Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
A pleasure! I sometimes realise that I’ve picked up a bit of knowledge/skills over the last 4 or 5 years I’ve been a Forum attendee and then a member!
Re. payment in advance & challenging (from WendyH). I emailed Mike Edmunds, head of Leaseholder Services earlier today as I thought it a good question and this is what he had to say:
“Payment of service charges doesn’t impact at all on a challenge, leaseholders pay all of their services in advance, simple example would be caretaking. Reasonableness of a service charge is mainly governed by section 19 of the Landlord and Tenant act 1985. If the service is poor or not delivered the leaseholder is entitled to challenge and seek an adjustment.
Same applies to major works paid, a tribunal may decide the cost was too high or the works were of poor quality leading to a reduction.”
I am now reminded that with LVT appeals and now First Tier Property Tribunal (Property Chamber), it is generally recommended to get the work done and keep full documentation as to objections etc. In the worst case where you have a disagreement and go all the way through to appeal which you then lose, you have to pay up and you may not even get the benefit of the work if the project has already completed. Several leaseholders on my estate got burnt this way.
p.s. Mike doesn’t usually respond this quickly, so I’m not going to guarantee that I’ll get such a quick and forthright answer on any other topic!
As to Lambda: I totally agree, just no one is currently willing or volunteering to do this. We (the Forum) do strongly recommend people form both Leaseholders’ and Residents’ Associations within your block/estate if possible, as they give different rights and privileges in terms of access to information and powers during disputes. It’s also a wonderful example of sharing knowledge and being stronger together than individually. More information can be found here: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/guides/
Hi Canshe. There should be contact details on the notice/bill you have received. Start with that to field your questions.
Hi Joshnic. I know where you are coming from 🙂 From my perspective it starts to get into “conflict of interest” territory where someone says “I have a cousin that does that” or “would you mind forwarding on/advertising my services”. There are many companies offering double glazing, so I (personally) have reluctantly decided its a distraction from the main Forum activities (and has historically been the consensus opinion, although it hasn’t been discussed recently). Also, in this age of litigation, if we were to publicise someone who then does a poor job, this would give the Forum a bad reputation, so we (the Forum) are playing better safe than sorry.
That said, I know when I got my double glazing replaced a few years ago, trying to get someone to actually turn up, take measurements and then actually write back to me afterwards was an absolute nightmare.
Cheers, Paul
Some work Camden does get a guarantee for – ask them and they should be able to tell you. There are documented cases where there is a guarantee but the staff didn’t realise so they didn’t invoke the guarantee; nevertheless if we/you catch that error it means that the leaseholder shouldn’t have to pay.
It’s a useful point, that leaseholders need to (sadly) be asking for guarantees as part of any remedial works, to prevent the situation you describe.
That said, occasionally pinpointing damp is not a straight-forward business.
So just to add to NW5-flat’s point, the freeholder doesn’t take on unlimited liabilities because that wouldn’t be sustainable as buildings do age and wear. The lease clearly states that leaseholders will have to pay for these things and that is a fact of life with any leasehold purchase (which should have hopefully been evident from the bundle of paperwork you received as part of the leasehold buying process).
What the freehold will do is coordinate with other people in the block (both tenants and leaseholders) to produce a “reasonable” outcome. For better or for worse, they are allowed to charge for this service (“management charge”) and this is set out in the lease too.
Hi Lambda. This query often comes up during our meetings.
In practice organising these things come with a lot of responsibility and demands from people; if the perceived benefit is great enough perhaps people would come together and organise themselves on lines such as your suggest. If people were paying fees towards legal work, then the people running such an organisation would have larger responsibilities than the Forum does currently. There was a fees-based Camden Leaseholders Association some time ago (and Peter Wright may be along shortly to correct me if I have the wrong name) many years ago but that is now defunct.
From the Forum’s perspective, the consensus is that our constitution doesn’t allow us to do this, so we operate with that in mind when we engage with Camden Council and try different things. I personally think the Forum would welcome alternative attempts at getting Camden to improve, although I would suggest that one challenge would be identifying suitable legal cases; it’s probably helpful to note that from time to time the Forum has wanted to find “no win, no fee”-style lawyers and struggled to do so.
One other pain point is that realistically some leaseholders would pay and others wouldn’t (and would benefit from the free advice).
Best regards,
Paul Ginsberg, Camden Leaseholders’ Forum memberDo keep us posted! Real world experience beats theoretical positions any day of the week 🙂
The window units themselves (not the surroundings) are the individual leaseholder’s responsibility.
https://www.camden.gov.uk/ccm/cms-service/stream/asset/?asset_id=3474295& (page 16 in particular);
To be honest I think Camden’s attitude to this has previously varied but they now seem to have come up with a consistent position.
From what I’ve heard from Camden Council officers, the following article and CNJ reports, I suspect it would be highly unlikely for short term lets: https://www.camden.gov.uk/ccm/content/environment/planning-and-built-environment/two/planning-applications/before-you-apply/residential-and-business-projects/short-term-lettings/
The takeaways seem to be the amount of time you intend to let out your property for:
Less than 90 days in any one go: “You will need to apply for full planning permission to convert a flat or house into a short term/ holiday let if you intend to let the property for periods of less than 90 days for more than a total of 90 days in any one calendar year… Current planning policy in the Council’s Local Development Framework is to resist development that changes permanent housing to short stay accommodation/holiday lets”With the caveat: “Permission is not required… if you let a room within your property whilst you are still living there.”
More than 90 days, just in case you can stretch to that: It is very possible you you must notify Camden Council otherwise you will have breached your lease with whatever risk that entails. Camden Leaseholder Services do have procedures in place for official sublets of more than 90 90 days.
p.s. Anthony make same useful points about subletting over here: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/discussion-post/subletting-my-flat-have-you-encountered-any-problems/
Sorry for the bad news!
For what it’s worth Camden Council have some information on their website which may help: https://www.camden.gov.uk/ccm/content/housing/council-tenants-and-leaseholders/homeownership/making-improvements-to-your-property/
Hi Fabi, Do you know where the water stockcock is to the whole property? (rather than just focusing on the bath tap) Camden would be responsible for locating the former (because that’s where their responsibilities end), not the latter.
I know there was talk of setting up a TRA in your neighbourhood, but don’t know what happened; it may be that other neighbours may also have some experience if you send them a comment via this (admittedly old) website to “connect” with them: https://stsilasnorth.wordpress.com/2014/11/30/first-agm-of-st-silas-north-tra/
Other people may have more useful suggestions!
p.s. I know my stop cock for the property is underneath the kitchen sink, but I somehow suspect that every block may have their stop cocks in different places.
I can’t guarantee that, but you can email them and ask! The next guaranteed sessions, after that, are on 18th October.
Hi GRivolta,
After our (Leaseholders’ Forum) lobbying, you can now have a face to face chat with Leaseholders Service. This is only an infrequent service – the next slots are available on the evening of Tuesday, 6th September at Camden Town Hall. Email leaseholderservices@camden.gov.uk to reserve your slot. Therea are more details about the background of the face-to-face scheme here: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/2016-06-14/drop-sessions-announced-also-improvements-works-repayment-options/
p.s. I can’t guarantee you any better news as, unless the bill is calculated incorrectly, I know of no reduction schemes for service charges (only extended payment periods for major works, or a charge against the property with interest applied).
p.p.s. And in response to Jez’ observation about the management charge: this was due to Camden Council winning a legal case, which we (the Leaseholders’ Forum and many other individuals in Camden) fought and lost. The calculation method was (largely) upheld as valid by the First Tier Tribunal sadly.
Kind regards,
Paul Ginsberg (Leaseholders’ Forum member)Re. Kiln Place and heat meters. It’s a messy issue. The heat meters weren’t the significant problem, it was the heating solution that was chosen at the same time – they installed radiators but didn’t replace the central boiler. This means that when our old central boiler fails (as it does half a dozen times a year) it affects the entire estate.
Back to heating meters: we were a pilot project and the valves on the heat meters were a duff batch, so they didn’t shut off when the hot water stopped. This can be easily checked by switching off all heat for 6 hours and seeing if the meter/clock moves. Camden were really bad at getting to the bottom of this and lots of people were overcharged – the valves have now been replaced but obviously if you’ve over-payed you won’t be happy. I think there’s also a different type of meter now in use that you can pay online (we can’t with our – they have to be pre-paid at a local convenience shop, which isn’t convenient if they are shut).
The last bill-shock came as people who had been paying a flat fee suddenly had to pay for what they were using. As low users had been subsidising heavy users (e.g. people with heating on all the time and windows open), I find heating meters generally less hard to disagree with. They are also now required by law, which is why Camden are going through and moving people over to meet the new regulations.
Hope that helps explain Kiln Place a bit,
PaulI’m sure Camden would claim that there is – recently they have retendered a lot of their contracts hopefully to better value but I’ve no idea what submissions they actually received; time will tell as these will have an impact on the service charges. Unfortunately Camden Council don’t particularly post on these pages (they used to on the now defunct WeAreCamden website, but then again they owned that one, so it was easier to persuade them to post). That said, we (the Leaseholders’ Forum) always welcome suggestions to pass on to them!
Personally my bugbear is that they improved their outbound communications and actually listened to consultations then that would save them a lot of money, but some departments appear to hear this better than others (yes, I’m looking at you Major Works).
Paul
Leaseholders’ Forum memberFor what it’s worth, the Leaseholders’ Forum always welcomes practical ideas in helping reduce service charges! 🙂
Hi Simon. If you compare your current Service Charge bill to last year’s you will be able to see where the spend has increased and then perhaps be able to make further enquiries. For what it’s worth March’s bill is only an estimate. The September-on-September comparisons are the real deal in terms of what is actually spent.
Hi JR; all I can do is offer you this: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/guides/heating-options
Major Works are making a mess of things at various places recently, but all one can do is get alternative quotes and then pursue them at the LVT if necessary (explained in much better detail in the above document). There are recent cases where Major Works have backed down if the “opposition” is well organised and forceful enough in their opinion!
If you’re still unsure you can always email Leaseholder Services for clarification (their email address is usually at the top of the letter) – it may also help them improve their correspondence for next time!
Easy one, MM! Doesn’t make any sense whatsoever (from what you’ve said), so email Leaseholder Services with that question – and then post the answer back here, to inform everyone else in a similar position.
I find the consultation process spectacularly inept at the moment – this could just be the consultation; my personal advice is to call the number on the letter and then ask for an email address to write in to – that way you can ask the questions you need and, just as importantly, have the answers in writing just in case they give you incorrect advice!
Not the answer you want, but here are the current guidelines on payment options for larger bills. I think they are being updated currently, but I don’t know whether there will be any significant revision. https://www.camden.gov.uk/ccm/content/housing/council-tenants-and-leaseholders/homeownership/payment-options-for-major-works/
Regards, Paul
Hi Fabi. Bad news I’m afraid; usually it’s in the terms of your lease that you have to contribute towards lifts (etc) even if you don’t use them. Very annoying but standard practice. The general policy is that the infrastructure cost to your block/estate is divided by the number of properties (not size) and billed accordingly.
It’s a method of “fair” billing; recent informed advice has been to make sure that when there’s consultation works make sure that the works are appropriate for the block/estate/property – e.g. that they aren’t overspecified and happen only when necessary, rather than too soon/when the previous works for the same area are still under guarantee!
Camden have now published a Service Charge guide explaining how they divvy up the charges: https://www.camden.gov.uk/ccm/cms-service/stream/asset/?asset_id=3414319&
Hi there. I’m a bit confused. Repairs to your own flat are your responsibility. If the repairs are the consequence of problems in another flat then I *think* your Camden Council buildings insurance should cover this and you claim on that, calling the insurance company directly (and they will let you know how to proceed).
I could be missing something here and suspect I am!
For what it’s worth, if you think that some Camden Council service is failing and not responding in a timely fashion, then the most expedient is to lodge a formal complaint: Here’s the Leaseholders’ Forum guide: https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/guides/complaining-effectively/
Best regards, Paul Ginsberg
7th October 2015 at 17:02 in reply to: External Wall Insulation – Rendering nightmare and huge bills #1897If you contact the Major Works team (their number will be on the paperwork that you have been sent), they will be able to tell you. It will vary from estate to estate. As to why they are in such a hurry – that one I’m genuinely not sure about and haven’t received any meaningful answers, given that the purchasing framework changes next year, hopefully bringing in more suppliers and therefore lower costs. That said, they do have a programme to get on with dealing with lots of buildings in Camden; personally I don’t think that Major Works have woken up to the fact that if they listen better they might make their own life’s easier in terms of less hassle and happier punters! Paul (Leaseholders’ Forum member).
Hi Jerome. Yes, you’re entitled to a breakdown of the charges – some of this will be visible on Camden Account (e.g. all the repairs – click on the latest bill then repairs); for other queries in regards to breaking down your bill contact Leaseholder Services if you can’t navigate to them from the bill.
Best regards, Paul (Leaseholders’ Forum member)23rd September 2015 at 17:22 in reply to: Help please: Maiden Lane major work massive estimate #1856Hi there. Can’t help much, but this guide will help you find your fellow leaseholders on your estate:
https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/guides/finding-fellow-leaseholders/Within our Guides section (on this website) we’ve also got some stuff on how to form a Leaseholders’ Association which may provide useful and also about how to challenge the Major Works process if you feel that it is unfair.
Kind regards, Paul Ginsberg
That’s very useful (although disappointing news!). Following your post, I spoke to a knowledgeable person at Leaseholders’ Forum and they confirmed that this is correct. Cheers for updating. At least it is better to be informed about what is and isn’t possible/legal.
13th September 2015 at 08:03 in reply to: External Wall Insulation – Rendering nightmare and huge bills #1812Morning all! Just to say that I spotted a number of letters in this week’s Camden New Journal about building cladding, all going along the same lines. The first letter about Clarkson Row/Mornington Crescent, this one is about http://www.camdennewjournal.com/letters/2015/sep/reasons-oppose-cladding-plan-mortimer-estate and this is a small counter-argument.
Do remember this week’s Forum meeting on Tuesday where Stephen Platt will be in…
Cheers, Paul
-
AuthorPosts