CarolynM

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 30 posts - 1 through 30 (of 51 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Replacement Associate Cabinet Member for Leaseholders #7766
    CarolynM
    Participant

      An update – CLF have been chasing Anna Wright on this all summer and received various excuses.
      We have also chased Sagal, who as leader has the power to appoint this person. She seems more focussed on advancing her own political career.
      The next CLF meeting is 23 Sep but we have had no answer as to who this person is and whether they will be attending.

      in reply to: Charges for Smoke alarm safety checks/inspections #7765
      CarolynM
      Participant

        My service charge is on the Camden Account.
        One particularly egregious charge is £336.19 pa for “Fire alarm monitoring” – this is for a small street property with two flats. The visits take 5 mins once a quarter, so this is over £84 per visit!
        This charge is on top of the £134.97 for quarterly visits by Camden to check that the corridor is empty (spoiler, it is)
        So that is £471.16 for completely unnecessary 5 min visits of which I am charged 50%
        CLF raised a concern about these multiple visits over a year ago, and have had no response, despite reminders.
        If you are seeing these charges on your bill, please raise a complaint or talk to your local councillor.
        I have queried this with leaseholder services but no response as yet.
        Can’t wait till Sagal comes canvassing to my doorstep….

        in reply to: 2025-26 estimated service charges #7764
        CarolynM
        Participant

          I have been able to view my service charges on the Camden Account.
          There are some large and completely unexpected charges which I have never been notified of before and have immediately queried – I have had no response.
          One particularly egregious charge is £336.19 pa for “Fire alarm monitoring” – this is for a small street property with two flats. The visits take 5 mins once a quarter, so this is over £84 per visit!
          This charge is on top of the £134.97 for quarterly visits by Camden to check that the corridor is empty (spoiler, it is)
          So that is £471.16 for completely unnecessary 5 min visits. of which I am charged 50%
          CLF raised a concern about these multiple visits over a year ago, and have had no response, despite reminders.
          If you are seeing these charges on your bill, please raise a complaint or talk to your local councillor.
          Camden relies on us being too busy to challenge their inflated costs.

          in reply to: Replacement Associate Cabinet Member for Leaseholders #7751
          CarolynM
          Participant

            Update – when pressed Cllr Anna Wright said that this person should be confirmed by w/c 20 July

            in reply to: Replacement Associate Cabinet Member for Leaseholders #7750
            CarolynM
            Participant

              CLF have a meeting with Cllr Anna Wright (Cabinet Member for Housing) this afternoon and this is top of my agenda. I’m sure she will want someone appointed too otherwise we keep going to her! Soon as we have a name we will share – in the meantime maybe email Anna Wright for cross-borough leaseholder issues/ your ward cllr if your specific building.

              in reply to: Claiming on Camden’s Public liability insurance #7749
              CarolynM
              Participant

                I don’t have direct experience of insurance claims, but you might want to approach your ward councillor first, with any background on your attempts to get Camden to clear the guttering. Maybe get together with other affected residents and approach councillor as a group.That might prompt some action from Camden to remedy the source of the damp – as you can’t redecorate until that is sorted.

                in reply to: Master Keys in street properties #7748
                CarolynM
                Participant

                  We had a long debate about this issue at the June CLF. Many Forum members expressed concern about security issues if the keys get passed on to subcontractors – and the risk of Camden gaining access and then charging residents for unnecessary work without prior notice.
                  It fell on deaf ears – Scot Reid is clearly just “following orders”
                  We have won one concession – that they will roll out advance text notifications of routine maintenance visits – so residents can choose to be in if they are concerned contractors will show up and cause damage or do unnecessary work.
                  Using text alerts for other repairs has improved the access rates from c75% to c95% which CLF argue removes the original rationale for master keys in the first place.
                  However Camden are still vague about how long it will take to roll this out – we heard excuses about tech priorities.
                  All we can do as individuals is raise a complaint, and then an appeal, and also go see our respective ward councillors.
                  The more complaints, the harder it is for Camden to just ignore.
                  Camden rely on people being passive, like most large organisations.
                  CLF are meeting with Cllr Anna Wright who is Cabinet member for Housing to press for a pause in the programme

                  in reply to: Housing buy back 2026 #7747
                  CarolynM
                  Participant

                    The link is here but it is closed atm as they have more interest than cash – they have to sell more properties first before they can buy.
                    https://www.camden.gov.uk/housing-buy-back
                    You could ask your local cllr to do a “member enquiry” to find out when the list will re-open

                    in reply to: Redecorating communal hallways #7727
                    CarolynM
                    Participant

                      Izzy, this seems a strange decision. It might be tempting to do the decoration work anyway. But you could try your local ward councillor to see if that gets a response. Or email camden@leaseholdersforum.org and we can forward to an officer as a generic question.

                      in reply to: Housing buy back 2026 #7726
                      CarolynM
                      Participant

                        At the CLF on Tuesday Sinead confirmed that c200 leaseholders had submitted on the buyback form.
                        Camden only replied to those they wanted to pursue so if you haven’t heard back that means they are not interested.
                        They have proceeded with c20-30 so the process works.
                        But they have paused the form as they have to sell more flats before they consider buying back.
                        I did say that it would be more polite to reply to everyone but they are unlikely to do that to historical submissions.
                        Camden prefer to buy 2-bed or 3-bed flats in purpose built blocks they already manage as they are best for families.
                        Camden are selling empty street properties as they are more complex to maintain. This raises the £ for the buy back programme.

                        CarolynM
                        Participant

                          There are some new people in leaseholder services who are at least trying to improve the systems after years of stagnation. Progress can seem slow, but we can all help keep up the pressure by raising complaints, or seeing our ward councillors, or getting involved with the Leaseholders Forum. We have vacancies for Forum members in the Camden Town and Holborn districts – email camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk if you’d like to get involved.

                          in reply to: work on front porch #7703
                          CarolynM
                          Participant

                            Are you in a street property? Are the other occupants council tenants? If so then Camden may pay part of the costs of works to communal space. Probably best to email leaseholder services.

                            in reply to: Housing buy back 2026 #7702
                            CarolynM
                            Participant

                              CLF have attempted to arrange a meeting with Sinead who heads up the asset management team to find out the proposed timescale – but as of today we haven’t had a response. We will keep trying.

                              in reply to: Short Term Letting Advice Email #7656
                              CarolynM
                              Participant

                                Several members of the CLF received a similar email, although none of us let our flat.
                                So we suspect it is a blanket email to all leaseholders.
                                We raised concerns about the tone at the CLF meeting on 3 Dec (quite forcefully)
                                Salim Khan and Sean Scott of Leaseholder Services said that it had not been sent out by their team.
                                They agreed that the wording was heavy-handed, and promised (with support from Cllr Greenwood) to find out who had sent it, as no department or named person was mentioned.

                                The facts are:
                                – you can let your flat to a long term private tenant, but you do need to notify Camden Leaseholder services, give them your tenants name and your correspondence address and pay a small fee (£25 if done online)
                                – you are not permitted to list your flat on airbnb, booking.com etc for short term holiday lets. CLF considers this reasonable as none of us want to live in a building that is being used by tourists and short term visitors.
                                What seems to have happened is that an email intended for people where Camden has evidence of short term lets was sent to all 9000 leaseholders.

                                If we get any more info we will share it here or in the CLF email newsletter.

                                CarolynM
                                Participant

                                  Dear Jennifer, Thanks for sharing the story of your letter. In the past I have had various letters threatening legal action – when I called up they usually backed down and blamed “a computer error”. Earlier this year I did receive assurance from Salim that leaseholders would not receive legal letters if they were with-holding payment because they believed there was an error on their service charge. Your case is a bit different but the principle is the same. If you can email salim.khan@camden.gov.uk to ask him to review the wording and check why it was sent out early, that would be helpful to others. Copy lorna.greenwood@camden.gov.uk and camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk sop we can track the response. Carolyn

                                  in reply to: Master Keys in street properties #7646
                                  CarolynM
                                  Participant

                                    Just wanted to share that over the weekend I heard about another case of a carpenter turning up unannounced to change the locks on a street property where a resident (in this case a council tenant and a vulnerable adult) had received no letter or call beforehand. If you hear about this happening to people you know please share as then we can prove it is not isolated incidents but a systemic failure of communication and lack of consultation.

                                    in reply to: 2025-26 estimated service charges #7571
                                    CarolynM
                                    Participant

                                      My printed estimate arrived this week in the post. Haven’t checked the online version yet.

                                      in reply to: Buying back properties #7544
                                      CarolynM
                                      Participant

                                        I am aware of one person. Obviously he has now left the CLF. But I will see if he can share some tips

                                        in reply to: Communal Fire Alarm #7485
                                        CarolynM
                                        Participant

                                          Update: I have a meeting with James Slater on Thursday. I also dug out two letters I received in April 2023 and Sep 2023 which both stated that the £250 fee was per property. Worth checking your own pile of letters from Camden.

                                          in reply to: Communal Fire Alarm #7477
                                          CarolynM
                                          Participant

                                            Hello All, I’m expecting to have a short meeting with Cllr James Slater next week (day tbc) and would be keen to be able to share (anonymised) examples of fire safety programme overcharging. Do please email me on carolynm.clf@gmail.com with details. Don’t stop complaining directly to Leaseholder services or anyone else – I just want to prove that this is widespread, not just isolated cases.
                                            @Izzyw

                                            @whkingdom


                                            @harrietg

                                            • This reply was modified 2 years ago by CarolynM.
                                            • This reply was modified 2 years ago by CarolynM.
                                            in reply to: Communal Fire Alarm #7473
                                            CarolynM
                                            Participant

                                              Hi Izzy,

                                              Agree with your suggestions. I have a handful of examples of excessive charges already and may receive more.

                                              Please email me on carolynm.clf@gmail.com and I will keep you in the loop.

                                              My plan is to compile a “dossier” of anonymised examples of overcharging, then first approach Cllr Slater who I have met a few times.

                                              If we can get his support I’d then like to raise it with Susanne Afra (Head of Capital Works) before the 4 Dec meeting. She has agreed to attend the meeting – I’d rather ask her to respond to the issue at the meeting than just confront her cold and then we won’t get a response till 2025.

                                              If 9000 leaseholders have been charged £800 each (like me) then Camden is extracting £7.2m from us for the fire safety works.

                                              • This reply was modified 2 years ago by CarolynM.
                                              in reply to: Communal Fire Alarm #7468
                                              CarolynM
                                              Participant

                                                Evening all, I’m keen to collate examples of excessive service charges to leaseholders as part of the fire safety programme. We have Susanne Afra attending the 4 Dec CLF and I want to raise this as an issue. Personally I am being charged c£750 plus 10% management fee ie c£800 for three elements of the same programme, all in a tiny corridor of a street property, zero consultation. If @IzzyW @HarrietG @WHKingdom are willing to send me their emails I can compile some cases – can anonymise if you prefer. I already have @daugs email thank you. Will also raise this with James Slater. My email is carolynm.clf@gmail.com

                                                • This reply was modified 2 years ago by CarolynM.
                                                in reply to: Actual Service Charge 2023-24 #7463
                                                CarolynM
                                                Participant

                                                  If you haven’t the energy for a legal battle, a first step would be to make an online complaint https://www.camden.gov.uk/en/complaints-form, then email your local councillor and copy Cllr James Slater, Associate Cabinet member for leaseholders. Include as much detail as you can on why you think the charges are unreasonable. I have received “legal” letters after querying estimated SC bills and then called them up. If you are firm, they back down on the legal action until the query is resolved.

                                                  in reply to: Communal Fire Alarm #7451
                                                  CarolynM
                                                  Participant

                                                    I have had a similar experience. I had an email from Susanne Afra (Head of capital works) stating that no leaseholder would pay more than £250 for all the fire safety works. However my charges (SC + MW) total c£750. If this affects other people you know please post here and then we can raise this as an issue with Camden, local councillors and the new Cllr for Leaseholders, James Slater.

                                                    in reply to: AIRBNB regulation for leaseholder flats #7393
                                                    CarolynM
                                                    Participant

                                                      Catharine, you could try one or all of the following:
                                                      – contact your Housing Officer
                                                      – make an online complaint to Camden https://www.camden.gov.uk/en/complaints-form
                                                      – email your ward councillor
                                                      As with noise, maybe keep a diary of comings and goings of different people to the flat as evidence

                                                      CarolynM
                                                      Participant

                                                        The minutes of the 28 May CLF have now been published. Below is the extract with the explanation given for the calculation of tenants and leaseholders energy bills. The person who attended said that leaseholders were not subsidising tenants.

                                                        What this does not address is the level of the charges. You rightly point out that there should be an adjustment in September for actual costs rather than estimated. If once you receive this it still looks too high/ above market rate then post here or email camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk and we can raise at future meetings with Camden officers. Also worth raising with your local councillor.

                                                        12. ENERGY
                                                        David Hart provided the Forum with some background information, advising that the issue with energy bills had come about when a leaseholder had queried whether tenants heating bills had been subsidised by leaseholders. The Leaseholder had put in a number of Freedom of Information requests to the Council, the Council’s response had appeared to alleviate those concerns.

                                                        The Leaseholder Services Manager explained that Leaseholders connected to a communal heating system received bills which included a number of items such as, gas and electricity consumption, insurance for the boiler, any ad hoc repairs and maintenance. Gas and electricity consumption was based on the actual bills received from the Energy Company for the system Leaseholders were connected to. Leaseholders did not subsidise any other heating systems or any other residents connected to the heating systems. Leaseholders paid their share of the cost of any gas, electricity and repairs used for that heating system.

                                                        Emma Cardoso (Strategic Finance Lead) explained that tenants charges were calculated in a different way and the confusion may have been due to the report she wrote to cabinet where she referred to residents rather than tenants. She informed the Forum that some tenants were connected to the district heating system who were on meters. Those tenants not on meters were part of a pool, where all the gas, electricity and some running costs were lumped together and apportioned out based on tenant’s bedroom sizes and also whether or not their system was 24 hours a day.

                                                        There were different scales which could be found at the back of the Cabinet report which explained how much they were charged.

                                                        Tenants did not get actualisation like leaseholders, once they had been given their scale, they paid according to that which was not changed until the following year.

                                                        Carolyn
                                                        Chair, CLF

                                                        in reply to: Service Charge Credit Question #7239
                                                        CarolynM
                                                        Participant

                                                          Dear @msmo I suggest you also email Cllr Slater (james.slater@camden.gov.uk) as he is submitting a report to Housing Scrutiny Committee on 22 Feb with recommendations for improving billing and services for leaseholders. You sound like a good case study of Camden demanding more £ than required and then taking months to refund credits.

                                                          in reply to: Communal Fire Alarm #7125
                                                          CarolynM
                                                          Participant

                                                            Update: Today I spoke to Jeremy Do (project manager). When pressed he said that a decision had been made “by a director” to install these over-specced fire alarms in all street properties with three or more stories (ie ground, first floor, second floor). I have asked him for documents to confirm this. Ultimately the cost, which must be more than £250, will be retrieved from us via service charges or council tax in the end.

                                                            in reply to: Communal Fire Alarm #7108
                                                            CarolynM
                                                            Participant

                                                              Hi Izzy, I have raised the issue with James Slater (councillor for leaseholders). Do get in touch as if several leaseholders have had the same experience this will help our negotiations. carolynm.clf@gmail.com

                                                              in reply to: Communal Fire Alarm #7109
                                                              CarolynM
                                                              Participant

                                                                Hi Izzy, I have raised the issue with James Slater (councillor for leaseholders). Do get in touch as if several leaseholders have had the same experience this will help our negotiations. carolynm.clf@gmail.com

                                                              Viewing 30 posts - 1 through 30 (of 51 total)