Camden Leaseholders’ Forum homepage › Discussion Board › Service Charges › Extortionate service charges
- This topic has 111 replies, 36 voices, and was last updated 2 years, 9 months ago by checko.
-
AuthorPosts
-
19th March 2023 at 20:48 #6772
Hi
I have just sent the following e-mail to the leaseholders e-mail address (camdenleaseholderservices@camden.gov.uk. Please feel free to adapt and use. Hopefully, they might act on this if enough people get involved. I’m going to draft a letter to my local councillor tomorrow and will post the contents of that on here too:
Dear Sir/Madam,
I am writing to express my deep concern regarding the leaseholder service charges that have doubled since last year. As a resident of the Charlton Court Estate on Brecknock Road, I am appalled by the fact that we are being charged for services that do not take place, such as cleaning and maintenance. Moreover, the cost for gas/heating/hot water has risen from £1186 to £3186, which is well above the average for a two bed flat, despite the government energy price cap remaining in place. British Gas states that the average gas bill for a 3 bedroom house currently is £1383 per annum yet I am being charged more than £3000 for a small 2 bed flat at a time when wholesale prices for gas are dropping and the government support is set to remain in place. This is extortionate and I would request that this is reviewed immediately and that leaseholders are charged in line with actual projections for energy costs rather than this abritrarily massive figure that seems to have been plucked from the air. Camden Council widely advertises their supposed support for its’ residents during the cost of living crisis, however, their willingness to charge these inflated prices clearly demonstrates a complete lack of care and empathy for Camden residents.
I find it very unfair that we are being charged for services that are not being provided to us. The cleaning and maintenance services that we are being charged for have not been carried out, and it is not justifiable for us to pay for them. We have been paying for these services in good faith, and it is unacceptable that we have not received them. Some of the questionable work is described below. I look forward to receiving a detailed account from you in regards to how these costs were incurred:
£415 block cost for TV aerial: No work has been done to tv aerials on the estate. What is the predicted cost here for?
£16,560.53 block cost for Caretaking Services: There is a notice up on the estate describing daily caretaking services that should be being carried out. They are not happening and there are parts of the estate that have never been cleaned in the 6 years I have lived here
Block (£3656) and Estate (£1779) charges for electricity: The estate only consists of one block so why are we being charged twice for estate wide electricity? What are these charges for?
Tree Maintenace £5012: In the six years that I have lived on the estate the only work ever done on any trees was 2 small trees being planted at the front of the estate. What specific work is the council predicting that is going to cost £5012
Lighting costs for block and estate: Same as the electricity above, where is the estate wide lighting that isn’t part of the one block?
Refuse £1436: The bins are permanently overflowing and only ever removed when the bin men, who we pay for through council tax, clear them. What is this charge specifically for?
Estate Roads and Footpaths £964.62: No roads on the estate and no work has been compoleted on any footpaths in the time that I have lived here. What is this predicted charge for specifically?I urge you to take immediate action and investigate the reasons behind the increase in service charges. It is our right as leaseholders to receive the services that we are paying for, and we should not be charged for services that are not being provided. We also expect transparency in the billing process, and we should be able to see a breakdown of the costs that we are being charged.
I am a member of the Camden Leaseholders Forum and I know that this problem is widespread across Camden. I and many other members of the forum will be contacting Local Counsillors as well as the local press in order to expediate a prompt and thorough investigation and review of these most recent Camden Leaseholder charges.
In conclusion, I kindly request that you take our concerns seriously and take appropriate action to resolve the issue. I hope that you will do everything possible to ensure that leaseholders are treated fairly and that we are charged only for the services that we receive and that we are charged a fair price for our gas, heating and hot water.
Yours faithfully,
[insert name]
20th March 2023 at 16:20 #6774Camden’s communal energy supply contracts… AND support offered by Camden
My building requires gas for the communal heating boiler and electricity to power lifts, door entry, lighting to common areas, boiler controls and pumps. This is communal energy and is quite separate from the domestic electricity and gas I use in my flat.Camden buys communal electricity (supplier is Npower) and gas (supplier is Total Energies) through energy buyer Laser. Until last October some properties (mine included) were supplied electricity by SSE.
Laser buys tranches of energy for the following year up to 36 months prior to the October start of the annual supply period. It aims to buy when there is a dip in the market (at lower prices), in accordance with its risk managed forward purchasing strategy.
Prices are fixed at the beginning of each annual supply period which is from 1 October to 30 September. This means that the energy price affecting our service charge billing changes halfway through the financial year (1 April to 31 March). So, the charge for energy is partly at old rate and partly at new rate.Year ending 31 March 2023
For year ending 31 March 2023 the energy price was partly set in October 2021 (for March 2022 – September 2022) and partly set in October 2022 (October 2022 to March 2023). Camden knew the unit prices for the first 6 months but had to estimate those for the second period when billing us in March 2022 for the estimated cost of energy for year just ending. Camden now knows the likely actual cost and says it has added 50% to this to estimate the cost for the next year, from April 2023 to March 2024. Working these numbers back, it looks as if I must brace myself for an additional £1,000 charge for heating when I receive the billing for actual costs this September.Bulk gas has seen a huge price hike for the new Contract period October 2022 to September 2023. The new gas price increased by 318% (from 2.04 to 8.53 pence per kiloWatt hour – that’s four times more expensive). The daily standing charge increased by 76%. The Government’s EBRS support scheme does appear to shave 1.5p/kWh off this figure, from October to March. But the new EBDS support package from April 2023 is less generous and does not appear to offer us any price reduction.
The gas used for our communal boiler is billed from March to February. So, for the service charge period, 5 months are at the old rate and 7 months at the new rate. I note that our gas costs make up over 80% of the total energy cost (electricity just under 20%).
Camden apportions electricity costs to heating, communal areas and lifts (where these apply – and in my case at 50%, 30% and 20% respectively). Last October my supplier changed from SSE to Npower and communal electricity increased by 57% (from 17.03 to 26.78 pence per kiloWatt hour). My daily standing charge increased to £1.07.
Year ending 31 March 2024
The day to day estimated service charge billing we have just received is for year ending 31 March 2024. Camden only knows the unit prices for the first 6 months and Laser has provided no estimate for October 2023 to March 2024. Camden says it has estimated the energy cost for year ending March 2024 based on the expected 2022/23 outturn and adding 50%.My conclusions
Having modelled the sums, I was hoping to be able to say that Camdens 50% increase on this year’s outturn appears unjustifiable. Bad news! I’m afraid this is not the case.
Unless Laser buys the new contracts in October 2023 at significantly lower wholesale prices, Camden appears to have got it about right.
And be prepared for a shock additional energy charge in the actual costs billed next September, for year ending March 2023.Support offered by Camden
At the Leaseholders’ Forum meeting last week Geraldine Littlechild (acting Head of Leaseholder Services) spoke about the assistance which Camden is offering to leaseholders to support them with the payment of the estimated heating charge.1. Leaseholders may pay the charge by 12 monthly instalments (extended from the usual 10 monthly payments).
2. Leaseholders may apply to have payment of the heating element of the estimated charge extended to a longer period, tailored to specific needs. Camden will require the leaseholder to provide details of their income and expenditure for review before deciding whether a longer repayment period will be offered.
3. Leaseholders who are on a communal heating system and who are also required to pay major works bills may apply to have the major works bill frozen, to be paid at a later time. Camden will require the leaseholder to provide details of their income and expenditure for review before deciding whether freezing a major works bill will be offered.
4. Camden will conduct a mid-year review of heating costs to see if payments might be reduced.
5. Any leaseholder who wishes to seek this support should appply to leaseholderservices@camden.gov.uk as soon as possible. Those leaseholders who wish to apply for extended payment terms for the heating element of their service charge do not need to be residing in their property.
20th March 2023 at 16:23 #6773It would have been better handled if the Council had sent out letters/emails to all leaseholders alerting them to these massive increases rather than just post them out without any forewarning – I did expect to pay an increase but I was deeply shocked to have a £1,500 increase, plus there are major works planned for next year amount to £25K for each flat.
Can someone please let me know – have renters received a massive hike in their rents – if not it is deeply unfair that the leaseholders are baring the brunt – this communal heating system is a joke – I pay when I’m away working, yet the people next door have 3 children, are home all day with the heating on – I feel as though I am subsidising them. I 100% regret buying this flat, and to think that we were led to believe that council housing was affordable. At this rate I will be plunged into debt soon.
20th March 2023 at 16:42 #6765Awful to hear about how this is impacting Camden leaseholders. To add my voice, I live in a 1 bed flat in Palgrave House, Fleet Road. Our estimated service charge has gone up by 57% from £2355 (2022-2023) to £3701 (2023-2024)! It’s unjustifyable. Is there soemthing we can do as a group to campaign against this?
Issued 18 March at 20:06 (apologies for delayed publication) – Manager
20th March 2023 at 17:26 #6779Hi all – my new heating and hot water estimate is £5,000 – it is extortionate bearing in mind communal heating is turned off from 1st May until October….
20th March 2023 at 17:36 #6789Whatever the system Camden uses for purchasing and apportioning costs for gas is clearly broken if leaseholders are being so many thousands of pounds for gas when many of us are using so little of it in reality. I intend to fight this every step of the way and hope that others wlil to.
21st March 2023 at 09:00 #6791Please count me in if there is an emergency meeting. And thank you for all the helpful comments. I shall be writing to both the Council and my MP.
21st March 2023 at 16:59 #6794Jennifer,
I agree with your comments and suggestions above.
Is there a chir of leaseholders we could approach with this?21st March 2023 at 21:30 #6795Thanks everyone for the information shared. That’s a very useful template, Harvinho. It’s certainly not surprising to see that a lot of us are deeply shocked.
Manager has provided some useful information – thanks. However, I don’t think it addresses the central issue, which is how it is justifiable for Camden Council to charge heating that is more than double what one might expect to pay nationally for a flat of that size. You say:
My conclusions
Having modelled the sums, I was hoping to be able to say that Camdens 50% increase on this year’s outturn appears unjustifiable. Bad news! I’m afraid this is not the case.I would ask that you be very specific about how you did your modelling, especially in light of what you also say here: Working these numbers back, it looks as if I must brace myself for an additional £1,000 charge for heating when I receive the billing for actual costs this September.
To me, it seems like there are two possibilities:
1. Camden did not secure a good deal for energy prices. Why not? What was involved in this? Are the projected costings justifiable?2. If this can be shown beyond a shadow of a doubt, i.e., that X amount of gas was used and that it was secured at a good price, then I suppose that we come to the issue that some have already mentioned – why is it that so much was used and who is turning on the heating all the time? I have read that meters are being installed in some places (mine is not in the list). This would be the obvious solution to the problem of low heating use leaseholders being made to subside others (leaseholders and non-leaseholders).
I feel like this may be the fairest way forward, even if energy prices are falling. One thing that Camden needs to avoid doing here – I’m saying this just in case – is charging leaseholders for installing the meters. Imagine if British Gas users were told that they had to pay hundreds or thousands of pounds just for the privilege of having a meter reading and that if they did not do this, they were likely to face astronomical bills well beyond the kWh that they actually used!Finally, would anyone like to share information about supportive Councillors or MPs that they have reached (since there’s quite a list of Councillors)?
22nd March 2023 at 10:55 #6796@manager forgive me if I’ve calculated this wrong but if the unit price has increased to 8.53p per kw/h and I’m being charged £3186 Camden are estimating that I’m going to use 37,482 kw/h equivalent of gas. Ofgem has the average gas use for a 4+ bedroom house at 17000 kwh per annum. This then suggests that I’m being charged for the gas that would be used to heat an 8 bedroom mansion (I live in a 2 bed flat). I’m not sure how much the daily standing charge is but do seem to remember seeing that it could account for up to a third of the charge, which would mean that I’m still being charged for 25,000 kwh of gas use (more than double the national average).
22nd March 2023 at 11:49 #6797In answer to Parrhesiast’s query about councillors I have spoken to both Sylvia MacNamara and James Slater and found them willing to listen and – hopefully – follow-up our concerns. Hope this helps.
22nd March 2023 at 15:51 #6798Im also in favour of joining an emergency meeting to support fellow leaseholders. I have a studio flat in Clerkenwell and SC has increased by £500 this year – so not as significant as others, but its the biggest jump to date and it will only continue to increae.
22nd March 2023 at 19:20 #6800Thanks Jennifer. Keen to see if we can get some traction on this.
23rd March 2023 at 11:28 #6801Thank you, Jennifer. That is helpful to know.
23rd March 2023 at 15:50 #6802Further to my posted reply #6774 on 16 March at 16:20
@Parrhesiast asks that I “be very specific about how you did your modelling”.I have asked to see Camden’s calculations for my estimated heating charge for year ending 31 March 2024. I imagine they must be swamped with enquiries and don’t expect an answer anytime soon.
So, here are my calculations for my own heating service charge.HEATING COSTS APPORTIONED TO MY FLAT
YE 31 March 2022 Electric £107 Gas £645 Repairs £0 Maintain £143 Total £896
YE 31 March 2023 Electric £245 Gas £1,541 Repairs £0 Maintain £156 Total £1,943 Billed Est £1,185
YE 31 March 2024 Electric £309 Gas £2,618 Repairs £0 Maintain £170 Total £3,097 Billed Est £3,240PREDICTING MY ADDITIONAL HEATING COST FOR YE 2023
Heating Estimate YE 2024 £3,240 (based on expected outturn YE 2023 + 50%)
So, YE 2023 expected outturn = £2,160 (= 3240 / 3 x 2)
Less YE 2023 estimated heating £1,185
YE 2023 anticipated additional £975 (due in actual costs to be billed September 2023 ?)SUMMARY of MY BULK GAS COSTS – BLOCK COSTS (10 flats)
1/3/20 – 30/9/20 92842 kWh Fuel 1 £1,807 Standing 1 £858
1/10/20 – 28/2/21 139056 kWh Fuel 2 £1,815 Standing 2 £666
Actual Gas used = 231898 kWh Fuel yr £3,622 Standing yr £1,524
YE 31 March 2021 Total £5,1461/3/21 – 30/9/21 117796 kWh Fuel 1 £1,538 Standing 1 £944
1/10/21 – 28/2/22 118002 kWh Fuel 2 £2,407 Standing 2 £779
Actual Gas used = 235798 kWh Fuel yr £3,944 Standing yr £1,723
YE 31 March 2022 Total £5,6671/3/22 – 30/9/22 105319 kWh Fuel 1 £2,148 Standing 1 £1,104
1/10/22 – 28/2/23 128529 kWh Fuel 2 £9,038 Standing 2 £1,371
Avg of YE 21 & 22 233848 kWh Fuel yr £11,186 Standing yr £2,475
YE 31 March 2023 Total £13,6611/3/23 – 30/9/23 105319 kWh Fuel 1 £8,985 Standing 1 £1,943
1/10/23 – 29/2/24 128529 kWh Fuel 2 £10,966 Standing 2 £1,371
Avg of YE 21 & 22 233848 kWh Fuel yr £19,951 Standing yr £3,314
YE 31 March 2024 Total £23,265SUMMARY of MY COMMUNAL ELECTRICITY COSTS – BLOCK COSTS
(Note: Until recently my kWh billing was based on estimated readings…
**For these calculations, I have used kWh usage data from previous years)1/4/20 – 30/9/20 9000 kWh Fuel 1 £900 Standing 1 £6
1/10/20 – 31/3/21 9000 kWh Fuel 2 £900 Standing 2 £6
Average Elec used** 18000 kWh Fuel yr £1,800 Standing yr £11
YE 31 March 2021 £1,8111/4/21 – 30/9/21 9000 kWh Fuel 1 £900 Standing 1 £6
1/10/21 – 31/3/22 9000 kWh Fuel 2 £900 Standing 2 £6
Average Elec used** 18000 kWh Fuel yr £1,800 Standing yr £11
YE 31 March 2022 £1,8111/4/22 – 30/9/22 9000 kWh Fuel 1 £1,533 Standing 1 £6
1/10/22 – 31/3/23 9000 kWh Fuel 2 £2,410 Standing 2 £195
Average Elec used** 18000 kWh Fuel yr £3,943 Standing yr £201
YE 31 March 2023 £4,1441/4/23 – 30/9/23 9000 kWh Fuel 1 £2,410 Standing 1 £195
1/10/23 – 31/3/24 9000 kWh Fuel 2 £2,410 Standing 2 £195
Average Elec used** 18000 kWh Fuel yr £4,820 Standing yr £391
YE 31 March 2024 £5,211And, on the subject of HEAT METERS…
My building (10 flats) was part of a project in Spring 2018 to install Plant/Block levels meters on 80 estates across the Borough. The cost for our block was £2,700 and I received a demand for my share of the cost. It is the total energy usage which is measured, not the use by individual residents.I was told that energy consumption readings are transmitted to a central facility, via a private and secure wireless network, for monitoring and billing. The meter is designed to analyse the exchange of energy between boiler output and delivery to the residential units in the block. The information gathered will be used by Camden’s Energy Efficiency and Performance Team to try and make the exchange of energy more efficient and ultimately more cost effective also.
I hope this helps.
23rd March 2023 at 23:00 #6803@Manager, I think Harvinho’s line of questioning above is a productive one so I encourage you to expand on things in that way.
You have for YE Mar 23 this total for gas:
Avg of YE 21 & 22 233848 kWh Fuel yr £11,186 Standing yr £2,475
YE 31 March 2023 Total £13,661That means that for the individual, it is one tenth of that (given 10 flats). So each flat has been apportioned 23384.8 kwh. According to British gas, however, annual consumption for a 1-2 bedroom flat is only 8000 kwh and it is 12000 kwh for a 3 bedroom house. Now, I do not know any particular details concerning your flat but mine does not have any heating in communal areas to justify anything outside the flat size itself.
https://www.britishgas.co.uk/energy/guides/average-bill.htmlThis kind of energy consumption figure seems exceedingly high. I would say unreasonable. A 5 bedroom house still is only at 17000 kwh. And that is an average figure, so it would of course be lower for prudent gas users.
I now understand more about the meters, given what you have said. I had thought that our existing billed figures for actual costs were based on real expenditure pertaining to the block. It seems that this is what they are actually aiming for. It would not therefore solve the issue (given the costs that we have now, which are comparatively so much more than what we have been used to), even when implemented, of some people subsiding others in the same block.
If I have misunderstood anything, please let me know. Thanks for the information that you have kindly provided.
24th March 2023 at 12:24 #6804GOVERNMENT SUPPORT
We need to remember that the cost of supply of gas and electricity recharged by Camden is not covered by the Government’s support for domestic users because they are seen as commercial/business supplies. The Government has separately provided a business support package (EBRS) for the period from October 2022 to March 2023. But as our gas price is only just over the cap it only shaves 1.5 pence of the price of a kilowatt hour. Electricity energy supply prices are made up of…Camden has explained that delivered p/kWh unit rates for electricity are made up of the cost of the energy itself (wholesale costs), plus the pass through of third-party costs, such as regulated network charges (the cost of transporting energy) and green levies. The capped element of the Government’s Energy Business Relief Scheme (EBRS) applies only to the energy component of delivered prices and not the third-party costs (the cap also doesn’t apply to any standing charge elements of the bill). Camden’s purchased electricity rate for the period 1 Oct 22 to 31 Sep 23 is approximately 17p/kWh, which is below the Government cap of 21.1 p/kWh, so we are not eligible for relief under EBRS. Third-party costs make up the remaining c.10 p/kWh.
From April 2023 the EBRS will be replaced by the Government’s Energy Bill Discount Scheme (EBDS), which will run for 12 months until March 2024. As of 23 January 2023, LASER (Camden’s public sector buying organisation for gas and energy supplies) suggest that based on the current market conditions and purchased volumes for April 2023 – March 2024, Camden’s energy contracts will not be eligible for EBDS support, as the wholesale commodity cost is forecast to be below the set thresholds and are unlikely to qualify for any support.
HEATING / HOT WATER / GAS
It seems to me that if my building has used a quantity of gas then Camden may charge the leaseholders in the building their share of the cost of supplying that gas in accordance with their lease. In my case I can see no argument that Camden has been negligent in its procurement. And the fact that I cannot control the amount of heat that the other 9 residents choose to use is something I should have been aware of when I signed the lease. Perhaps we might at some stage change to a system where I am metered for the energy I personally use (see Heat Meters below) but even this change would be disruptive and expensive.Camden apportions the heating costs to each leaseholder based on the system type and number of bedrooms. For example, We have two bedrooms whilst some flats have only one so although there are 10 flats we are charged slightly more than 1/10. I would also note that our boiler only provides heating and not hot water.
Gas usage for heating will depend upon the boiler and system efficiency, the thermal efficiency of the building, period of operation, residents’ desire to reduce costs (and perhaps the ratio of leaseholders to tenants). So it seems to me that one cannot rely upon a British Gas guide (albeit interesting) to support an argument that Camden’s heating charges are extortionate (if by that we mean “more expensive than is reasonable”).
The quantity of gas used will also depend upon its purpose. There are various types of communal systems supplying heating, hot water or cooking gas or combinations of these. The heating section of the Camden Service Charge Guide here is very informative.
MORE ABOUT HEAT METERS
The Camden Service Charge Guide says about heat meters:
The Heat Network (Metering and Billing) Regulations 2014 requires all homes on a district heating network to have a heat meter where it is possible. We have been rolling out a long-term programme to install heat meters in our homes in line with these Regulations and our Camden Plan to reduce carbon emissions in the borough. A heat meter accurately measures the energy you use to heat your home and the hot water you use. It means we can charge you accurately for the energy you use and you can monitor how much energy you are using. [These will give you control over your own usage. They are not the same as the Plant/Block level meters which I mentioned before]KNOW YOUR LEASE
What Camden can include in the day-to-day service charge is covered in the lease. Camden has are a number of lease types in use.
An example, if the lease says:
“Provided only that the amenities hereinafter in this sub-clause mentioned are provided to all the Flats in the Building at the date hereof but not otherwise and subject as hereinafter set out at all times during the Term to supply hot water for domestic purpose to the Flat by means of the boiler and heating installations serving the Building and also from the 1st October to the 30th April inclusive in each year to supply hot water for heating to the radiators fixed in the Flat so as to maintain a reasonable and normal temperature”
Then the leaseholder should not be required to pay for heating between 1 May and 30 September, should Camden decide to leave it running during the summer months.There are also statutory protections for leaseholders (such as reasonableness)… but that is another story.
@Harvinho asks “Block (£3656) and Estate (£1779) charges for electricity: The estate only consists of one block so why are we being charged twice for estate wide electricity? What are these charges for?”ELECTRICITY USAGE APPORTIONED
Camden apportions the electricty used across the estate and this may be what is happening here? The Inspection File should show this? The Inspection File, which Camden provides to those who request it following actual costs billing in September, contains information about how the summarised costs are made up and the relevant invoices.24th March 2023 at 14:02 #6806The issue of energy price increases was discussed at length at the CLF on 14 March.
The detail of their calculations on energy is here: https://www.camden.gov.uk/service-charge-insurance-and-freeholders#vmcnosuw
Geraldine said that leaseholders should use the camdenleaseholderservices@camden.gov.uk email to request a payment plan.
The CLF summary of what was said is below. Geraldine has confirmed this is correct.
1. Leaseholders may pay the charge by 12 monthly instalments (extended from the usual 10 monthly payments)
2. Leaseholders may apply to have payment of the heating element of the estimated charge extended to a longer period, tailored to specific needs. Camden will require the leaseholder to provide details of their income and expenditure for review before deciding whether a longer repayment period will be offered.
3. Leaseholders who are on a communal heating system and who are also required to pay major works bills may apply to have the major works bill frozen, to be paid at a later time. Camden will require the leaseholder to provide details of their income and expenditure for review before deciding whether freezing a major works bill will be offered.
4. Camden will conduct a mid-year review of heating costs to see if payments might be reduced.
As you can imagine they have a large volume of calls/emails so you may have to wait.
CLF is sending out an email update next week – if you aren’t already on the email list then email camden@leaseholdersforum.org.uk
Carolyn (CLF chair)
26th March 2023 at 20:52 #6816Please read and register in
Leighday.co.uk26th March 2023 at 20:56 #6817@manager If the fact that so many leaseholders with 1/2 bedroom flats are being charged for the amount of gas that would normally be used in a 5+ bedroom house than there very clearly is a problem here that Camden needs to investigate and set right. I don’t believe that you or any of us should be happy to settle for these astronomical charges; if, as you state, this is as a result of boiler and/or building inefficiency than Camden needs to urgently fix its boilers. I very much doubt that it is as a result of thermal efficiency of the building when you take into account the thermal efficiency of the average 5+ bedroom house, many of which are older properties. Whatever the circumstances are that have led to leaseholders being charged for such disproportionately high gas usage, need to be investigated and set right by Camden, in my opinion.
28th March 2023 at 17:02 #6838@manager how can I get hold of this inspection file? I asked leaseholder services for it and they sent me the last fire risk assessment on my estate (not helpful). They have also responded to my initial e-mail to them without answering any of the questions I posed.
28th March 2023 at 17:41 #6837I live on the Holly Lodge Estate in a small 2 bedroom flat.
We have just received our new estimated Service Charge up from 3k to now 5k.
Hot water and heating element is costed out at 3k.
And this Council are still intent on replacing gas boilers with new gas boilers.
It’s a blank cheque backed up with threats and demands by a failed authority.28th March 2023 at 18:04 #6840@harvinho I fear there is no quick fix to reduce gas consumption, except for everyone to demand less heat. The Forum has set up a working group to explore this issue and to identify Camden’s progress with the heating network conversions enabling residents to be individually metered.
With regard to the Actual Costs Inspection File, this should be requested in October when the actual costs are billed. For last year’s costs, Camden may be prepared to assist you if a leaseholder in your building has already requested it.
28th March 2023 at 18:05 #6841I have written to James Slater and Sylvia Mcnamara (my local councillors) and have included the text below: please feel free to use and adapt. Local councillors can be found here: https://www.camden.gov.uk/find-your-ward-and-ward-map . I am going to encourage more leaseholders on my estate to do the same and feel that the more voices being heard in regard to this issue, the more likely it is to at least be investigated. I’ve also written to the Camden New Journal and Ham and High (who ran a story on this in 2021) requesting that they consider an investigation into Camden service charges.
Letter to councillor:
Dear [insert councillor’s name]I am writing to you today to express my deep concern over the exorbitant council service charges that are being imposed on leaseholders in our local area. As someone who has been a resident in Camden for several years, I have noticed a disturbing trend of rising service charges, which is placing a heavy financial burden on many of us. The service charge bill I have just received for 2023/34 is £[insert figure] compared to £[insert figure] the previous year
In particular, I would like to draw your attention to the astronomical increase in the cost of gas, which has trebled since last year. This sudden surge in prices has hit many leaseholders hard, and it is becoming increasingly difficult for them to keep up with the payments. The cost for gas/heating/hot water has risen from £1186 to £3186, which is well above the average for a two bed flat, despite the government energy price cap remaining in place. British Gas states that the average gas bill for a 3 bedroom house currently is £1383 per annum yet I am being charged more than £3000 for a small 2 bed flat at a time when wholesale prices for gas are dropping and the government support is set to remain in place. This is extortionate and I would request that this is reviewed immediately and that leaseholders are charged in line with actual projections for energy costs rather than this seemingly arbitrary figure. Camden Council widely advertises their supposed support for its’ residents during the cost of living crisis, however, their willingness to charge these inflated prices clearly demonstrates a complete lack of care and empathy for Camden residents.
These exorbitant service charges also render all leaseholder properties unsaleable for at least the next year as the service charge is over £500 per month as well as mortgage rates being particularly high at the moment.
It is my belief that the council has a duty to provide its residents with services that are affordable and sustainable, and I am deeply concerned that these recent increases are not in line with that principle. As someone who has been elected to represent the interests of the people in our area, I urge you to investigate this matter thoroughly and to take action to ensure that the council service charges are fair and reasonable.
I would like to request that you take the following actions:
· Conduct a thorough investigation into the recent increases in council service charges for leaseholders, including the sudden surge in gas prices.
· Ensure that the council is transparent in its charging policies, so that leaseholders can understand how their fees are calculated and what they are paying for.
· Work to develop a fair and sustainable charging policy for council services, which takes into account the needs and financial constraints of leaseholders in our area.
I believe that it is imperative that our local government takes steps to address this issue, and I hope that you will use your position to help bring about positive change.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Yours sincerely,
[Insert name]28th March 2023 at 18:21 #6842@manager Who would I actually contact for the Inspection File? is it leaseholderservices@camden.org.uk. Regarding gas consumption, I don’t think it is a problem of the level consumption so much as a miscalculation in how much gas Camden estimates that estates/residents are using. It would be interesting to hear from someone who has already had a heat meter fitted by Camden (if they’ve actually fitted any to this point) to ascertain how much gas they are using and what their annual charges are. Not surprising that Camden don’t seem to have installed many heat meters yet, despite the legislation requiring all properties on a heat network to be metered being passed nearly ten years ago.
30th March 2023 at 00:18 #6853Part of the problem I think is that the communal heating systems are so inefficient compared to boilers in individual flats, and I guess are on and provided heating available to all even if some turned down…….
I’m in a street property so fortunately don’t have to deal with the communal heating system costs, but The Heat Network (Metering and Billing) Regulations 2014 (amended 2015 and 2020) make interesting reading and I would be asking camden the following if I were:
1) does the heating etc supply one or more than one building
2) what were the meter readings at start and end of each year for the meters on communal system and for flat ie calculation of the volume element of cost calculation. What were the dates and readings of any other readings.
3) What work has been idenfified as required to heating system/boiler in stock condition survey and elsewhere. What has been done.
4) Has heating system/boiler been maintained in accordance with manufacturers specifications and all proper lagging in place for pipework
5) Copy of feasibility study for installation of meters in flat per regulations and what plans were and are for meter installation
6) Copy of service charge calculation estimate and actual for 2021/2022 which was invoiced and certifed in September 2022
7) If meter readings based on estimates then whether invoices for “actual” were based on estimates and identified as such. Dates of payments by Camden as to when payments by Camden actually took place and maybe 18m rule maybe applicable.As an aside, in my experience Camden frequently falls foul of the requirements for the 18m rule for capital works. Somewhere I have a very good presentation Camden gave to other LA on requirements, shame they don’t follow their advice. Further shame for Camden they rejected my £10k offer for £16k “ish” overpriced/substandard capital works, took me to court instead and then I found that “none” was payable as 18m rule applied. Camden then dropped their claim after reading my defence document I filed in court. I never even had to apply for change of jurisdiction to Tribunal to consider reasonableness.
If leaseholders want a meeting happy to participate, but someone needs to make it happen, I would also argue the meeting should be in person not online, hybrid meetings don’t work and far better in person, very hard to chair otherwise if any more than dozen.
30th March 2023 at 01:02 #6854Thanks daugs, I suppose I should know…..but I don’t know what this useful-sounding “18m rule” is?
30th March 2023 at 10:35 #6862Dear all. I have written to Julian Fullbrook re this but I have not heard from him for a while. If we are going to have a meeting on this can we have one soon? teams or whatever ?
30th March 2023 at 10:43 #6863I agree. Shall we get on with it straight away? Protest outside our lovely new taxpayer funded town hall too.
30th March 2023 at 21:49 #6869We do need to meet and coordinate, I had a 6,200£ service new bill, total madness! Gas alone account for 4,400£ way beyond government 2,500£ cap guide line.
Tristan (Bassett Street) and Frances next door
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.