Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
I received a copy of the fire assessment which was done back in Nov 2021. They didn’t bother to talk to me or see in my flat. They have rated the building as medium risk from looking from the outside. I am challenging this. If it has happened to me and I am now being charged £00s for an overspecced fire system it could happen to others. A nice little earner for the contractors.
I have had a similar experience. I am in a street property with just two flats (me plus a tenant). I got a form letter which was clearly written more for larger properties. This was a different contractor, OpenView. They showed up one morning without bothering to contact me for an appointment and installed an enormous unit which looks like it was designed for a block of 20 flats. Also lots of very ugly piping and intrusive switches. I complained to Jeremy Do (Project Manager) and asked for a copy of the specific fire assessment for my property. No answer yet. Of course I am now being charged £250 for this monstrosity. And on top they are claiming about £290pa for the electricity and fire checks/maintenance. In the corridor, dear reader, there is just one light on a timer and an external street door light on a motion sensor. The electricity bill for my entire flat including cooker, appliances, multiple rooms (which I pay privately) is £800pa so if I am being charged 50% then that means a total cost of almost £600pa for two lights on timers and this fire panel. The approach is over-specced, and costs are just being imposed on leaseholders.
I have a flat in a Victorian street property (two flats other is a council tenant). The flat door (not the communal street door) was horrible so five years ago when I moved in I asked about replacing it. I offered to pay to replace it with a private contractor but ran into the same issues about it has to meet fire regs, so nothing happened. Then Camden said they would replace it as part of a large scale programme. This took TWO YEARS to finally happen. I was chasing via email on a fortnightly basis, but as I work full time, not calling up. The door is quite nice and a big improvement but it has taken literally years to get here. Ask LS about the schedule for rolling out the new fire doors.
Hi Jerome, the CLF email is working for me so I will cut and paste your post and send it to David, comms member.
Carolyn (CLF chair 2022/23)Dear @harvinho thanks for sharing your contacts with the Guardian re that story about communal heating. Patrick Hagopian, a Forum member who is on our energy working group, has also had some email exchanges with Alex Lawson, so you should compare motes. Email me at carolynm.clf@gmail.com and I will put you in touch with Patrick.
Carolyn (CLF Chair 2022/23)Hello all, I just had an email from Geraldine Littlechild at Leaseholder services. She said that anyone who is having difficulty paying their service charge should contact leaseholderservices@camden.gov.uk. They can send out a confidential income and expenditure form for you to return. The payment plans will be worked out individually. To date 3 leaseholders are now on 18 month payment plans. LS are currently responding to queries within 10 working days. If you don’t get a response in that time frame email CLF on camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk and we will try to help. We are all leaseholders and volunteers so we have to do this around our day jobs but it is useful to know where there are problems.
On the “heat meter” issue, we have a spreadsheet listing which estates are due to have Camden fit heat meters which (eventually) will permit leaseholders to get individualised bills. This is not a fast process but CLF do have a working group on energy pushing Camden on this. To share your story, get involved, email camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk and we will pass to the working group.
We will have a discussion on energy at the next formal CLF on 30 May – you can request a link to observe the meeting virtually from camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk
Hello, just thought I’d repeat some info shared by the Camden Leaseholders Forum earlier in this thread. The reason the energy bills are so high is because Camden is estimating what will happen to energy prices for the rest of this year. We discussed this at the last CLF meeting on 14 March and our next public meeting is 30 May – it will be on the agenda again! Email this address to get a link to observe remotely on Teams camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk
1. Payment plans – we included a summary of the options available in the latest CLF email newsletter – if you didn’t get a copy then email camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk to join the list. Basically you can spread the entire service charge over up to 12 months, and if you contact Camden leaseholder services you can negotiate a longer term for the energy portion. They are slow to respond but lodge your request and then you need only pay 1/12 of the non-energy element until you get a response.
2. Heat metering – this is a way to monitor which flats in an estate are using more or less heat. It’s available in a few estates and we have pushed Camden to let us know when it will be available for other estates. It’s not as precise as a meter but a first step. It will provide all residents an incentive to turn down their heating. We have raised this again with Glendine Shepherd (Director of Housing) and also Meric Apak. If you want to know more about how heat metering works Patrick Hagopian (on the CLF) is best placed – email the same CLF email and we can forward it.
In the meantime do please email your local councillor as this helps them pressure Camden to put more resources on answering leaseholder calls and emails. CLF are bugging them every week but this will help. If your estate has a committee chair get them to lobby your local councillor on behalf of all residents.
We are also mentioning the number of posts/emails we receive on this topic to Glendine Shepherd (Director of Housing) and Meric Apak.Carolyn (CLF Chair 2022/23)
CLF have shared info on the options and Camden’s explanation of the energy increases earlier in this thread and in the CLF email newsletter. If you are not on our mailing list contact camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk to join.
My own service charge is lower as I am in a street property and pay my energy personally. But I do have issues on the bill. I have paid a first instalment, then raised issues by email to Camdenleaseholderservices@camden.gov.uk. I made it clear I do not agree to the total. At least then you have a record, even if they take time to respond.A quick update on a couple of topics raised in this thread:
1. Payment plans – we included a summary of the options available in the latest CLF email newsletter this week – if you didn’t get a copy then email camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk to join the list. Basically you can spread the entire service charge over up to 12 months, and if you contact Camden leaseholder services you can negotiate a longer term for the energy portion. They are slow to respond but lodge your request and then you need only pay 1/12 of the non-energy element until you get a response.
2. Heat metering – this is a way to monitor which flats in an estate are using more or less heat. It’s available in a few estates and we have pushed Camden to let us know when it will be available for other estates. It’s not as precise as a meter but a first step. It will provide all residents an incentive to turn down their heating. We have raised this again with Glendine Shepherd (Director of Housing) this week and also Meric Apak. If you want to know more about how heat metering works Patrick Hagopian (on the CLF) is best placed – email the same CLF email and we can forward it.
In the meantime do please email your local councillor as this helps them pressure Camden to put more resources on answering leaseholder calls and emails. CLF are bugging them every week but this will help. If your estate has a committee chair get them to lobby your local councillor on behalf of all residents.
Carolyn (CLF Chair 2022/23)
The issue of energy price increases was discussed at length at the CLF on 14 March.
The detail of their calculations on energy is here: https://www.camden.gov.uk/service-charge-insurance-and-freeholders#vmcnosuw
Geraldine said that leaseholders should use the camdenleaseholderservices@camden.gov.uk email to request a payment plan.
The CLF summary of what was said is below. Geraldine has confirmed this is correct.
1. Leaseholders may pay the charge by 12 monthly instalments (extended from the usual 10 monthly payments)
2. Leaseholders may apply to have payment of the heating element of the estimated charge extended to a longer period, tailored to specific needs. Camden will require the leaseholder to provide details of their income and expenditure for review before deciding whether a longer repayment period will be offered.
3. Leaseholders who are on a communal heating system and who are also required to pay major works bills may apply to have the major works bill frozen, to be paid at a later time. Camden will require the leaseholder to provide details of their income and expenditure for review before deciding whether freezing a major works bill will be offered.
4. Camden will conduct a mid-year review of heating costs to see if payments might be reduced.
As you can imagine they have a large volume of calls/emails so you may have to wait.
CLF is sending out an email update next week – if you aren’t already on the email list then email camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk
Carolyn (CLF chair)
It’s not recorded. Once the minutes are published (waiting on Sola at Camden) I’ll share a link here. Carolyn (CLF Chair)
Dear Izzy, I would suggest that you also post an online complaint on this link stating that there was not adequate explanation about the higher service charges. https://www.camden.gov.uk/en/complaints-form
Even if it doesn’t change this bill, it logs this as an issue with Camden.
At CLF we have raised a general issue with Geraldine Littlechild on providing more detail on service charges so knowing about cases like this is useful.Dear Flying Rider, I checked with Peter Wright, Vice-Chair of CLF, who was on the CLF in 2017 when the Guides were created (before my time on the Forum). He provided the following response:
The core of ‘Flying Rider’s’ message is “In what way might we hope to hold Camden to these standards”.
The answer is that Camden is only formally bound to follow clear-cut legislation, whether an act of Parliament, statutory regulations or directions given under statute. Where there is any doubt, decisions of courts above the First-Tier Tribunal (Property Tribunal) create precedents for courts beneath them. All court decisions can be varied on appeal up to the Supreme Court. These two sources of law are constantly changing, so any advice has to be reviewed at the point it is used. In addition, of course, Camden is bound by the terms of the lease in any particular case. A number of different types of lease have been issued to right to buy leaseholders over the years, and Camden now has some 300 leaseholders in new properties on entirely different leases and this number is growing faster than new applications under the right to buy legislation. Finally, like many social landlords Camden treats leaseholders who live in their property differently in some ways to those who do not.
Camden Leaseholders’ Forum is independent of Camden Council, which is not bound by anything the Forum says, and Forum documents are not approved by Camden, apart from the minutes of the four meetings a year the Forum holds on council premises which are taken to represent a correct record of the meeting.
The guidance material published on the website represents accumulated experience over some 20 years it has existed. Experience of the issues leaseholders have raised and how they have been resolved. In some cases, they represent decisions Camden has made at a particular point in time, but without any guarantee that a situation that now arises would be dealt with in the same way, or that new law means that Camden could deal with it in the same way. It has been drawn up by resident volunteers for other residents and cannot replace qualified legal advice for any individual case.
Ultimately the decision on whether a service charge has been reasonably incurred and is a reasonable cost lives with the first-tier Tribunal mentioned above. In broad terms, Tribunal and higher decisions imply that the judiciary believe landlords are entitled to recover costs specified in leases and the onus is on the leaseholder to prove that they are not, and that the leaseholder has materially suffered as a result.
Thanks for sharing your experiences.
I do suggest you use the email address: leaseholderservices@camden.gov.uk
I am pressing Camden to adopt a correspondence management system that will allow them to route incoming emails to the right teams based on the query. At the moment they receive 1200-1800 emails a week and have to open each one to work out who to assign it to. This is open to human error of course. Geraldine Littlechild, head of leaseholder services is supportive as is Glendine, her Director. The current block is that Camden are appointing a Head of Digital, but I understand that person starts next week. The CLF Forum are on the case on this. There is a Forum meeting on 22 Nov and we will share any more insights after that.
Sign up to our email list via camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk for. more updates.
Carolyn (Chair of CLF)
If it is Major Works then talk to the Project Manager who managed the works about the detailed spec – they all report to Susanne Afra.
If it is service charge then Leaseholder Services should have the detail.
Here’s a link to the relevant page on the Camden website
https://www.camden.gov.uk/service-charge-insurance-and-freeholders
This is the email they quote
leaseholderservices@camden.gov.uk
By coincidence I am talking to the active head of leaseholder services this afternoon about adding more contact details to the website – will report back at the next Leaseholders Forum on 22 Nov
Just to close the loop on this I got a quote to do the work at my own cost, and did manage to get permission to replace a 1970s casement window with a high quality double glazed sash window from a FENSA contractor, despite being in the Bartholomew conservation area. It took a lot of chasing – but Carson Thompson was quite helpful in navigating the various permissions. So don’t give up hope! Window was done in July 2021 and I am delighted. Have also replaced other sash windows with double glazed like for like designs. No planning permission required for like for like (but lots of fun CC bureaucracy to deal with).
Rough stats. Extended lease from 90 years to 180. The lawyers organised all the surveyors etc within their fee. It was roughly £1500 to Anthony Gold and £1500 to Camden including their surveyor, who did come to the property. So I paid the lawyers all the costs including the premium (£8k) in one go. Low effort from my POV and I hope it makes the flat more saleable in future.
I just extended my lease on a 2 bed flat in Kentish Town. Premium £8k and total legal costs (mine and theirs) £3k. So £11k.
I used Anthony Gold solicitors/ Ian Mitchell, no complaints, all done by email, took about 6 months all told.
ipm@anthonygold.co.uk
Yes I guess you could wait for legislation but that could be several years….Slightly different type of major works, but I have a dispute with Camden and I raised an online complaint via their website which they have now upheld and reversed a rather perverse decision. I have had some success contacting Susanne Afra, new head of capital services. I haven’t yet had a demand on fire works but will contact you Christopher so I can support your efforts.
With not a little trepidation I am about to embark on an external works programme for a street property. There are five flats in the two houses involved, I am the only leaseholder in my house so liable for a proportion of cost. I have asked for a very detailed cost breakdown, and have had a long call with two people at camden going through line by line and also establishing that they will communicate with me during the works if the spec/costs change. But having read this thread I am going to keep them on a tight leash. One issue I have already raised is that in their “overheads” breakdown they included a sum of £6k to pay for use of a parking space for a site office for four months. This money of course goes back to camden – and seems excessively high. Anyone else heard of this type of charge? And is there any way the “site office” can sit in the front garden rather than in a parking space?
-
AuthorPosts