couple £29.65 £31.93 £2.28 Amenity Charge Communal £4.54 £4.89 £0.35 Sheltered Housing Enhanced Management Charge £50.76 £54.67 £3.91 impact this would have had on tenants and their ability to pay. As such, Cabinet decided to limit the increase to residents to 125% – by applying £3.5m of temporary credits to accounts mitigating the expected high impact to HRA reserve. It was also agreed that the heating pool deficit (created by heating charges being less than actual costs to the HRA of gas and electricity during 2022/23) would be carried forward and recovered in later years.
3.21. Current supply gas prices (Oct 23 – Sep 24) are showing a decrease of 21.5% (or 16.5% including EBRS (Energy Bill Relief Scheme) and EBDS (Energy Bill Discount Scheme) discounts), but electricity prices continue to increase between 8 to 9% higher than previous contract period. The Council continues to benefit from purchasing energy at wholesale prices in advance – the Council has purchased all energy required up to September 2024 and this price is fixed. However, the Council still needs to purchase energy from October 2024 to September 2025 (six months of which falls within the 2024/25 financial year) and is therefore exposed to the ongoing price volatility for that period.
3.22. It is therefore recommended to freeze heating charges to tenants at the same level being paid in 2023/24 (i.e. net of credits but the charges will reset at this lower level) as shown in Appendix B. As an illustration, a tenant on scale A1 in a two-bedroom home on the highest heating charge level (for heating, hot water and cooking gas) would continue to pay £44.35 per week from April 2024. This is necessary to recover the deficit incurred in previous years to the HRA reserve and to avoid a negative heating pool reserve. It is also recommended that where eligible and applicable to refund surpluses generated by residents in “Bulk gas” Heating sites so that annual charges reflect expenditure incurred on these blocks. (Appendix B).
>>22nd February 2024 at 15:09 #7256Beautifully written. I will also be writing to Camden with regards to the extortionate service charge of £5400 for 23/24. It is beyond ridiculous for a 2 bedroom flat.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.