Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
15th March 2024 at 11:39 in reply to: problems setting up standing order to pay service charges #7274
I just set up the standing order with my banking app. The account details are on the invoice. Essential to use the invoice number as the reference.
Hello Izzy, as a rider to my last note – if I had made no payment at all in respect of the charge and as it is now being pursued as a debt I would now make payment in full. I would continue to investigate and to challenge the amount if it has been unreasonably incurred or not properly consulted.
Hello Izzy
If you accept that the works to which the disputed charge relates were reasonably necessary then you should pay what you consider to be a reasonable amount as a payment on account. You are likely to be found in breach of the terms of your lease if you make no payment at all.
What you might consider to be a reasonable amount will probably depend to a large extent on what information Camden has provided to you.
It sounds as if this is a demand for Actual costs incurred, rather than estimated costs. When I receive the demand for Actual costs (in September) I always ask, straightaway for an opportunity to inspect the accounts for the charges to which the summary relates. For Major Works, I ask for a detailed breakdown and invoices. I am entitled to see this but of course Camden cannot provide it so I have an opportunity to make my own reasonable assessment and make that payment on account – pending the final account. In that case the invoiced should be placed on hold for the outstanding amount.
Do make sure to keep a careful chronological record of all communications with Camden. In you current situation, this may prove vital for your case.
I would suggest that if the buyer is that concerned they can take out an indemnity insurance themselves?
Emilia, are referring to a letter from Camden dated 29 December and referenced 20-004?
The item you refer to is a heads-up for planned maintenance work which is in the pipeline. The figures are only best estimates for a scope of works based on a stock condition survey and may go up or down.
Camden has entered into long term agreements (Contract 19-004: years 2020 to 2024) with shortlisted contractors to deliver its Better Homes programme and other major works. The selected contractors took part in a competitive tender process and submitted the most economically advantageous tenders.
The framework agreement consists of 7 specialisms – to cater for the various types of work – and sets out the terms, particularly relating to price and quality, under which individual contracts (call-offs) can be awarded following mini-competitions.
A mini-competition process for each package of work to be called off under the framework agreement invites the contractors to submit their best price for that package. Camden says this price will not exceed, and will potentially improve upon, the prices in the framework agreement.
Before a contractor is appointed, Camden is legally required to consult leaseholders. They will send you a Schedule 3 notice which will describe the work package and give you the opportunity to comment on the proposed works (but not to nominate a contractor).
Camden’s External Better Homes Programme schedule of planned works may be found here:
https://opendata.camden.gov.uk/dataset/External-Better-Homes-Programme/yas3-u9wcIf it’s you domestic supply, just go ahead. There is no need to notify.
I am no expert. But my research suggests that the limitation period for recovering a service charge in the case of a Camden lease is 12 years. As the leases are made by deed the service charge falls under section 8 of the Limitation Act 1980.
I note that a Camden lease does not reserve service charges as ‘rent’ which is why section 19 (6 years) does not apply.
Of course, Camden can seek to recover no greater amount than it has notified under the 18 months rule.Nelson, your lease sounds very similar to ours. I had just quoted extracts relating to lifts and not the full text.
On Lease page 16 (or thereabouts) there is a Clause 4 ‘The Landlord Covenants…’ and that is where the Landlord’s obligations are stated. That is where it makes it clear that the obligation to provide a lift, and therefore the Tenant’s obligation to pay for one, depends on the Tenant named in the lease being able to enjoy and use the lift.
You say that you have 7 non-communicating staircases in your building and that the lifts are within your building. Is it not the case that Wood Field is a terrace of seven Buildings? If so, then your “Building” is defined on Lease page 3 (or thereabouts) as “The building consisting solely of physically linked flats within the Estate and including the Flat described in the Premises and the Common Parts within the Building”. It is important to use the correct terminology.
You say that the Council was challenged in the early 1990’s on this issue but won the dispute. Was the case decided in the LVT property court? Or did the leaseholder give up when the Council said no? Being so recent, it was probably a question of payment of day-to-day charges rather than wholesale lift replacement.
This is not a question of fairness but of a Landlord’s duty to act lawfully in accordance with the terms of the lease and statute. It is unfortunate that leaseholders who do enjoy and use the lifts will probably face an increased contribution.
Nelson, I am a layman – not a lawyer – but my advice would be to challenge Camden’s notice requiring you to contribute to costs incurred in relation to lift installations which are not within your Building.
If your lease is like mine, “Items of Expenditure” is defined as “All those items referred to in the Fifth Schedule the costs whereof form the basis of the Service Charge”. Those items which refer to lifts say “The cost of periodically inspecting maintaining overhauling repairing and where necessary replacing […] lifts lift shafts and machinery therein (if any)” and “The cost (if any) of […] the electric current for operating the passenger lifts”. Note here the use of “if any”.
This “if any” means that a cost must be incurred in respect of a service which the lease requires the landlord to provide. So, is the landlord required to provide a lift in your Building?
The Landlord covenants (what he undertakes to do) are set out in Clause 4. In relation to lifts, 4.2 and 4.2.4 say: “to maintain repair redecorate renew […] The passenger lifts lift shafts and machinery (if any) and the passages landings and staircases and other parts of the Managed Buildings and the Common Parts enjoyed or used by the Tenant in common with others.
Worth noting also that the definition of “Common Parts” similarly refers to those parts being “enjoyed or used by the Tenant”.
As you, the Tenant, do not enjoy or use the lifts so the landlord has no obligation to provide any. Arguably, therefore, neither should you have any obligation to contribute to the cost of lifts which are provided solely for the enjoyment and use of others.
You might consider the following actions:
– Do not pay any charges in respect of lifts
– Make contact (where possible) with other leaseholders in those Buildings which have no lifts and jointly agree a strategy
– Write to the Head of Leaseholder Services (Mike Edmunds) stating your case and ask him to review Camden’s position and retract the notice
– If Camden will not retract the notice, seek legal advice as to the strength of your case
– Seek a determination of your case by the First Tier Tribunal.If we are talking about the bullying of leaseholders – well, it’s in the job title darling! Let me explain a recent experience.
Most leaseholders’ contact with our landlord Camden is likely to be around the subject of service charges. We are then faced with one of its team with the title “Collections Officer”. In other words, a ‘debt collector’.
We had disputed and withheld part of an actual charge and Camden had put this invoice ‘on hold’ while they resolved the matter. We next received a credit against another invoice (which we had already fully paid). Camden insisted on applying the credited amount to the disputed invoice, they said: “our automated allocations payment system doesn’t recognise invoices that are on hold. Therefore overpayments or credit notes cannot be prevented from crediting invoices on hold.”
We insisted that the credit should be applied to the latest payment due and so we paid less against that invoice. When we received a ‘final demand’ for payment we did not pay. Camden provided our address and the outstanding debt amount to its solicitors and they sent us their ‘£5 letter’, extracts: “If you do not pay this debt in full … will also seek to recover the cost of this letter which is £5. Further we will be instructed to issue you with a Pre-Action Protocol Letter of Claim … cost of that letter which is £75. In addition … recover interest on the debt owed.” Is this not an example of bullying?
Camden has admitted the problem we encountered is inherent in its automated payment system. This needs to be fixed. However, as a resident ratepayer we applaud Camden’s renewed efforts to recover unpaid bills which would otherwise be borne by all residents in the borough. Who has met a friendly and understanding debt collector?
-
AuthorPosts