Extortionate service charges

Viewing 30 posts - 61 through 90 (of 112 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #6917
    Andy
    Participant

      I emailed my local councillor Will Prince, who replied very promptly. Not much information we didn’t already know, but I’ve pasted it below in the hope it might help others. I thought the longest paragraph (the 4th) was particularly interesting regarding heat metering.
      I’m wondering whether there should be an option to opt out of the heating/hot water scheme altogether and install a boiler in my flat – which I’m pretty sure I could do for less than the cost of this year’s service charge!

      Will’s reply:

      You are not the first to have raised this issue and we are in the process of looking at available options. As a first port of call I would recommend exploring Camden’s cost of living crisis fund, details of which can be found here.

      As a longer run solution, I am trying to find out what payment terms might be available for leaseholders over a longer period of time. As soon as one of us has an update on this, we can come back to you.

      The increase in the heating charge is just the knock-on effect of heating prices that spiked around this time last year. Camden procures its energy from a syndicate which Camden pays in arrears. The service charge heating cost that residents are receiving now is for the period Sep-21 through Oct-22, so there is a slight lag in the billing relative to the spike in prices.

      Unfortunately, unmetered heating systems on (older) Camden estates are quite common and clearly were designed at a time with a very different approach to energy efficiency. This ends up meaning, as it appears you have realised, that residents realistically have no incentive to reduce their heating usage as all costs are split equally. There is no obvious easy option for Camden to pursue on this. Installing meters would be highly costly and would come in the context of other historical costly large works on estates (including Harben Rd) that have received pushback from leaseholders: alternatively forced shutdowns during periods of the day have been discussed but obviously this presents its own issues. I realise this is totally energy inefficient but it is the situation we find ourselves in.

      Specifically, re: the apportionment of the cost, your share of the heating cost should be (roughly) an equal split of the building/estate as a whole. I think it is allocated by the proportion of the floor area, so won’t be exactly one 54th (for example, assuming 54 flats) of the total amount, but will be approximately around that as the most of the flats will have the same footprint.

      We are monitoring the situation closely and the good news (as things stand) is that wholesale gas prices are coming down to a degree that next year’s service charge should be significantly cheaper than this year (subject to prices remaining low for the rest of the procurement period up to September this year).

      I’ll be back with an update as and when we have more.

      #6925
      billmurray
      Participant

        Yes, this is definitely the point where we extract the right to put in our own electric or gas hot water/heating systems. Perhaps Camden could be permitted to keep a central heating pipe going through a flat en route elsewhere, with radiators removed. Or they could remove the pipe at their expense…
        Best,
        Bill

        #6928
        CarolynM
        Participant

          A quick update on a couple of topics raised in this thread:

          1. Payment plans – we included a summary of the options available in the latest CLF email newsletter this week – if you didn’t get a copy then email camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk to join the list. Basically you can spread the entire service charge over up to 12 months, and if you contact Camden leaseholder services you can negotiate a longer term for the energy portion. They are slow to respond but lodge your request and then you need only pay 1/12 of the non-energy element until you get a response.

          2. Heat metering – this is a way to monitor which flats in an estate are using more or less heat. It’s available in a few estates and we have pushed Camden to let us know when it will be available for other estates. It’s not as precise as a meter but a first step. It will provide all residents an incentive to turn down their heating. We have raised this again with Glendine Shepherd (Director of Housing) this week and also Meric Apak. If you want to know more about how heat metering works Patrick Hagopian (on the CLF) is best placed – email the same CLF email and we can forward it.

          In the meantime do please email your local councillor as this helps them pressure Camden to put more resources on answering leaseholder calls and emails. CLF are bugging them every week but this will help. If your estate has a committee chair get them to lobby your local councillor on behalf of all residents.

          Carolyn (CLF Chair 2022/23)

          #6929
          MsMo
          Participant

            In my opinion the option to pay over 12 months has not been communicated early enough, I have taken advantage as I heard about it here but the first payment needed to be there today, it took 3 calls and a total of 2 hours on hold to get through. Having heard in various leaseholder forum meetings how inadequate Leaseholder Services email system is I would not have trusted them to answer in time.

            With regards to heat meters, the 2 blocks on our estate have a ‘bulk gas supply’ but we have separate boilers in each flat so can determine our own usage but we all just get charged the one amount. We would be prime candidates for heat meters as the flats are less then 50 years old and each controls it’s own consumption but this is the first I’ve ever heard about it. Thames Water installed a water meter.

            • This reply was modified 3 years, 7 months ago by MsMo.
            #6932
            billmurray
            Participant

              I don’t know how these things work, but can we get Council agreement at the next Leaseholder Meeting to the proposal that we have the right to opt out of communal hot water/heating systems in favour of our own properly fitted electric systems? Perhaps Camden could be permitted to keep a central heating pipe going through a flat en route elsewhere, with radiators removed. Or they could remove the pipe at their expense.

              Anyone got any ideas how to secure this right?

              Best,
              Bill

              #6934
              jennifer
              Participant

                Hi,
                I was just wondering if anyone has actually paid their March service charge estimate yet? How long before we get a final reminder and/or a penalty?
                Thanks for your feedback

                #6931
                Traveller23
                Participant

                  Thank you all for your contributions to the Forum, I’m a new joiner also based at Charlton Court Brecknock Road. On writing to Leaseholder Services to complain about the staggering increase in service charge from overall estimated £2467 in 2022 to £5654 in 2023 I was told that it is largely attributable to increase in energy prices to the tune of 318%, mentioned as if it were a small amount, with an offer to delay payment for 12 months. I don’t understand why a suggestion of spiralling debt by Leaseholder Services is seen as a viable remedy. As mentioned by Harvinho, energy fee increase is not the only excessive cost. Newly proposed fees are simply not supportable nor sustainable, not if I am to remain in my home. I will be sure to attend the next meeting.

                  #6940
                  CarolynM
                  Participant

                    CLF have shared info on the options and Camden’s explanation of the energy increases earlier in this thread and in the CLF email newsletter. If you are not on our mailing list contact camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk to join.
                    My own service charge is lower as I am in a street property and pay my energy personally. But I do have issues on the bill. I have paid a first instalment, then raised issues by email to Camdenleaseholderservices@camden.gov.uk. I made it clear I do not agree to the total. At least then you have a record, even if they take time to respond.

                    #6942
                    Leaseholder1
                    Participant

                      @CarolynM Thank you for your message. Is there any significance in just paying the first instalment? Does that in some way mitigate the risk of Camden trying to sue you for the whole amount in one go, if you object to the amount of the requested payment? Thank you.

                      #6944
                      daugs
                      Participant

                        In response to my post and Bill’s question (apologies for the delay) re 18 month rule

                        Under Section 20B of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, a landlord has 18 months within which to notify you of service charge costs being incurred or demand payment from you. If they fail to either notify you or demand payment within 18 months they will not be able to recover the charges from you. There are various rules for the information required in the notification.

                        #6945
                        daugs
                        Participant

                          In relation to the metering programme and questions raised at DMC meetings, just received an email from Camden as follows

                          “Dear DMC rep

                          At a recent DMC round of meeting there was a request for our Capital Work Team to share with you information on the Heat Meter Programme. Attached is a spreadsheet which lists all the properties that either have heat meters or will receive them in the near future. Many of you may ask why certain blocks are or aren’t included in the programme – below is an explanation.

                          1. Why are certain estates selected over any other properties and what was the selection criteria?

                          Camden began its heat metering retrofit programme in 2009 at Kiln Place, followed by other sites in later years (known internally as Phase 1, Phase 2 and Phase 3 sites). The heat meters in these phases of the programme were retrofitted in two stages – first a meter installation by a general contractor, and second the connection of the meter communications by a specialist heat metering engineer to get the resident’s heat data to Camden’s systems for charging purposes. This informed our retrofit programme content and order up until 2020 as the meters had been fitted in resident’s homes so we wanted to connect them up.

                          These phases covered certain homes and blocks at the following estates: Chalcots, Kiln Place, Ampthill, Henderson Court, Kenbrook, Kennistoun, Snowman, Casterbridge, Churchway, Doric, Hampstead Rd (partial), North Gower, George Mews, Mary Green, Hastings House, Penshurst, Rothay, Waxham, Ludham, Una House, Templar House, Seymour House, Somers Close, Platt St, Purchese St, Constable House, Tolmer Sq. We are currently approaching the end of Phase 3.

                          In addition during these years we retrofitted meters as part of several Capital Works projects (where an estate was having a bigger heating upgrade) and also for regeneration projects so the meters were fitted as part of the new build development. These estates were: Bacton, Bourne, Netley, Maiden Lane, Agar Grove, Regents Park, Abbey, Chester Balmore, Holly Lodge, Central Somers Town, Charlie Ratchford, Harben Road, Monica Shaw and Mansfield Road. These works are currently underway at St Silas, Highgate Newtown and Maitland Park.

                          The Heat Network (Metering and Billing) Regulations 2014 required us to meter homes where technically and financially viable, but the government put their tool for assessing viability on hold for several years while they redesigned the tool so it was fit for purpose. In the meantime we continued with the above phases of our heat metering programme.

                          The Heat Metering Regulations were amended in 2020 and a new cost effectiveness tool published. We applied the tool to all the remaining homes on our heat network, with the result that 157 homes still needed to be metered. The rest were either exempt from metering under the Regulations (including Camelot House) or deemed not cost effective through the tool.

                          These 157 homes are going to be prioritised under the next phase of our heat metering programme (Phase 4) as they are the ones we are legally required to meter. These are certain homes at Sanderson Close, Cressfield and Woodyard Estate, Lymington Road Estate, Netherwood Estate and Bacton Estate. This part of the programme is in procurement phase and we intend to do the meter installs later this year.

                          We still have plans to meter as many other homes on our heat network as possible, including those we are not legally required to meter. However the speed of the rest of the programme will depend on budget, resource, supplier constraints and resident access issues. We may also decide to change our retrofit approach and install meters as part of bigger heating upgrades as estates, rather than as standalone work. These are all decisions that will be made in the future by senior management.

                          It should be noted that for all residents in a block / estate to switch to heat meters we require at least 70% take up otherwise we can’t switch residents over to this new way of billing.

                          Kind regards”

                          #6953
                          Vigil
                          Participant

                            I think the sooner we can meet up to discuss this issue and resolve it, the better. Its not just about the service charges but also the exorbitant hotwater/heating and gas charges. I have paid under duress –AND decided to pay via a 12 monthly rate– the first payment. I have also sent emails of complaint to Camden, and the Leaseholder centre for help and advice. I dont expect a prompt response so its important to get together and use other means to get justice as soon as possible. Keeping my service charges aside, I’m shocked to see a hike of over 300% for my hotwater/heating (I dont get any gas supply from Camden), while i pay separately for my elec and gas consumption. My hotwater heating bill (no gas included) was £1316 for the year 2022 to 23, and the new estimate now for 23-24 is £4316! A hike of over 300%! Either Camden thinks they are smart and will get away with this with their poor accounting and maths calculation, or they think we are stupid enough to accept their arbitrary billing.
                            In addition. and even more important is to sort out the issue of having our own hotwater heating and/or gas system in place so we can take back control– for our usage and expense!

                            #6958
                            Harvinho
                            Participant

                              I agree with the last poster. With the amount that we are all going to be forking out every month the sooner we can meet and try to get this resolved the better.
                              After waiting for several weeks for a response from the Camden leaseholders forum they sent me another reply in which they didn’t answer any of my questions and stated that they have sent my enquiries to other departments. One piece of information that they sent that is fairly helpful is the estimated gas use for the coming year for my estate (and the estimates for the previous 2 years – impossible to get the actual usage figures for 2021/22 out of them). They estimate that the estate is going to use 1,059,638 kWh of gas in the coming year, which when divided by 57 (the number of flats on my estate – Charlton Court) gives a figure of 18,590 kwh per flat. I haven’t taken into account apportionment because Camden aren’t able to clearly explain how it works but being a small 2 bed, my flat is around average for the estate. 18,590 kwh at a rate of 8.53 pence per kwh (the price Camden has paid for gas means that I should be paying £1585 for gas not the £3196 they have charged me. Leaseholder services sent me a breakdown of costs for 21/22 and in that year there were £500 worth of maintenance costs per flat for the heating/gas/hot water systems (which is incredibly high and there does seem to have been a lot of repair work done to the gas/heating/hot water infrastructure that year). Adding that figure to the figure I should be paying for gas still leaves a £1000 discrepancy between what they are charging me and what the costs should be. It is worth also considering that 18,590 kwh of gas is more than the average use for a four bedroom house according to Ofgem.


                              @Traveller23
                              : Good to see another Charlton Court resident on here. Do you know if there is or has ever been a residents association for the estate?

                              #6959
                              daugs
                              Participant

                                Harvinho, you could try an FOI for the meter readings taken and the calculation of the final charge for 21/22 included in the service charge adjustment invoice in September 2022. Also were these certified by a Camden officer (mine were) and in which case, how if they don’t know the actual readings unless estimates ? but when were last readings ?

                                #6960
                                amon
                                Participant

                                  hi all, this is day light robbery and its great to see we are all standing up to this day light robbery from camden !!! i wrote to my local councillor and she made contact with leaseholder services and below is there response which was forwarded to me by my local councillor. The response from leaseholder is in inadequate. my property is 3 bedroom flat constable hse nw3 .. these fuel ESTMATED charges are way over and camden continues to milk leaseholders. any comments/advise on how to respond will be greatly appreciated… is there a date set up for meeting to discuss these extortionate service charges???

                                  ———————————————————————————————————————————–

                                  We understand annual service charge invoice has increased and the greater part of that relates to heating and electricity. The cost of energy has increased significantly over the past year or so which is beyond Camden’s control.

                                  Camden, along with a number of public sector organisations, purchases gas and electricity through the LASER public sector buying organisation. We are able to purchase energy for Camden’s Housing, Schools and Corporate estates at cheaper wholesale rates by combining with other organisations.

                                  LASER is a public-sector organisation which purchases gas and electricity on the wholesale market for local authorities and other public bodies. Since 2011, Camden has procured gas and electricity through a framework operated by LASER. Wholesale prices are lower than retail prices. Also, the purchasing scheme allows the purchase of energy before the supply period, meaning energy can be purchased when prices are most favourable. Therefore by using LASER to purchase energy at wholesale prices, the cost of your energy is lower than those buying at domestic market prices.

                                  Although the cost of gas and electricity has increased considerably, Camden is still paying considerably less than general wholesale prices.

                                  From October 2022 to January 2023 inclusive, Camden’s bills for gas were discounted by an average of 1.27 pence/kWh received through the Government’s Energy Bill Relief Scheme (EBRS). Discount values for February and March 2023 will become known as Camden receive billing.

                                  The property is connected to Camden’s communal system providing gas for heating and hot water. Below is a breakdown comparison of the gas charge for the 2022/23 and 2023/24 estimated service charges.

                                  2022/23 – Fuel/gas £524.06 / Electricity £89.36 / Other £295.41 = Total £908.83

                                  2023/24 – Fuel/gas £2,028.03 / Electricity £167.68 / Other £319.17 = Total £2,514.88

                                  We calculated the estimated service charges for 2023/24 in December 2022, when we received the costs for the 2022/23 year (October 2022 to September 2023) from LASER.

                                  The estimated consumption per site for 2023/24 was calculated in the same way as previous years, by using an average consumption over the previous 2-3 years.

                                  Whilst LASER provided prices for the year October 2022 to September 2023, unlike previous years they did not provide a forecast for the period October 2023 to September 2024.

                                  To calculate the estimated service charge for the 2023/24, we recalculated the expected outturn for the 2022/23 financial year based on two sets of prices sent to us by LASER. For the period from April 2022 to September 2022 we used the 2021/22 prices (October 2021 to September 2022) they sent us in November 2021. For the period from October 2022 to March 2023 we used the 2022/23 prices (October 2022 to September 2023) which LASER sent to us in December 2022. We then added 50% to the expected 2022/23 out turn as a means of forecasting the prices for 2023/24.

                                  The estimated Day to Day service charges for 2023-24 is £4,454.30 in comparison to £2,653.05 for 2022-23. The main increase is the Heating/HotWater/Gas Supply charges, which is beyond Camden’s control.

                                  The recent service charge invoice is an estimated charge for the property for financial year 2023-24. When the actual service charge account adjustment for 2023-24 is issued in September 2024, we will be able to provide a breakdown of the costs to block/estate.

                                  I have included a link to our website page for leaseholders-and-freeholders which includes useful information including our Service Charge Guide.

                                  Information on cost of living support can be found on Camden website; Cost of living support – Camden Council and Cost of living crisis fund – Camden Council

                                  #6936
                                  15vesage
                                  Participant

                                    I will just add my support to all the comments here. Camden seem to have calculated my heating charges by pulling a number from thin air. They seem to think it costs £2000/year to heat a small 1 bed flat. They are either completely incompetent or collecting money from us under false pretences.

                                    Any support or advice on how we can contest this would be appreciated, since it seems to be affecting everyone in the entire Borough.

                                    #6964
                                    billmurray
                                    Participant

                                      OK. We’re all whinging about how something must be done. Someone needs to step up and offer to spearhead our complaints, otherwise they will just, as always, just run into the sand. I’d be happy to chip in for this if required.

                                      #6967
                                      DrDavid
                                      Participant

                                        I completely agree with comments on this thread – service charges on my flat have been increased by some 75% on last year. How is this justified? I’ve asked Camden for detailed explanation but no reply yet. Next stop local government ombudsman? Judicial review? I wonder if these are options.

                                        #6974
                                        daugs
                                        Participant

                                          local govt ombudsman after Camden Complaint process but in my experience the ombudsman doesn’t get involved as leaseholders have legal redress under terms of lease.

                                          In my experience, can wait for Camden to take you to court, and then argue for transfer to First Tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) ie what was LVT to determine reasonableness of service charges, after which gets transferred back to court. Or you can apply direct to FTT for a determination of reasonableness yourself. The rules around what is reasonable come from Landlord and Tenant Act and there is a lot of case law. The reasonableness can be on quality and price. HOWEVER, be careful, the view on reasonableness is about alternatives, NOT just proving a cheaper alternative, so advice is often needed depending on the issue. You don’t need legal representation for FTT, but may well need expert witness. Well worth speaking to Leasehold Advisory Service and reading previous decisions.

                                          David

                                          PS judges don’t appear to like people representing themselves at the early stages in court, I did several years back and argued for transfer to LVT. Represented myself at the directions hearing against Camden + lawyer + barrister, after 10 minutes of being belittled by the judge I was allowed to put my request that it be transferred to LVT which the judge begrudgingly accepted as appropriate given my case (as filed in the defence document) was a resonableness issue, but Camden did oppose it…..In the end case never got before the LVT as Camden withdrew their claim before the hearing (ie capitulated) but they did drag it out.

                                          #6975
                                          CarolynM
                                          Participant

                                            Hello, just thought I’d repeat some info shared by the Camden Leaseholders Forum earlier in this thread. The reason the energy bills are so high is because Camden is estimating what will happen to energy prices for the rest of this year. We discussed this at the last CLF meeting on 14 March and our next public meeting is 30 May – it will be on the agenda again! Email this address to get a link to observe remotely on Teams camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk

                                            1. Payment plans – we included a summary of the options available in the latest CLF email newsletter – if you didn’t get a copy then email camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk to join the list. Basically you can spread the entire service charge over up to 12 months, and if you contact Camden leaseholder services you can negotiate a longer term for the energy portion. They are slow to respond but lodge your request and then you need only pay 1/12 of the non-energy element until you get a response.

                                            2. Heat metering – this is a way to monitor which flats in an estate are using more or less heat. It’s available in a few estates and we have pushed Camden to let us know when it will be available for other estates. It’s not as precise as a meter but a first step. It will provide all residents an incentive to turn down their heating. We have raised this again with Glendine Shepherd (Director of Housing) and also Meric Apak. If you want to know more about how heat metering works Patrick Hagopian (on the CLF) is best placed – email the same CLF email and we can forward it.

                                            In the meantime do please email your local councillor as this helps them pressure Camden to put more resources on answering leaseholder calls and emails. CLF are bugging them every week but this will help. If your estate has a committee chair get them to lobby your local councillor on behalf of all residents.
                                            We are also mentioning the number of posts/emails we receive on this topic to Glendine Shepherd (Director of Housing) and Meric Apak.

                                            Carolyn (CLF Chair 2022/23)

                                            #6976
                                            billmurray
                                            Participant

                                              Thanks Carolyn,
                                              How do we get on the agenda the leaseholder’s right to change to individual heating/hotwater systems?

                                              #6977
                                              CarolynM
                                              Participant

                                                Hello all, I just had an email from Geraldine Littlechild at Leaseholder services. She said that anyone who is having difficulty paying their service charge should contact leaseholderservices@camden.gov.uk. They can send out a confidential income and expenditure form for you to return. The payment plans will be worked out individually. To date 3 leaseholders are now on 18 month payment plans. LS are currently responding to queries within 10 working days. If you don’t get a response in that time frame email CLF on camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk and we will try to help. We are all leaseholders and volunteers so we have to do this around our day jobs but it is useful to know where there are problems.

                                                On the “heat meter” issue, we have a spreadsheet listing which estates are due to have Camden fit heat meters which (eventually) will permit leaseholders to get individualised bills. This is not a fast process but CLF do have a working group on energy pushing Camden on this. To share your story, get involved, email camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk and we will pass to the working group.

                                                We will have a discussion on energy at the next formal CLF on 30 May – you can request a link to observe the meeting virtually from camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk

                                                #6978
                                                patrickhagopian
                                                Participant

                                                  As Carolyn said yesterday, I have been looking into the heat meter issue as a member of the CLF energy working group. I will be happy to address any questions that members bring up, whether on the discussion board or addressed to me at patrickhagopian@gmail.com. If I can’t answer a question I will try to refer it on to the appropriate quarter.

                                                  Please note that no one believes that the adoption of individual charging through heat meters is the solution to the very high energy costs now in leaseholders’ Service Charges. Actually, it probably works the other way round: because of the high energy costs we are being charged, residents have had new reason to gain control over their personal energy costs, as well as conserving energy. Camden has told my local association that the vast majority of those individually charged through heat meters use less energy (and save money) as a result. On my estate leaseholders have told me they are very keen to have their heat meters activated and for individual charging to begin for that reason. They have also told me of their frustration: it looks as though under Camden’s stated procedures, it may take a very long time for individual charging to start, for reasons that we can address in the discussion, if there is any interest in the topic.

                                                  I don’t want this to be a monologue, though: I want to hear from leaseholders about your concerns and experiences — and also to get your answers to some questions. The first question for you: do you have a meter installed but before it was/is activated, you were told your Heat Interface Unit requires/d an “upgrade” (or something similar)? Or were you given a specific reason that something needed to be done before the heat meter could be activated? A second question: have you experienced any contractor-related delays or postponements in the activation of your heat meter?

                                                  I won’t say more now in order not to influence responses, but I’ll be happy to explain the context and reason for these questions if any replies follow. Please post responses to the board or directly to my email address.

                                                  Manager: perhaps if any heat meter-related messages come in, we might establish a new thread with heat meters as the topic?

                                                  Thanks! Patrick Hagopian, CLF Member

                                                  #6980
                                                  billmurray
                                                  Participant

                                                    Hi Carolyn,
                                                    Thanks. How do we get on the agenda the leaseholder’s right to change to individual heating/hotwater systems?
                                                    Best, Bill

                                                    #6985
                                                    Vigil
                                                    Participant

                                                      Since there seems to be a lull in our enthusiasm to battle on with rgds to the extortionate service and energy charges, I’ve taken the opportunity to assess all the comments sent by this group. While I agree profoundly with Harvinho, Bill and Manager (as well as all the others), I think someone must take the initiative to set up a meeting, online or in person to discuss what we need to do to get the charges lowered, and, for the future, how to convert the heating and hotwater supply/meters onto our personal/property names. What Manager has expressed in his email dtd 24th Mar is also of serious importance and must be looked into.
                                                      According to the Gov website, it clearly states–
                                                      * “If you pay for your energy as part of your rent, your landlord or property manager must pass on some or all of the support they get.

                                                      *If you get your energy from a heat network, your supplier must pass on some or all of the support they get”.

                                                      It goes on to say–
                                                      * “You can get a £400 discount to help with your energy bills for winter 2022 to 2023. This is called the Energy Bills Support Scheme.
                                                      You’ll usually get the discount automatically – you do not have to apply.

                                                      *If you have a traditional prepayment meter, you’ll get the discount in the form of credit or a voucher to use at a top-up point. Smart meters get it automatically”.

                                                      It goes on to explain–

                                                      *The Energy Bill Relief Scheme which support businesses and organisations will run between 1 October 2022 and 31 March 2023. Then, the Energy Bills Discount Scheme will replace the EBRS to run for 12 months from 1 April 2023 to 31 March 2024″.

                                                      I know that this was explained earlier by a participant but, I’m sorry to say Im a lay person and I do not understand all the technical and complicated innuendo pushed forward by Camden. All I know is that £400 was due to me as a Govt support scheme– and when Camden sends a statement of service charges to me as an individual, this amount (rebate) shud reflect in that invoice. Am I wrong in thinking that? Can someone honestly explain in laymen’s terms?

                                                      #6990
                                                      Harvinho
                                                      Participant

                                                        No lull in enthusiasm here! Would just like to point you all towards an article published in the Guardian today on this very matter: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2023/may/19/uk-households-with-communal-heating-facing-350-rise-in-energy-costs. There are nearly half a million people across the country currently in the same position as us and also clearly not happy about it. Heat networks, which are currently unregulated, are going to be regulated by Ofgem from 2024 onwards, so there clearly is some recognition by the government that heat network providers aren’t acting in everyone’s best interests. Whilst there’s very little we can do about the greed driven inflation caused by multinational food and energy suppliers, I feel like local councils present a very ‘winnable’ battle if enough of us get involved. With that in mind, I’ve taken the following actions and I would urge others to do the same (I’m more than happy to provide the text I sent as a starting point for others with less time on their hands):

                                                        1: Contacted alex.lawson@theguardian.com and sarah.marsh@theguardian.com (the journalists responsible for the article)to share the plight of Camden leaseholders and describe my own situation in case of a follow up article to the one published today.

                                                        2: Contacted https://www.leighday.co.uk/forms/contact-leigh-day/ the law firm mentioned in the article to find out whether they think that we might have grounds for some form of joint action against Camden Council.

                                                        3: Contacted the following consumer affairs programmes to see if they might be interested in a piece about Camdens exorbitant service charges:
                                                        -The Martin Lewis Money Show (itv) martinlewis@itv.com
                                                        -You and yours (radio 4) youandyours@bbc.co.uk
                                                        -Rip Off Britain (bbc) https://www.bbc.co.uk/send/u19921092?ptrt=https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00wck32
                                                        -Watchdog (bbc) watchdog@bbc.co.uk
                                                        The message I sent them was along the lines of:
                                                        Dear Sir/Madam,

                                                        I am writing to you in the hope that you might be willing to investigate extortionate leaseholder service charges that Camden leaseholders have just received for the coming year. These service charges have always been extremely high and incorporate work that is never completed in many cases; I’m charged annually for work on ‘roads and pathways’ of which there has never been any maintenance on my estate, however, my service charge has more than doubled for the coming year 2023/24. A large portion of this massive increase has come from gas/heating/hot water that has risen from £1186 to £3184. Whilst I appreciate that the cost of energy supplies has increased, British Gas state that the average gas bill for a 3 bedroom house this year is £1386 whereas I live in a small 2 bedroom apartment, and have switched my heating on only when temperatures have been below freezing but am paying more than double that figure. The amount that we are being charged does not equate to how much Camden is paying for gas and how much energy is used by the whole estate. I have a four year old daughter and another baby on the way in July and am now not sure how I am going to make ends meet with childcare costs, the increased cost of groceries and bills and now a £500 a month service charge to pay. I feel that an investigation by [insert name of consumer affairs programme] might help to shed some light on how Camden can justify these charges and encourage them to create more parity for leaseholders on heat networks at a time when many of us are facing financial hardship. Thank you for considering my request.

                                                        Yours faithfully
                                                        Adrian Harvey

                                                        4: I have previously written to james.slater@camden.gov.uk and sylvia.mcnamara@camden.gov.uk my local councillors, but wasn’t getting anywhere with them so have started e-mailing keir.starmer.constituency@parliament.uk directly. He has yet to respond but I feel like he might if we all e-mail him. I think I previously copied in the content of my letters to my local councillors; my correspondence with Keir Starmer has been along similar lines.

                                                        5: As well as contacting the Guardian today, I also wrote to the Camden New Journal editorial@camdennewjournal.co.uk and the Ham and High simon.murfitt@newsquest.co.uk urging them to investigate this story. The Ham and High has previously run a story on extortionate service charges in the local area.

                                                        I have continued to try to get leaseholder services to explain how they have arrived at the figure that they are charging me for gas/hot water/heating, however, they take weeks to respond every time I contact them and they don’t answer my questions when they do. Most recently they sent me a spreadsheet that didn’t contain any calculations and seemed to arrive at a figure that was £500 less than what they are actually charging me.

                                                        #7000
                                                        Honey_Bee
                                                        Participant

                                                          Thanks to those sharing experiences and advice here on finding a way through this.

                                                          I have emailed leaseholder services to request a longer payment period as I have a large increase not only for energy but also due to major works.

                                                          #7002
                                                          Harvinho
                                                          Participant

                                                            Leigh day, the Law firm I mentioned in my previous post, is considering a group claim on behalf of heat network customers paying excessive bills. They believe that there is a lack of transparency in the billing process and issues around the efficiency of heat network systems, that could represent a breach of contract by the heat providers. There is a very simple form to fill in if you would want to be involved in this group action here: https://www.leighday.co.uk/our-services/group-claims/heat-networks-group-claim/ The blurb that comes up after having filled in the form seems to suggest that the more interest they receive, the more likely it is that their claim will go ahead, so I would urge as many of you as possible to fill in the form (took me about 5 minutes). You will need a copy of your invoice for the previous year’s service charge (22/23) and the current one (23/24).You can download these as a PDF if you go to your Camden Account then locate the invoices within ‘Housing’ then send them to print to be able to save the PDFs. They request a copy of the lease/contract but i haven’t been able to get leaseholder services to send this to me yet.

                                                            #7004
                                                            CarolynM
                                                            Participant

                                                              Dear @harvinho thanks for sharing your contacts with the Guardian re that story about communal heating. Patrick Hagopian, a Forum member who is on our energy working group, has also had some email exchanges with Alex Lawson, so you should compare motes. Email me at carolynm.clf@gmail.com and I will put you in touch with Patrick.
                                                              Carolyn (CLF Chair 2022/23)

                                                              #7003
                                                              PW
                                                              Participant

                                                                On top of the energy costs per kwh that Camden are charging – I would highly recommend you request the meter readings from when (if you have a smart meter) the first smart meter reading was available. It took me a few weeks to get the readings but in the end leaseholder services provided them.

                                                                In our case the meter was installed in September 2021. I have compared the usage between Sept21-Mar22 and Sept22-Mar23 and the meter reading is showing 165% increase. I would query if the smart meters are measuring correctly. So far no response from Camden.

                                                                I have registered here as per the advice of Harvinho: https://www.leighday.co.uk/our-services/group-claims/heat-networks-group-claim/

                                                              Viewing 30 posts - 61 through 90 (of 112 total)
                                                              • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.