LVT evidence inspection appointments

Hi there,

Welcome to this LVT update which focuses on the appointment system for viewing Camden Council’s evidence for the LVT management charge case.

If you have already registered your interest in the case with Camden Council, Lauran Bush of Camden Council has probably emailed asking you for your preferred appointment slot to view Camden’s evidence in regards to this case (within the window of 13th August to 27th September, as set by the LVT). If you have not already received an email, we recommend that you contact her again now. Lauren’s email address is lauran.bush@camden.gov.uk.
 

Appointments

We suggest leaseholders spread out their sessions and don’t all try and view the information at the same time. Each leaseholder can then view the information and, should they wish, feed what they discover back to other leaseholders, for example through our website (see below) – the aim being that we don’t all just section at “Section A” and no one gets past “Section D” (for example!).

Pick a time to suit yourself; slots so far have tended to be 4 hours or 5 hours in length, some running from 12pm to 4pm and others from 2pm to 7pm. Camden Council have told us that they will endeavour to be flexible and amenable so that all those that want have any opportunity to inspect the information which will be accessible on laptop computers.

If you want to “buddy up” with someone to view the documents on a laptop together, do feel free to post requests at https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/discussion-board/ [editor’s note: old Discussion Board posts were not migrated when we changed sites in 2015] to see who else is around. TIP: For the above link, the most recently updated discussion is listed at the top of the page with the older discussions towards the bottom (the “updated” date is in the last column).

If you know of friends who are well-versed with figures or accountants, do feel free to bring them along with you (just ensure that you let Lauran Bush know how many people you will be bringing). Apparently there will be a Camden Council accountant on hand to facilitate, but we would obviously rather have independent eyes if possible.
 

More appointments?

We understand that Camden Council wish to be “reasonable” over this particular issue and will issue follow up appointments if requested (or first appointments, to those that missed the original deadline). If you would like an(other) appointment ideally between 13th August and 27th< September email lauran.bush@camden.gov.uk your request; we assured (but cannot guarantee!) that there will flexibility around the closing date so if there are problems, let us know.
 

Data

Camden Council’s initial position was that information can be printed out at 10p a sheet. We have pressed Camden Council allow memory sticks, so that information can be taken in as near an original form as possible (e.g. XLS files) to reduce the likelihood of formatting issues, data corruption or merely photocopying errors. We expect to hear back from this before 13th August and will let you know.
 

Discussing the information

Do feel free to discuss what you discover at https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/discussion-board/ [editor’s note: old Discussion Board posts were not migrated when we changed sites in 2015] which is a discussion board specifically set up for this purpose. The aim is to share whatever information that we can find, to build on each other’s discoveries (and avoid reinventing the wheel). The downside is that the discussion boards are in the public domain (and viewable to individuals from Camden Council), but there is no practical way around this for such a discussion.

If you would prefer to make suggestions privately please email camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk, but we cannot guarantee to reply to every email.
 

Important Advice!

As well as the points of law that various leaseholders have raised and made us aware of, the Leaseholders’ Forum are currently of the opinion that evidence that we get about individual mistakes/overcharging that are documented in the information provided will benefit our case; these will help prove that Camden Council aren’t justified in increasing the management charge in the way that they wish. If you see any evidence of this then please make the Leaseholders’ Forum aware of these errors by posting in the discussion board (particularly to the post entitled: “LVT Case: Evidence”) or email camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk.

But, do remember what the LVT has already said “It is important to re-iterate that the case is not about the cost of the other services that the council provides, such as gardening, cleaning or repairs. It is also not about the standard or quality of the services provided by the council in the current year, because the actual costs of those services will not be known until after the hearing of the application. If appropriate, those issues can be considered by another tribunal at a future date”. The case is about projected management costs, not the costs or quality of the services themselves.

There is a body of opinion that also recommends seeing major works data as well as service charge data, as the principles involved in the case can be identified as covering major works too. Consequently any errors in charges for major works are also important.
 

Here is what the Leaseholders’ Forum are doing:

We have asked to see the documents on the first day that they are released, 13th August. We will be inspecting the information and then report back, hopefully the same evening, to https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/discussion-board/ in a post probably entitled “LVT Case: 1st Day Report”. [editor’s note: old Discussion Board posts were not migrated when we changed sites in 2015]

With this information we feel that we might be able to offer an opinion on where following leaseholders can best place their efforts when inspecting the documentation themselves (in the same way as indicated in “Discussing the information”, above).

There is no guarantee that any of this will be useful and that we will understand the information in a meaningful way, but we should all try our best.
 

That’s it for now!

Paul Ginsberg
on behalf of Camden Leaseholders’ Forum
More information available at: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk

If you know of anyone who would like to receive updates from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum please direct them to https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/mailing-list where they can sign up.  You can also adjust your own preferences by clicking on the link at the bottom of this email.

The Leaseholders’ Forum is a volunteer group representing all the leaseholders in Camden Council properties and freeholders paying service charges to Camden Council.  We scrutinise Camden Council proposals, examine working practices and lobby on behalf of leaseholders to Camden Council.

LVT (action required!) and other news updates

Hello and welcome to a July news update from the Leaseholders’ Forum.

Topics in this newsletter:

  • LVT update (action required!)
  • “Camden Account” – volunteers wanted
  • Briefing Note – Lease Buy Back
  • Leaseholders’ Forum minutes
  • A thank you!

 

LVT update – inspecting the management charge figures
There have been a number of delays so Camden has not met deadlines in the LVT Directions.  They have therefore conceded that all reasonable requests for information will be met (as far as possible).

If you are a respondent (‘B’ / ‘C’ leaseholder) and you want to inspect the “in depth” figures that Camden Council has prepared in relation to the LVT management charge case, or specify particular figures you want to see, you still should let Camden Council know.  Interested leaseholders should apply by 1st August (when Camden Council is due to send out appointment details).  Leaseholders’ Forum members will also be inspecting the documents but the more eyes the merrier! – we are always grateful for observations and constructive input.

The appointment dates will be between 13th August and 27th September inclusive; we would expect Camden Council to be flexible in regards to the appointment slots if you cannot meet the date(s) originally issued.

To express your interest we suggest you send an email along the lines of the following:
To: leaseholderservices@camden.gov.uk
Subject: Management Charge LVT Case
Message: Please accept this email as my registration of interest to inspect the figures and supporting documents regarding the above case.  I may also bring other people who are helping me/representing me in regards to this issue.  Yours sincerely, NAME, LEASEHOLD ADDRESS.

Lastly, if you make requests to Camden Council which you feel have been rejected unreasonably, please let us know.  We will try to support you whenever possible, and evidence of obstructiveness could be useful for the LVT hearing and any potential appeal.
 

Camden Account
Camden Account is the online facility to view service charge statements in detail.  It was rolled out to all leaseholders earlier this year.  Cheree Collins, Camden Account project manager, has emailed the Leaseholders’ Forum asking if anyone on our mailing list would be available to participate in an hour long feedback session on 21st or 22nd August at Camden Town Hall, Kings Cross, so that they can trial further improvements.

Please consider participating as this will help all leaseholders – as a Forum we want the data to be accessible to all, not just ‘techies’.  We agree with Cheree that “It is preferable that they receive a wide range of service charges e.g. block and estate repairs, caretaking, mobile security, heating and/or hot water, mechanical ventilation, lifts etc, but testing is not limited to such properties and I’m happy to consider anyone that is interested in helping us out.”

If interested please email Cheree directly before 1st August letting her know whether you are available on 21st or 22nd August (or both), so that she can inform everyone of the selected session in good time.  If Cheree gets too many volunteers, she will let you all know that too!  Cheree’s email address is cheree.collins@camden.gov.uk.
 

Briefing Note
At the end of last month we comprehensively updated our briefing note regarding Lease Buy Back.  The revised document explores the options for leaseholders surrendering their lease to Camden Council, whether as part of a regeneration initiative or on a voluntary basis (e.g. conversion into a secure tenancy, albeit with a significant financial loss).  You can find it at: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/guides/lease-buy-back/

We would also point out that we continue to explore improvements to the options currently available.
 

Leaseholders’ Forum Minutes
The draft minutes from the last meeting will be issued shortly (to those that have opted in to receive them).  We have recently worked with the new Head of Leaseholder Services to improve the process around agendas, minutes and commissioned reports and improvements should be visible from the next meeting onwards.

The next regular meeting will be at 6.45pm on Wednesday, 31st July at Camden Town Hall, Judd Street, Kings Cross, WC1H 9JE.  The next open meeting will be later this year, on a date to be confirmed.
 

A thank you!
There are now 610 people on the Leaseholders’ Forum mailing list.  Given that there are almost 9,500 leaseholders in Camden we are very pleased with how quickly this figure has grown since the mailing list was formally established earlier this year.  We believe that it shows how much leaseholders want to contribute and also be informed about Camden Council, so that we can all nudge it to improve upon the work it is already doing.

We hope that you find these news updates useful and welcome any suggestions or feedback.  Do also have a look at our discussion boards (https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/discussion-board/) where you can start and participate in the debate yourself!
 

That’s it for now!
Paul Ginsberg
on behalf of Camden Leaseholders’ Forum
More information available at: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk

If you know of anyone who would like to receive updates from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum please direct them to https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/mailing-list where they can sign up.  You can also adjust your own preferences by clicking on the link at the bottom of this email.

The Leaseholders’ Forum is a volunteer group representing all the leaseholders in Camden Council properties and freeholders paying service charges to Camden Council.  We scrutinise Camden Council proposals, examine working practices and lobby on behalf of leaseholders to Camden Council.

Request for feedback from Camden Council regarding their website

Hello and welcome to a small news update from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum.

Geraldine Littlechild, the Finance and Income Manager for Leaseholder Services at Camden Council, is currently looking into improving the quality of information available for leaseholders on Camden Council’s website.  She’s been in touch with the Leaseholders’ Forum and asked us to pass her request on so that as wide a group as possible can have an opportunity to participate.  Given that this should lead to an improvement for all leaseholders, we of course are happy to be able to help by forwarding the request out.

If you are interested in assisting please visit https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/130625-camden-council-request.pdf for more information and details on how to get involved.  They are hoping to get the ball rolling in about 2 weeks’ time.

That’s it for now!

Paul Ginsberg
on behalf of Camden Leaseholders’ Forum
More information available at: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk

If you know of anyone who would like to receive updates from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum please direct them to https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/mailing-list where they can sign up.

The Leaseholders’ Forum is a volunteer group representing all the leaseholders in Camden Council properties and freeholders paying service charges to Camden Council.  We scrutinise Camden Council proposals, examine working practices and lobby on behalf of leaseholders to Camden Council.  We regard ourselves as an “honest friend” of Camden Council and aim to achieve better outcomes for all.

More Camden Council witness statements now available for LVT hearing

Hello and welcome to the latest LVT news update from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum.

We have, today, received additional witness statements and methodology from Camden Council in regards to the current management charge LVT issue.  We will be analysing this documentation over the next months.  More documentation should be released by Camden Council this August, according to the timetable set by the LVT.  The additional statements are a witness statement from Geraldine Littlechild and an example of a request for a non-urgent repair.

If you are interested in reading the statements and methodology we have now made this available on our Dropbox file-hosting site.  The link is https://www.dropbox.com/sh/8dicdoe4qr7zndd/t9v3aEMWnc.  The first document you may wish to look at is called “Covering Email.pdf”.  You will need Adobe Acrobat Viewer to read it, but most computers have this installed as standard.

We have also pointed out to Camden Council councillors and the LVT Tribunal that Camden Council managed to miss the LVT’s deadline for this information by 4 days, with no advanced warning, explanation or apology.

That’s it for now!
Paul Ginsberg
on behalf of Camden Leaseholders’ Forum
More information available at: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk

If you know of anyone who would like to receive updates from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum please direct them to https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/mailing-list where they can sign up.

The Leaseholders’ Forum is a volunteer group representing all the leaseholders in Camden Council properties and freeholders paying service charges to Camden Council.  We scrutinise Camden Council proposals, examine working practices and lobby on behalf of leaseholders to Camden Council.  We regard ourselves as an “honest friend” of Camden Council  and aim to achieve better outcomes for all.

Camden Council witness statements now available for LVT hearing!

Hello and welcome to the latest LVT news update from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum.

We have, tonight, received witness statements and methodology from Camden Council in regards to the current management charge LVT issue.  We will be analysing this documentation over the next months.  More documentation should be released by Camden Council this August, according to the timetable set by the LVT.

If you are interested in reading the statements and methodology we have now made this available on our Dropbox file-hosting site.  The link is https://www.dropbox.com/sh/8dicdoe4qr7zndd/t9v3aEMWnc.  The first document you may wish to look at is called “Covering Email.pdf”.  You will need Adobe Acrobat Viewer to read it, but most computers have this installed as standard.

We have also pointed out to Camden Council councillors and the LVT Tribunal that Camden Council managed to miss the LVT’s deadline for this information by 4 days, without advanced warning, explanation or an apology.

That’s it for now!
Paul Ginsberg
on behalf of Camden Leaseholders’ Forum
More information available at: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk

If you know of anyone who would like to receive updates from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum please direct them to https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/mailing-list where they can sign up.

The Leaseholders’ Forum is a volunteer group representing all the leaseholders in Camden Council properties and freeholders paying service charges to Camden Council.  We scrutinise Camden Council proposals, examine working practices and lobby on behalf of leaseholders to Camden Council.  We regard ourselves as an “honest friend” of Camden Council and aim to achieve better outcomes for all.

Want to know more about LVTs?

Hello and welcome to the latest LVT news update from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum.

LVTs

A Leasehold Valuation Tribunal (LVT) is a statutory tribunal in England which decides on various types of landlord and tenant disputes involving property.  e.g. If you have a property complaint which is not resolved with Camden Council, you may take Camden Council to the LVT.  Equally, as in the current case regarding the management element of service charges, Camden Council may take you to the LVT.  The decision of the LVT is legally binding but only to your specific case, unless one of the parties decides to appeal.

Nicolas Kisson (Chief Litigation Solicitor) and Tom Frith (Solicitor) from LEASE will be giving a presentation on the recent changes to the LVT, which will become the new First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber), as part of Islington Leaseholders Association’s annual general meeting.  The meeting is on Wednesday, 12 June at 7pm in the Council Chamber at Islington Town Hall, 222 Upper Street, Islington, N1 1XR.  All are welcome.
 

Other Updates

Camden Leaseholders’ Forum has also published a document about how to try to get Camden Council to deal with your complaints; hopefully speeding up the whole process, reducing misunderstanding(s) and getting an effective resolution.  Download the article here.

The next regular Camden Leaseholders’ Association meeting will be at 6.45pm on Tuesday, 18th June at Camden Town Hall, Judd Street, Kings Cross, WC1H 9JE.  The next open meeting will be later this year, on a date to be confirmed.
That’s it for now!
Paul Ginsberg
on behalf of Camden Leaseholders’ Forum
More information available at: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk

If you know of anyone who would like to receive updates from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum please direct them to https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/mailing-list where they can sign up.

The Leaseholders’ Forum is a volunteer group representing all the leaseholders in Camden Council properties and freeholders paying service charges to Camden Council.  We scrutinise Camden Council proposals, examine working practices and lobby on behalf of leaseholders to Camden Council.  We regard ourselves as an “honest friend” of Camden Council and aim to achieve better outcomes for all.

Leaseholders​’ Forum website update

This is just a very brief news update to let you know that the Leaseholders’ Forum website has had a minor makeover (now that it has been up and running for a few months in its new revitalised form).  No content has been removed, but some items are now in different places.  The upshot of this is that information is easier to find and easier to search for; it is also easier for us to maintain!  The downside is that old links that you may have had from emails (etc) may no longer work.  To find an item, the best place to start looking is the News Archive, where all the old links have been updated to the new locations.

There is a new section called Step-By-Step Guides which will be regularly updated with items which we think will be of general interest to Camden Leaseholders and the News Archive section is easier to navigate.  We also now have Member biographies which are linked to from the “About the Leaseholders’ Forum” section on the front page as well as our website guiding policies and principles document if you fancy a read.  Finally a mention for our Discussion Boards where you can raise and discuss issues that you think that other Camden leaseholders may be interested in.

No other news, but if you want to subscribe to our mailing list and haven’t already done so the address is: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/mailing-list.  There are currently three different topics available, all selectable via the mailing list link:

  • MAIN – all the important stuff!  typically about one email a month
  • Updates relating to the Service Charge/Management Charge LVT issue (2013)  ad hoc
  • Meeting Agendas and Minutes  this is an email twice a month

That’s it for now!
Paul Ginsberg
on behalf of Camden Leaseholders’ Forum
More information available at: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk

If you know of anyone who would like to receive updates from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum please direct them to https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/mailing-list where they can sign up.

The Leaseholders’ Forum is a volunteer group representing all the leaseholders in Camden Council properties and freeholders paying service charges to Camden Council.  We scrutinise Camden Council proposals, examine working practices and lobby on behalf of leaseholders to Camden Council.  We regard ourselves as an “honest friend” of Camden Council and aim to achieve better outcomes for all.

LVT directions released

Welcome to the latest LVT news update from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum

Hi,

Camden Council have now released the LVT directions.   These are the formal outline for how the LVT case will be handled and includes the timeframe that will be involved.

On  an environmental point, I would add that if you are interested in  receiving documents that Camden Council will release as part of this  process, you may wish to email Camden Council (leaseholderservices@camden.gov.uk) and say something along the lines of:

“Dear Leaseholder Services,

As  stated in your letter of 30th April, I do wish to receive further  documents and am now advising you, by email, to confirm this.  Should  you wish to send me these documents electronically rather than by post (as and when they become available) please email them to me at EMAIL ADDRESS instead.

I  note that emailing me documents will save Camden Council (and  potentially leaseholders) time and money, in comparison to printing out  the documents and posting them to me.

Yours sincerely, NAME, ADDRESS.”

The Leaseholders’ Forum will be seeking the names of those that wish to be represented by us, but at a later stage.  If you wish to be informed when we are ready to take names, please ensure that you are signed up to our mailing list (in particular, tick the “LVT” box).

That’s it for now!
Paul Ginsberg
on behalf of Camden Leaseholders’ Forum
More information available at: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk

If you know of anyone who would like to receive updates from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum please direct them to https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/mailing-list where they can sign up.

The Leaseholders’ Forum is a volunteer group representing all the  leaseholders in Camden Council properties and freeholders paying service charges to Camden Council.  We scrutinise Camden Council proposals, examine working practices and lobby on behalf of leaseholders to Camden  Council. We regard ourselves as an “honest friend” of Camden Council and aim to achieve better outcomes for all.

Estimated Service Charges

Welcome to the latest news update from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum

Hi All,

We (the Leaseholders’ Forum) have been asked a number of times what the Leaseholders’ Forum position is in regarding to paying the recently issued estimated service charges for 2013-14.  These include a greatly increased management charge for Type B leaseholders (in comparison to previous years).  We are still in the process of seeking further information from Camden Council regarding this matter, but in the meantime we do have some “holding” advice.

Camden Council has (historically) accepted that leaseholders can without the payment of service charges, if there is a real dispute, while the issue is resolved.  This is in their interest anyway as, if they tried to enforce the debt through the County Court, the judge is likely (but not required) to send the issue to the LVT to decide whether the charge is reasonable.  This means long delays and administration costs (which ultimately can fall back on leaseholders!).

In this instance Camden Council argues that this is their case with the LVT.  They also argue that this is an estimate and Camden Council are entitled to request payment up front for estimates, with the correct calculation being produced some time later.

Some leases allow for interest to be charged for late settlements.

Although you must decide for yourself, one option is to start making the monthly payment towards the current estimate and then you can update your payment amounts later, should further suitable information become available.

That’s it for now!

Paul Ginsberg
on behalf of Camden Leaseholders’ Forum
More information available at: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk

If you know of anyone who would like to receive updates from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum please direct them to https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/mailing-list where they can sign up.

The Leaseholders’ Forum is a volunteer group representing all the leaseholders in Camden Council properties and freeholders paying service charges to Camden Council.  We scrutinise Camden Council proposals, examine working practices and lobby on behalf of leaseholders to Camden Council.  We regard ourselves as an “honest friend” of Camden Council and aim to achieve better outcomes for all.

LVT Management Charge Pre-Trial Review meeting update 2

Welcome to the latest news update from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum

At last week’s Pre-Trial hearing it was proposed that the Directions for the management charge LVT hearing would be released this week.  Having spoken to Lauran Bush from Camden Council, the current schedule appears to be that they will be released on or before 3rd May.

This is what Peter Wright, chair of Camden Leaseholders’ Forum had to say on the matter.

“I am sorry if some of you feel frustrated that the case (and so our response) has seemed to move slowly, but I think we should all conserve energies for what will be a testing time.  And, things are hotting up now; there will be more than enough to keep us all busy.

Camden Council received the draft directions late Wednesday evening.  They have not been published yet because the Tribunal has asked Camden to consider re-framing their Statement of Case.  I imagine Leaseholder Services, the Borough Solicitor and Counsel are busy discussing their response.”

We have asked Camden Council for more information on the supposed subsidy going from tenants to leaseholders, and the high-level management costs breakdown which the last Forum meeting was told are available now from Camden Council.  Camden Council has said that releasing this information early may conflict with the LVT’s Directions.  We have now written to the LVT seeking permission for this disclosure as soon as we see the Directions.

This should give us extra time to begin examining the figures, to ask why Camden Council pays so much and cannot live within 10% management charge like so many other organisations.  As and when we get this information we will publicise it on our website.  It will also go to Camden’s five District Management Committees (which represent tenants as well as leaseholders), so that tenants can also see the high costs which they too are paying through their rents.

That’s it for now…
Paul Ginsberg
on behalf of Camden Leaseholders’ Forum
More information available at: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk

If you know of anyone who would like to receive updates from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum please direct them to https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/mailing-list where they can sign up.

The Leaseholders’ Forum is a volunteer group representing all the leaseholders in Camden Council properties and freeholders paying service charges to Camden Council.  We scrutinise Camden Council proposals, examine working practices and lobby on behalf of leaseholders to Camden Council.  We regard ourselves as an “honest friend” of Camden Council and aim to achieve better outcomes for all.

Minutes from the Leaseholders’ Forum Meeting of 28th March 2013

Welcome to the latest news update from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum

As promised, please find the full minutes (audio version) of David Padfield’s Q&A session at the Leaseholders’ Forum meeting on 28th March.  Click this link to download the WAV audio file.

Regards to all!

Paul Ginsberg
on behalf of Camden Leaseholders’ Forum

If you know of anyone who would like to receive updates from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum please direct them to https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/mailing-list where they can sign up.

The Leaseholders’ Forum is a volunteer group representing all the leaseholders in Camden Council properties and freeholders paying service charges to Camden Council.  We scrutinise Camden Council proposals, examine working practices and lobby on behalf of leaseholders to Camden Council.  We regard ourselves as an “honest friend” of Camden Council and aim to achieve better outcomes for all.

LVT Management Charge Pre-Trial Review meeting update

Welcome to the latest news update from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum

The Pre-Trial Review (PTR) took place on 16th April attended by representatives from Camden Council, the Leaseholders’ Valuation Tribunal (LVT) and about 125 other people.

Here is a note about the day – it is not a cast iron exact blow-by-blow account.
 

16th April

The layout was that the LVT was on a raised stage at the front of the hall on the right hand side, with Camden Leaseholders’ Forum on the left hand side of the raised stage.  Camden Council were also on the left hand side of the raised stage.

Very approximate timetable was as follows:
11am PTR began – introductions & explanations of procedure
11.15am Camden Council explained its application and then answered questions from the audience
11.45am Leaseholders’ Forum (represented by our chair, Peter Wright) explained our position and more questions and points were made by the audience
12.15pm Discussion of direction and a draft timetable was discussed based on the typical template for LVT hearings
1pm Session ended

The timetable was fixed, so there were a number of people who did not have a chance to make a contribution during the course of the PTR itself.  All observations that were sent in advance for the PTR were read in advance by Mr Powell, who led the LVT.
 

From the meeting there were various outcomes of which these were some (in no particular order):

  • – the case was not thrown out (at this stage)
  • – the full case is likely to be heard in February or March 2014.  The exact timetable will also be released in a about a week’s time by LVT; this will include many steps such as when Camden Council will release evidence and what the viewing windows will be for this will be (provisional answer: a 5 week period during August and September later this year).
  • – the format for the case hearing will be very similar to the PTR
  • – it was clarified that even if Camden Council win the LVT then unreasonable future charges can still be taken to the LVT
  • – Camden Council is likely to incur a cost of £30k for the LVT case; they will seek to reclaim a proportionate amount Type B leaseholders (the other proportion falling on Type A leaseholders, but that charge would not be reclaimable in practice due to the existing 10% limit management charge limit in their leases); this will be about £3 per leaseholder
  • – the LVT highlighted that respondents (Leaseholders) and the applicant (Camden Council) are expected to talk to each other and only involve the LVT if there is an impasse (e.g. information not being provided).  The LVT do not seek and do not wish to be copied in to all correspondence
  • – the LVT Chair, Mr Powell, recommended that leaseholders form themselves into groups, in order to limit costs and duplication of documentation.  The groups could be of any size and number initially and no one group – or individual – would be given preference over any other in the eyes of the LVT

 

This is what Camden Leaseholders’ Forum will be doing

  • – this Tuesday, 23rd February, we will be meeting and organising our action place
  • – we will research as much as possible in order to challenge Camden Council’s case that the proposed increase in management charges are reasonable
  • – we will seek further pro-bono legal advice
  • – we will be asking, in due course (but not at this stage), for the names and addresses of those that want to be represented by Camden Leaseholders’ Forum
  • – when the LVT release the directions for the main LVT hearing (expected later this week) we will send out an email to all those on our LVT mailing list to let you the confirmed details

 

That’s it for now!

If you know of anyone who would like to receive updates from Camden Leaseholders’ Forum please direct them to https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/mailing-list where they can sign up.  You can also adjust your own preferences by clicking on the link at the bottom of this email.

Paul Ginsberg
on behalf of Camden Leaseholders’ Forum

The Leaseholders’ Forum is a volunteer group representing all the leaseholders in Camden Council properties and freeholders paying service charges to Camden Council.  We scrutinise Camden Council proposals, examine working practices and lobby on behalf of leaseholders to Camden Council.  We regard ourselves as an “honest friend” of Camden Council and aim to achieve better outcomes for all.

Your opportunity to question Camden Council regarding Leaseholder Service Charges this Thursday

Next Leaseholder Forum Meeting: 6.45pm on Thursday, 28th March at the Council Chamber, Camden Town Hall, Judd Street

STOP PRESS!! David Padfield, Assistant Director (Housing) from Camden  Council, will be coming to this month’s Leaseholders’ Forum meeting to talk about the current LVT case regarding service charges.  He will be presenting the case from Camden Council’s point of view and be available  to answer questions (subject to the time available).  All are welcome.

The full agenda for the meeting is available at: http://democracy.camden.gov.uk/ieListDocuments.aspx?CId=382&MId=47422

This meeting may also be webcast.  Further details will be posted here if they are available in time!

For more details about the Leaseholders’ Forum please see https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk.

Pre-Trial Review: Camden Leaseholders’ Forum Submission to the LVT

See below for Camden Leaseholders’ Forum submission to the Pre-Trial Review, in reference to Case number LON/OOAG/LSC/2012/0791 (i.e. the proposed increase to the management fee element of service charges).  The Pre-Trial Review itself will take place on Monday, 4th April at a venue to be announced.

Should you be affected and wish to be represented at the Pre-Trial Review by Camden Leaseholders’ Forum please see the FAQs and article regarding representation.

1. The case papers refer to respondents being ‘the leaseholders of Camden’. The paper from Camden refers to it being the freeholder of the properties in question. But, in carrying out your instructions to consult, it has only written to type ‘B’ leaseholders. In fact, Camden itself only holds a lease on some of its properties, and there are freeholders of houses on estates paying service charges to Camden. It is not clear from the papers submitted to date who the respondents really are, and whether there are hidden sub-groups of ‘B’ leaseholders who fall to be treated differently, and how they might be handled in the light of any judgment the LVT might make. I submit that the LVT needs reassurance on this point before addressing the issues of the case.

2. It is unclear how Camden proposes to re-coup the costs of the case, and how they might be apportioned between holders of type ‘A’ and type ‘B’ leases. Whatever the LVT is asked to decide on this issue is potentially likely to impact on both types of lease. By failing to contact holders of ‘A’ leases, despite the LVT direction, Camden has deprived them of the opportunity of stating their case on this aspect of the decisions the LVT is likely to have to make in considering Section 20 (c). The LVT may therefore be statutorily obliged to see that they are advised of the case.

3. The timescales imposed on leaseholders have been quite unreasonably short; leaseholders reported receiving their letters from Camden dated 22nd January a week later leaving no real time to consider the issues if they were away or did not have a copy of the lease to hand. Many consulted our Forum on issues we could not respond to; others doubtless called the LVT.

4. The methodology implied in the statement could be construed as transferring costs not recovered from capped ‘A’ leaseholders to ‘B’ leaseholders. The result would effectively be a change to the terms of the type ‘B’ leases as being incompatible with the type ‘A’ leases. Again, if this issue is to be considered by the LVT, ‘A’ leaseholders have to be party to the case. It only arises from the actions of Camden in framing its leases in such a difficult way. I submit that the straightforward way out of this issue is to reject anything that arises from Camden’s current position that entails changing the type ‘B’ leases which it chose to issue.

5. The headings within the charges as set out are unclear, but Camden asserts that it has calculated the sums lost to it. That should mean that calculations showing their methodology exist now. There should be no need to delay producing them until the hearing, making it impossible for the respondents to examine them. I submit that the LVT should order their immediate production, and allow respondents time to group and consider them. If the LVT is inclined to continue with the case despite its hidden elemental purpose of changing the type ‘B’ leases, I suggest it would take at least three months to assemble leaseholders and commission the necessary examination. The alternative is to have 9,300 rushed and separate submissions, assuming it is accepted that both ‘A’ and ‘B’ leaseholders have interests in this case. I therefore request that the LVT provides my Forum with a full contact list for all Camden leaseholders and freeholders paying service charges, giving their property and contact addresses, in a format to allow automatic addressing of mail. We will do what we can (and what leaseholders agree we should) to provide a respondent case.

LVT Frequently Asked Questions

Here are the answers to frequently asked questions that the Leaseholders’ Forum is currently receiving (regarding the current LVT management charge issue).
 

Why was there such a shortfall last year – are wages increased at a special rate for Camden employees? Were the staff numbers increased greatly?

No, the shortfall has existed for some time though we have not seen a convincing breakdown of the figures, or totals for more than the last three years.
 

Will you be asking for a breakdown of costs for the last 5 years so that leaseholders can see what is going on in these departments.

There are some figures which are hard to interpret over a longer timescale which are in the papers for the Scrutiny Panel on Leaseholder Service Charges on the Camden website.  Delving into the past is not a current priority.
 

I know Councils have to cut back their costs – are the leaseholders being used as a ‘milch cow’ for extra money?

Current financial pressures have undoubtledly influenced this move.
 

Why the distinction between Type A and Type B leaseholders?  are Type A people mainly in receipt of benefits and thereby unable to pay more?

No, Camden progressively tightened its leases over the years, so A ones were issued before 1996 and B ones since then.
 

What can I do?

At this stage, the first step is the pre-trial hearing on 20th February.  We recommend that you are represented.  If you would like the Leaseholders’ Forum to represent you please click go to this page: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/2013-02-10/urgent-action-required-for-leaseholders-before-wednesday-13th-february/
 

Why should the Leaseholders’ Forum represent me?

We do feel that it is important for you to be represented at the LVT – either by yourself or someone else you have confidence in.

We do not know who Camden will send; it could be someone from Leaseholder Services, but it could well be a barrister given the importance of this case to them.  We will continuously review the case and seek legal advice.  We will update this website as the case unfolds.  But, we are a voluntary organisation with limited resources and no funds.  Within those constraints, it would help us to engage with the LVT, and could help you, if you choose to let us represent you for as long as you feel comfortable with us doing so.  Our aim is to see that any charges Camden levies are reasonable given all the circumstances, and we are currently far from being able to say that about Camden’s proposals.  Your support will help us to press for the evidence to satisfy all leaseholders about what is proposed.
 

What is the current state of play?

This is the most recent news update from the Leaseholders’ Forum: Posted in News

Urgent Action Required for Leaseholders (update!) regarding Service Charges and the Leasehold Valuation Tribunal

[updated 7th March 2013 with the confirmed Pre Trial Hearing date]

Dear Leaseholder,

ACTION REQUIRED FOR CAMDEN LEASEHOLDERS

You may have recently received a letter from Camden Council entitled “Leasehold Valuation Tribunal”.  This has been sent to all Camden Council leaseholders (and freeholders) who have leases issued from (approximately) 1996. Camden Council believes that leases prior to 1996 are unaffected. A sample copy of the letter is available at https://www.dropbox.com/s/sl4fubjfdosbga4/130124%20Service%20Charge%20Notification.pdf?dl=0 (n.b. this is an 11mb download, so may take a minute or so to open).

The letter informs you that Camden Council has started legal proceeding which will ultimately remove the cap on the management element of your service charge. The effect of all this is that Camden Council would raise your service charge by around £200 (these figures will vary slightly, depending on where you live) in 2013/14 and possibly further amounts thereafter.

Camden Leaseholders Forum is the only body that currently represents all Camden Leaseholders. We will be attending the hearing on 16th< April [editor’s note: previously scheduled for 4th April] and making representations to allow us to learn more about this proposed increase, discuss the detail with you (affected leaseholders) and oppose it firmly if it proves unfair. We are discussing the issue with LEASE (http://www.lease-advice.org) who are funded by Government and provide free advice on the law affecting residential leasehold property in England and Wales.
 

Are you affected?

Camden Council have sent letters to all leaseholders that have been affected; if you have not received a letter you are unaffected. The Leaseholders’ Forum has not been provided with a list of the leaseholders affected so cannot verify this. If you would like to double check whether you are affected you can contact Camden Council (leaseholderservices@camden.gov.uk / 020 7974 3559, selecting Option 6) and they will be able to let you know.
 

Next steps – for those that have not responded so far

If you wish to represent yourselves at the hearing on 16th April you need to let the Leasehold Valuation Tribunal know before that date (and they would prefer sooner rather than later, in order to help with their logistics).

The postal address is Ms Margaret Egenti, London Rent Assessment Panel, Leasehold Valuation Tribunal, 10 Alfred Place, London, WC1E 7LR and email address is london.rap@hmcts.gsi.gov.uk. They will only accept letters of representation by post or email – all other submissions must come in by letter only and copy in Leaseholder Services, Camden Council, Bidborough House, 38-50 Bidborough Street, London, WC1H 9DB.

If you cannot or do not wish to attend, do consider letting the Leaseholders’ Forum represent you at this stage. To be represented by the Leaseholders’ Forum simply email in this attached letter (https://www.dropbox.com/s/rry252v1q6nzkyy/130225%20LVT%20nomination%20request.doc?dl=0) to london.rap@hmcts.gsi.gov.uk (and CC camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk and leaseholderservices@camden.gov.uk) before 16th April, making sure to put your name and address where appropriate at the bottom of the letter.
 

Next steps – for those that have already responded

If you have already responded and requested to be represented at the original Pre-Trial hearing date of 20th February, then these requests are still valid for the new date of 16th April – so you don’t have to do anything. The Leaseholders’ Forum has additionally applied for a Section 20C which may help towards deferring Camden Council’s legal costs from being added to leaseholders’ service charge bills for all the parties that we are representing (other parties are advised to apply separately to be included on any Section 20C decision).
 

Staying in the loop!

We will keep all the parties we are represented up to date by email. Should you not wish to be represented by the Leaseholders’ Forum but still wish to be kept up to date with our progress and other issues of interest to leaseholders simply email camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk with “Subscribe” in the title of the message.

The Leaseholders’ Forum initial submission to the pre-trial LVT hearing can be read here: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/2013-02-26/pre-trial-review-camden-leaseholders-forum-submission-to-the-lvt/
 

About the Leaseholders’ Forum

For more information about the Leaseholder Forum and also how to get involved please see https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk

Wednesday’s Pre-Trial Review Postponement

We (the Leaseholders’ Forum) have just received an email from the Leasehold Valuation Tribunal (LVT) in regards to the Pre-Trial Review that was originally due on 20th February.  The review has now been postponed until 4th April.  The email is displayed at the end of this update for your reference.  For the background on this case please see: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/2013-02-10/urgent-action-required-for-leaseholders-before-wednesday-13th-february/.

This is very much a developing situation and it will be a number of days before we can fully interpret the potential implications and options that the postponement presents.  As soon as there is more useful information available we will of course update our website at https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk.

In the meantime we particularly note that the email from LVT states “that no email correspondence will be accepted in this case”.  As the original deadline for responses (13th February) has already passed, it is unlikely to make any material difference to communications already sent to the LVT.  In our next update we will advise on whether responses already sent (such as the representation requests already emailed into london.rap@hmcts.gsi.gov.uk) need to be also be sent by post and whether any further representations requests about the Pre Trial Review will be accepted if sent in.

Should you wish to be emailed when there is more advice from the Leaseholders’ Forum simply email camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk with “subscribe” in the title.  All those who have already asked the Leaseholders’ Forum to represent them at the Pre-Trial Review will also be updated at this time (so no need to email us again!).

Camden Council has also posted an update (https://www.dropbox.com/s/e2od5vbu5vo8lfp/Camden%20FAQs.pdf?dl=0) and, again, the Leaseholders’ Forum will consider this information as part of its deliberations.

Yours sincerely,
Paul Ginsberg
on behalf of the Leaseholders’ Forum
For more information please see: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk
 

EMAIL RECEIVED TODAY (15th February) FROM LEASEHOLDER VALUATION TRIBUNAL

Dear Sir/Madam

Thank you for your recent correspondence.

A Procedural Chairman of the Tribunal has asked me to write to you.

As the number of Respondents who have confirmed they wish to attend the pre-trial review scheduled on 20 February 2013 exceeds the capacity of our largest hearing room the pre-trial review is postponed as there is insufficient time to notify all Respondents of a change of venue.

Camden will be contacting all leaseholders shortly with confirmation of the venue and date.

ALL correspondence to the Tribunal should be sent by post, fax (5 pages or less) or both ONLY and must be copied to the other party.  No email correspondence will be accepted in this case.

Regards
Ms M Egenti
Case Officer
LVT
020 7446 7806

Urgent Action Required for Leaseholders! (before Wednesday, 13th February)

Dear Leaseholder,

ACTION REQUIRED FOR CAMDEN LEASEHOLDERS (BY WEDNESDAY, 13th FEBRUARY)

You may have recently received a letter from Camden Council entitled “Leasehold Valuation Tribunal”.  This has been sent to all Camden Council leaseholders (and freeholders) who have leases issued from (approximately) 1996.  Camden Council believes that leases prior to 1996 are unaffected.  A sample copy of the letter is available at https://www.dropbox.com/s/sl4fubjfdosbga4/130124%20Service%20Charge%20Notification.pdf?dl=0 (n.b. this is an 11mb download, so may take a minute or so to open).

The letter informs you that Camden Council has started legal proceeding which will ultimately remove the cap on the management element of your service charge.  The effect of all this is that Camden Council would raise your service charge by around £200 (these figures will vary slightly, depending on where you live) in 2013/14 and possibly further amounts thereafter.

Camden Leaseholders Forum is the only body that currently represents all Camden Leaseholders.  We will be attending the hearing on 20th February and making representations to allow us to learn more about this proposed increase, discuss the detail with you (affected leaseholders) and oppose it firmly if it proves unfair.  As we, ourselves, were only notified in the same letters that were sent out on 24th January we have had limited time to prepare, but we are already discussing this with LEASE and we are currently preparing to mount a defence.  LEASE are funded by Government and they provide free advice on the law affecting residential leasehold property in England and Wales.
 

Next steps

If you wish to represent yourselves at the hearing on 20th January you need to let the Leasehold Valuation Tribunal know by the 13th February. Their postal address is Ms Margaret Egenti, London Rent Assessment Panel, Leasehold Valuation Tribunal, 10 Alfred Place, London, WC1E 7LR and email is london.rap@hmcts.gsi.gov.uk.

If you cannot or do not wish to attend, please consider letting the Leaseholder Forum represent you at this stage.  It will make your voice heard in seeking information and give you the chance to defend your interests.  To support us simply email in this letter to london.rap@hmcts.gsi.gov.uk (and CC camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk to let us know) by 13th February, making sure to put your name and address where appropriate at the bottom of the letter.

After the 20th, please see https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk as we will keep that website up to date with all the developments!

Also, do feel free to send this message on to any other leaseholders who you think might be affected.
 

About the Leaseholders Forum

For more information about the Leaseholder Forum and also how to get involved please see https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk.

Yours sincerely,
Paul Ginsberg

on behalf of the Leaseholders’ Forum
For more information please see: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk

Leaseholder Valuation Tribunal and service charges

Please come back to this page soon!  We expect to have information by Friday evening (8th Feb) about what we (the Leaseholders’ Forum) recommend you do to fight the recent letter from Camden Council in regards to raising service charge fees from 10% to 30% (which could mean an increase in £200 in the annual service charge).

In the meantime, feel free to start a discussion. [editor’s note: older Discussion Board posts were not migrated when we changed sites in 2015]

UPDATE: 8th February.  Responses to the letter need to be in by Wednesday, 13th February but can be made by email.  Given this information the Leaseholders’ Forum are now using the extra time given to us to put more effort into our next steps.  Look out for our update on the afternoon of Sunday (10th February).