patrickhagopian

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Heating #7778
    patrickhagopian
    Participant

      Marou, I happened to see your message when logging on to the CLF site to look at its recent meeting minutes. I am a resident on the Whittington Estate and am aware that we and a number of other Camden estates are experiencing problems with their heating and hot water systems. I am not a lawyer and cannot advise you about the law (for which you would need your own professional advice) but here is my best understanding of an answer to your question: if your lease says that your apartment is on a communal heating system, you will be liable for the repair and/or replacement of the communal heating system even if you manage to disconnect from it. Depending on how you get billed for the heating/hw, you may also have to pay a share of the energy costs. If you have a heat meter (not a gas meter) your bill will be based on how much energy you use. That’s the only way in a practical sense that declaring independence would benefit you, but it may be inconsistent with your lease provisions. Many residents complain that their systems are/were much more costly in installation and repair costs, and less reliable, than an ordinary domestic combi boiler would be. Some people have asked accordingly if they can be disconnected from the communal system, but to my knowledge Camden is extremely reluctant to give such permission. Perhaps others who see your message can let us know if they know of anyone who has been allowed to disconnect. I would love to do so myself! In any event, you have plenty of company. There is an informal grouping of representatives of about half a dozen estates who have gathered to commiserate and try to see if they can adopt a common approach to heating and hot water problems. If you contact me b/c I can give you a contact (perhaps you are already represented). Patrick patrickhagopian@gmail.com

      in reply to: Gas safety certificate check #7482
      patrickhagopian
      Participant

        Hi Adeeb,

        I did gather from your original message that that was the situation, and I did cover it in my previous message: the Gas Safety Certificate covers YOUR flat, not the building, and you must provide it to your tenant if you have a gas supply and a gas installation or appliance IN YOYR FLAT. The tenant does not have a right to a certificate for the building as a whole, just the flat they are renting: or, if they do have such a right, I have never heard of it and nor does it seem does anyone from Camden you have contacted.

        Since I am here, though, let me tell you other things you will want to know if you are letting your flat to a tenant. Apologies if you already know all this (although it sounds as though you might not).

        I am not a lawyer but what follows is my best understanding of the relevant law, and is offered in good faith.

        Your obligations to your tenant and the tenants’ rights are set out in a leaflet titled “How to Rent: A Checklist for Renting in England”. You can find it on a GOV.UK website. I just found the current edition by putting the words “How to Rent” in a search engine. This is important. There is a legal obligation involved, so it is not just a checklist.

        1. You must provide a gas safety certificate produced by a Gas Safe engineer if your flat has a gas installation or appliance. (That does not apply to yours, by your account.)

        2. You must provide an Electrical Installation Condition Report (EICR), which must be produced by a qualified electrician. Unlike a Gas Safety Certificate, which must be renewed annually, an EICR has a lifetime of several years. If you have one, it will be dated and will indicate the duration of its validity, telling you when a new one is recommended.

        3. You must provide an Energy Performance Certificate.

        4. You must have made an arrangement with a recognised deposit scheme to receive and administer the tenant’s deposit and you must provide the tenant with the relevant paperwork.

        5. You must provide a copy of the leaflet itself, “How To Rent: A Checklist for Renting in England” either in hard copy or as a .pdf AS LONG AS THE TENANT HAS AGREED TO RECEIVE IT IN .PDF FORMAT. Make sure you get that agreement in writing and keep a copy.

        Depending on the terms of your lease, you may need to get your tenants to sign a “Deed of Covenant”, which assures that the tenant will abide by the terms of the lease. These days, most standard tenancy agreements include a clause that has the same effect, but that does not absolve you of the obligation to provide a Deed of Covenant if the lease says it is required. I have heard a former acting Head of Leaseholder Services complain that leaseholders subletting their properties did not go through the legal process in doing so, so Camden does not have an exact count of how many properties are sublet. Camden makes it easy to register your subtenancy on line, which may make leaseholders think that is all they are required to do. (I refer to your letting your apartment as a “subtenancy” because according to our leases, leaseholders are generally — always? — referred to as tenants.)

        I would also highly recommend getting a specialist inventory company to do a check-in inventory, and to take out landlord insurance.

        Everything from 1 to 5 are legal requirements for a landlord.

        Based on your description, I believe that the Gas Safety Certificate is not required because your flat does not have any gas appliances or a gas meter.

        Again, I am not a lawyer and you must rely on a professional for definitive legal advice.

        Happy landlording!

        Patrick

        in reply to: Gas safety certificate check #7475
        patrickhagopian
        Participant

          Hi Adeeb. Something about your message does not add up. You say you need the “gas safety certificate for my flat”. But you say that your building has no direct gas supply. Here are the discrepancies: If there is no gas supply to the building, then it follows that you have no gas supply and no gas meter in your flat. Your flat does not require a gas safety certificate. If it did, the person who would obtain the gas safety certificate for your flat is you, the leaseholder. If you had tenants, you would be required annually to have a gas safety inspection. You would contact a qualified engineer who would check your appliances and your meter and would issue you with a certificate if your flat passed. You are therefore on the wrong track for two reasons: first, your flat does not need a gas safety certificate; secondly, if it did, you are asking the wrong person: YOU would have arranged a gas safety inspection for the flat and would have obtained the certificate. You cannot obtain the gas safety certificate for your flat because it sounds like it does not exist. That would also explain why all the Camden offices you have contacted have drawn a blank. The same is true if you are in a building with gas-fired central heating. The inspection of the gas supply to the boiler room and any related equipment is nothing to do with you. You say you need the certificate “urgently”. Why? The only reason I can think of is that you want to let or sell the flat. You must follow your solicitor’s advice but it does sound like you are barking up the wrong tree. If you haven’t ever arranged for a gas safety inspection for your flat (and why would you have?) the simple answer is that your flat does not have a gas safety certificate. End of story. In case you need any more reassurance: when my flat, which is on an estate with a central gas boiler, had tenants, I used to have to get a gas safety certificate. The only things that the engineer looked at were my appliance and gas meter. I told him that the Heat Interface Unit did not have a gas supply: it receives hot water from the remote, central boiler. The HIU was therefore not something he looked at, because it had nothing to do with certifying gas safety IN THE FLAT. Best, Patrick

          patrickhagopian
          Participant

            Dear Birdsnest,

            Thank you for the helpful responses. CLF has sent a query, including one of your messages, to Camden’s Geraldine Littlechild and we’ll await a response.

            To give you my view of one of the matters you raised early on (and let me make it clear I speak now only for myself, not for the CLF or even for its Energy Working Group): “In 2023-24 council tenants were given a one-off cost of living adjustment, and therefore paid far less than leaseholders for their heating. As it is a ring-fenced account, it appears that the council tenants’ adjustment was subsidised by leaseholders.”

            I think “was subsidised” is unproven and doesn’t necessarily follow from the fact of the tenants’ discount. If Camden allowed the tenants’ contribution to the heating pool accounts (and therefore the heating pool itself) to run at a deficit, it must have been cross-subsidised somehow, but that could have been, as an extraordinary measure, by funds outside the Housing Revenue Account. Ring-fencing or not, there are lots of ways an organisation can run a deficit into the next year: it is basically an accounting exercise.

            What eventually determines who will have subsidised the tenants’ heating costs depends on who ultimately pays off the deficit. That is what will determine whether it is true that leaseholders subsidised tenants’ heating costs.

            It seems to me that if the discounted amount (hence the deficit) is allocated solely to tenants in current and future accounting, and is therefore paid off gradually through a supplementary tenants’ contribution to the heating pool account, then the issue is resolved: tenants’ heating costs would have been discounted in one year and deferred to future years’ tenant contributions. Agreed? Alternatively, as an extraordinary measure, Camden could write off the deficit using funds from outside the Housing Revenue Account. I don’t think this would be an attractive option, but it is possible at least in principle. If neither of these mechanisms is used, then the only alternative left is the conclusion you came to, perhaps prematurely: that leaseholders will retrospectively subsidise the discount that tenants were given.

            If that is all a bit complicated, it comes down to a very simple question: who will pay off the deficit that Camden ran up when it allowed tenants a discount on their heating costs?

            I am not sure that question was as posed as clearly as it might have been to Geraldine Littlechild. It is possible accordingly Geraldine Littlechild will miss the point and will simply recite truisms: the general policy that leaseholders pay only for their own heating costs. The issue is whether that principle is respected or breached in this particular case. The way to get the answer will be by asking specific questions and addressing the specific facts of the case.

            Again, as a personal view: my worry is that there are ways that a subsidy could be disguised. If we all make a higher-than-usual contribution to replenish the reserve fund, and then at some stage the reserve fund is used to wipe out the deficit, that will amount to a covert way of smuggling a leaseholder subsidy into the accounts. To avoid that obfuscation, one has to keep a laser-like focus on the question above: who pays off the deficit?

            The issue you raised gives onto a larger issue: we rely on Camden’s accounting for apportioning fair costs to everything, from heating costs to the costs of repairs and of Major Works. All of these decisions are riven by a conflict of interest. That is not just a risk; it is a fact. Camden is the accountant and we hope it behaves as an honest broker, but it is also one of the parties that has to pay whatever costs are not met by leaseholders. It has a clear — and legitimate — interest to collect every penny that can be fairly attributed to leaseholders but it also has a duty not to collect a penny more than that. It is therefore vital that the accounting processes be honest and transparent, and that leaseholders and their local and borough-wide organisations keep Camden honest. We have an equally clear and legitimate interest in demanding accountability. Careful scrutiny like the exercise you have performed is vital for that purpose.

            patrickhagopian
            Participant

              I am a member of the Camden Leaseholders Forum Energy Working Group and I am concerned about the issue that you raised. We (myself and the other member of the group) are currently having an internal discussion trying to work through your argument and evidence. May I ask @birdnest: have you raised the matter directly with Camden? If so, would you be willing to share the exchange of messages with me at patrickhagopian@gmail.com ? If you do contact Camden in future, please feel free to cc the message to me.

              If, however, the CLF decides after our deliberations to contact Camden ourselves, would you give us permission to copy (anonymously) the meat of your message to them: the part that concerns the Cabinet decisions of January and the two-line conclusion that leaseholders appear to be subsidising tenants? I’ll also take a look at the FOI request and response before doing anything.

              It may actually be more constructive for you to address Camden directly, since you seem to be on top of the subject and probably better able than anyone to engage in further dialogue if one develops, but this is also a matter of general concern to many leaseholders. My thought is that Camden might say that only tenants are going to repay the deficit created by the subsidy, if that is true. That seems to be the only mechanism that would mean that your suspicion about the subsidy is wrong. But that seems to me, on its face, to be at odds with your evidence. It does seem worth challenging Camden to explain just how the deficit will be repaid and by whom.

              Can we have a b/c conversation?

              Thanks, Patrick Hagopian, vice chair of the CLF (for another three weeks).

              in reply to: Water Stop Cock Location #7049
              patrickhagopian
              Participant

                In similar circumstances, my kitchen fitter FROZE the water supply coming into the kitchen. Ask your plumber what this means. They will know what you are asking about.

                in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6978
                patrickhagopian
                Participant

                  As Carolyn said yesterday, I have been looking into the heat meter issue as a member of the CLF energy working group. I will be happy to address any questions that members bring up, whether on the discussion board or addressed to me at patrickhagopian@gmail.com. If I can’t answer a question I will try to refer it on to the appropriate quarter.

                  Please note that no one believes that the adoption of individual charging through heat meters is the solution to the very high energy costs now in leaseholders’ Service Charges. Actually, it probably works the other way round: because of the high energy costs we are being charged, residents have had new reason to gain control over their personal energy costs, as well as conserving energy. Camden has told my local association that the vast majority of those individually charged through heat meters use less energy (and save money) as a result. On my estate leaseholders have told me they are very keen to have their heat meters activated and for individual charging to begin for that reason. They have also told me of their frustration: it looks as though under Camden’s stated procedures, it may take a very long time for individual charging to start, for reasons that we can address in the discussion, if there is any interest in the topic.

                  I don’t want this to be a monologue, though: I want to hear from leaseholders about your concerns and experiences — and also to get your answers to some questions. The first question for you: do you have a meter installed but before it was/is activated, you were told your Heat Interface Unit requires/d an “upgrade” (or something similar)? Or were you given a specific reason that something needed to be done before the heat meter could be activated? A second question: have you experienced any contractor-related delays or postponements in the activation of your heat meter?

                  I won’t say more now in order not to influence responses, but I’ll be happy to explain the context and reason for these questions if any replies follow. Please post responses to the board or directly to my email address.

                  Manager: perhaps if any heat meter-related messages come in, we might establish a new thread with heat meters as the topic?

                  Thanks! Patrick Hagopian, CLF Member

                Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)