Leaseholder1

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Bathroom refurbishment and GEM #7360
    Leaseholder1
    Participant

      @SC Which sections of your bathroom need to be done by GEM (rather than your own bathroom fitter) according to Camden? Also, what explanation did Camden give you as to why they need to be done by GEM? We may have seen something similar.

      Leaseholder1
      Participant

        Hi Birdsnest

        Thank you very much for all of your research on this topic and sharing your significant findings.

        It would be interesting to know whether (i) council tenants will receive any subsidy for their 2024/2025 heating charges as well as their 2023/2024 heating charges, (ii) what proportion of leaseholders’ contributions to the heating pool for 2023/2024 were applied to subsidise council tenants’ heating charges, eg did leaseholders contribute £7 million to the heating pool so 50% of our bills were applied as a subsidy? and (iii) what proportion of leaseholders’ contributions to the heating pool for 2024/2025 will be applied to subsidise council tenants’ heating charges.

        It is not clear to me how under my lease Camden is entitled to inflate my heating charges so that it can use the excess money to subsidise tenants’ heating charges. My lease provides that I have to pay Camden a proportionate part of maintaining the heating system and the cost of gas and electricity to supply it. The proportion I pay is a specific percentage (based on the old rateable value system). If that percentage is, eg 1.5%, I don’t see how Camden can charge me eg 3% so that it can use the excess money to subsidise tenants’ heating charges. It would be interesting to know how your and other leaseholders’ leases work?

        Having said that, when I look at my service charge bills, for all services except heating/hot water/gas supply, the block cost is specified and then my cost, so that I can see what percentage of the block cost I am paying. However, in the case of heating/hot water/gas supply, no block cost is specified. Instead, I only see a number specifying my cost and an insurance premium. So I cannot see what the block heating costs are and I cannot verify what percentage of the block heating costs I am paying. I assume other leaseholders’ bills are set out in the same way.

        For 2024/2025 some blocks will have heat meters installed and activated and residents should be billed on their metered usage. It may be harder for Camden to extract additional money in subsidies from metered leaseholders, in which case the burden of subsidies may fall on unmetered leaseholders.

        This is a can of worms. If Camden have used leaseholders’ contributions to subsidise tenants’ heating charges I wonder whether Camden use leaseholders’ contributions to subsidise Camden’s share of major works charges.

        in reply to: New Boiler #7219
        Leaseholder1
        Participant

          Just to be clear, its a communal heating system but you aren’t supplied heating and hot water from communal boilers. Instead, you have an individual gas boiler in your flat which supplies only your flat (a gas boiler, not just a water heater). Despite having an individual boiler in your flat supplying your flat, you are billed for heating and hot water on a communal basis. As the system is communal Camden owns the gas boiler and pipework in your flat.

          Who are BTU? Also is there a surveyor at Camden you are dealing with?

          A few things occur to me:
          (1) I don’t know what is the layout of your flat. Is it concrete construction, in which case I think Camden will run surface pipework, or do you have wooden flooring (in which case pipework could be run underneath)? Even if concrete construction, I would expect most of the pipework to run through the skirting boards.
          (2) Do you have your own ideas as to where you would like the boiler to be located and how you would like the pipework to be run? You just need the pipework to feed the radiators and to supply the kitchen and bathroom hot water. If you do have your own ideas I think that you should propose them to Camden and tell them that this is how you want it done.
          (3) Alternatively, look up a few heating engineers online and tell them that you want the boiler in order to comply with new legislation with minimal disruption to the rest of the flat. Get them to suggest where they would put the boiler and how they would run the pipework and what price they would do it at. If they come up with more acceptable solutions than Camden’s then you can then propose one to Camden.
          (4) As the system in communal, and presumably other flats in your block have the same issue as you, is the relocaiton of boilers being classed as “major works”? I dopn’t know what the cost will be but has Camden gone through the correct process in connection with major works?
          (5) Also, if the system is communal, what does your lease say about how you will be charged for these works? Even though the works are being done in your flat, it may be that you only pay a specific percentage (or equivalent based on ratings value) under your lease.

          in reply to: New Boiler #7217
          Leaseholder1
          Participant

            I assume that you are a leaseholder and that you have individual (not communal) heating which you are responsible for. Presumably you need Camden consent under your lease to replace your boiler? When you say that the boiler needs to be from an “approved supplier” do you mean a supplier approved by Camden? If Camden need to approve the supplier then presumably you can just contact Camden at the usual Camden leaseholders address – camdenleaseholderservices@camden.gov.uk – and they can give you freeholder consent if necessary and tell you who their “approved suppliers” are.

            When you say you’ve been told to locate the boiler in your spare room and run pipework to the kitchen, who told you this? Camden’s surveyor? Or the approved supplier? If Camden/their approved supplier have told you this, I suggest you get alternative quotes from alternative heating engineers. If they advise you that you can install the boiler elsewhere (eg in the kitchen) and at a cheaper price, then you can go back to Camden and tell them that they are wrong and are being unreasonable.

            in reply to: Roof leak + delay + damage #7123
            Leaseholder1
            Participant

              Hi John

              I think this is outrageous. In my opinion:
              (1) Yes, Camden Council are responsible for the maintenance of pipework in the roof and for damage caused by the leak in the roof.
              (2) Yes, Camden Council are liable to pay for the damage caused by their property (ie pipework in the roof) to your property.
              (3) No. (Unless your lease says otherwise but I doubt that it does) you do not have permission to enter the freeholder’s property or do anything to it.
              (4) You should contact the buildings insurers with a view to a claim (if you don’t have a copy of the policy or broker contact details leaseholder services should be able to provide them or the information may be somewhere on the website). You should also look to claim on Camdens’ public liability insurance (get the details from the same sources). Also notify your home contents insurer – I assume the carpet is covered by contents. I don’t know where the liability sits but insurers may discuss together and agree to apportion liability. The claims lines should at least tell you what they will cover. Please also notify your area housing officer and ask them what they propose to do. If you don’t get a satisfactory response contact your local councillors and the Housing Ombudsman (your councillors should hopefully respond a lot quicker than the Ombudsman).
              (5) Yes. Does your contents insurance include a legal advice helpline and cover for legal expenses? Speak to them. If not and if necessary because you can’t get the matter resolved otherwise speak to landlord tenant solicitors.
              Good luck, I hope this gets resolved soon.

              in reply to: Water Stop Cock Location #7044
              Leaseholder1
              Participant

                If you haven’t got a stopcock in your flat to isolate the water supply the first thing you should do is put one in. Camden should know where the water stopcock for the block is, but they are, as you know, hopelessly incompetent.

                in reply to: New front door vs. the lease #7027
                Leaseholder1
                Participant

                  I would expect your lease to refer to alterations to the property and stipulate whether you require freeholder consent to make them. I would expect changing the door to be an alteration.

                  Depending upon the nature of your property, you may need planning permission (I think you can send an online enquiry using Camden’s planning portal).

                  The door will also need to be compliant with applicable fire regulations, which will depend upon the nature of your property. Your builder should know what those regulations are.

                  in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6942
                  Leaseholder1
                  Participant

                    @CarolynM Thank you for your message. Is there any significance in just paying the first instalment? Does that in some way mitigate the risk of Camden trying to sue you for the whole amount in one go, if you object to the amount of the requested payment? Thank you.

                    in reply to: 6 months after reporting leak, still not fixed #6790
                    Leaseholder1
                    Participant

                      So sorry to hear about your situation.

                      Have you made any claim on the buildings insurance? I would expect the insurer to have a strong interest in resolving the cause of the leak.

                      What was the outcome of the two complaints? Who were the complaints officers, what conclusions did they reach and did they state what action they would be taking? Which councillor did you contact and what did they say or do (if anything)?

                      in reply to: Contacting Camden leaseholder services #6517
                      Leaseholder1
                      Participant

                        If you raise a complaint how long does it take to get a response, or even an acknowledgement of your complaint? I have sent a complaint to complaints@camden.gov.uk, but for all I know they will ignore it just like requests lower down the chain are ignored.

                        in reply to: Letter From Camden on lease extensions #6298
                        Leaseholder1
                        Participant

                          @CarolynM Great, this is very helpful, thanks very much.

                          in reply to: Letter From Camden on lease extensions #6295
                          Leaseholder1
                          Participant

                            Many thanks for this information. Do you mind if I ask (1) how many years you had left on your lease before renewal, (2) what were your valuers fees and who you used, (3) did Camden just charge £450 for the valuation and did they actually send somebody to inspect, (4) how much did Camden’s lawyers charge. Thank you so much for your help.

                            in reply to: Major Works-WhatsApp Group #5895
                            Leaseholder1
                            Participant

                              Thanks very much GR. We could approach Michael Vincent, Eleanor at Anthony Gold, and whoever Bourne Estate uses (if they can share the name of their solicitors) and see if any of them would be interested in having a zoom call with the Camden Leaseholders.

                              in reply to: Major Works-WhatsApp Group #5892
                              Leaseholder1
                              Participant

                                I think the solicitors should do a 1 hour introductory zoom call for all the Camden Leaseholders in which they introduce themselves, and tell us about their experience and issues they can help us with. This is effectively marketing for them and I would have thought they would not charge for this.

                                in reply to: Solicitor recommendations #5873
                                Leaseholder1
                                Participant

                                  It seems to me that Anthony Gold could help us not just with excessive major works demands, but also Camden’s failure to meet its obligations as freeholder, including failing to carry out necesssary repairs and deal with noise and nuisance issues. Given that as a group we could push quite a bit of work their way, could Anthony Gold, as a starting point, give us a presentation (on zoom) explaining how they can help us, their previous experience of dealing with Camden and other councils, and how and at what point we should approach them.

                                  Also, I think members of the leaseholders committee may have taken legal advice or brought legal action against Camden, and it would be great if they could also share their previous experience, perhaps on the same zoom call. It would be particularly useful to know how leaseholders on an estate organise themselves as a group. We on our estate have found it difficult to form a leaseholders group and it is tricky knowing how to split costs between leaseholders.

                                Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)