Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
I would suggest s22 requests once the paper bills arrive, last year I had one inspection costing £300 for the block ! Challenged at the FTT, that’s another story…
I’d check the fees that Camden are seeking, at the recent DMC meetings they were consulting with tenants about the proposed rises in fees to Leaseholders, which seemed odd to me as the fees are not paid by tenants but Camden are looking for ways of raising more revenue it would appear
As to the changes in legislation, a lot of the commentary concerns situations with higher ground rents so I think you need to get into the detail, I have seen commentary that for ex RTB leases the new legislation may make it more expensive, but cannot say definitively, so if anyone knows it would be helpful. Mine has a few years to go before an issue
David
Wasn’t it from the short term letting team. I think it raises questions about the use of our email addresses that is for the use of leaseholder services in relation to their landlord function not their duty in relation to borough wide issues.
I am not sure of their insistence of the registration and fee. I have seen no basis for it since I can’t find a term in my lease. Surely the leaseholder simply making compliance with the lease with Camden a condition of the tenancy without Camden’s involvement be sufficient. How would Camden enforce it if no breach of the lease merely by subletting….but not looked at in huge detail since I live in mine. Maybe someone can ask Camden or knows already.
David
I got one too
Poorly worded heavy handed mass email by the looks of it. I can’t find a clause in my lease re subletting so Camden’s webpage and advice on subletting does not appear to represent my lease, but it would not be the first time Camden claimed something about the lease which was not true. I live in my flat so definitely does not apply to me. I’m not a lawyer but short term letting could be considered non residential use and hence the planning issues etc and there is a clause in my lease about only residential use. I guess the issue could be people who sublet and their tenants then do short term lets. But then, surely property that is used for short term lets for extended periods needs to get planning consent for change of use, and not just a camden leaseholder issue.
I thought they had given up with this “project”. I was going to ask about it this evening.
I understand the keys are designed with levels of hierarchy for security which I have less issue with than the repeated bullying and demands from Camden expecting us to act as a concierge service, lots of history….They may not have access issues at yours but it is a big issue for them, mainly as they can’t manage it. We have said we will only act as a concierge if proper appointments are made and agreed in advance with a time. All it takes is a simple phone call or email, really not hard….don’t get me started.
So we got new keys over a year ago but they haven’t actually changed the locks, as when they turned up to do it, I challenged about had they given new keys to everyone, which surprise surprise they hadn’t. One time they changed the locks years ago without managing it properly and one of the tenants kicked the door in. Not helpful but their willingness to change locks without telling residents effectively locking them out with new locks is truly shocking.
I made a formal complaint last year about fire safety works and Mulalley’s behaviour over access, Camden’s complaint process has not been improved despite their statements that it has, and I am waiting for the Ombudsman to get round to looking at. There is a big delay, up to 12 months…
Good luck with yours.
David
18th July 2025 at 10:59 in reply to: Request to Camden to add clause in Lease of Camden Flat they are selling #7602there are general comments re AirBNB on forum, noting that such activity would already be in breach of lease re residential use, if there are 3 leaseholders you could enfranchise but that also has its challenges, we can but haven’t, but I know people who have, there are pros and cons, and too complex for here
for what it’s worth I am not surprised, Camden has nearly 10,000 leasehold flats and having leases with same terms has advantages. Early ones are A, then B etc. The terms are different, usually in Camden’s favour as they took out clauses they didn’t like. Probably best known is the overhead charge. that in A leases is flat 10% but later leases calculated. There was an LVT case on it back around 2013 ?
David
pm sent, the 24/25 inspection period is open
seems quarterly is a guide, sometimes every 2 months sometimes as much as 4, I have told them not to ring my bell and disturb us but rather make an appointment, we are not a concierge service, part of bigger disputes. Dates of visits are shown on the on-line residents account. Have asked what basis for quarterly is and basis of amounts charged but no response….
so the invoice arrived today 14 March, but the invoice is dated 12 February 2025, so either Camden is sitting on them or the Royal Mail is even worse than before ?
David
14th March 2025 at 22:20 in reply to: Sale of leaseholder property with outstanding major works. #7573I had a garden wall issue some years back, not while selling. I presume when you say outstanding bill you mean outstanding works but no invoices and no s20.
In my case it’s complicated because we are near the junction of a road and the the rear of the gardens of the neighbouring road back on to our side wall. Camden identified a problem with the wall. Historically they had denied responsibility for the walls as not on the deeds of the property however it turned out they also owned the other property so they decided we did have a liability. The issues all arose following a lack of maintenance on the other side of the wall, and a neighbouring wall had collapsed as a result of plant growth into the mortar. We were charged for the survey prior to the s20 but Camden in its usual efficient way never actually did the work and I challenged the costs already incurred. Camden agreed to write them off eventually. The wall is still bulging 10 years later but not collapsed yet, touch wood!
So, I would ask which building owns the wall and who is responsible for maintenance?. Has the wall been maintained? Why did it collapse – plant growth disrupting mortar, subsidence or what ? Obviously any buyer’s survey will pick up but the answers to the above may impact discussions. I would push Camden, you may wish to make them aware of the consequences of delays on your selling process. If you are selling then guessing you have a lawyer, and maybe they can advise ?
As to regard selling I’ve never got there. Came close 20 odd years ago and there was a bunfight over settling outstanding charges that were disputed. The buyer’s lawyer wanted them all settled prior to exchange. I offered to put the money in escrow but that since the charges were disputed I was not paying to Camden. In the end the sale fell through for other reasons and our plans changed, and Camden wrote off those charges as well, so I am glad I didn’t pay them as part of the sale.
If you are selling, ownership for the walls etc will come up as part of sale process anyway.
David
is the lease clear which front door? my experience is that Camden officers are not above misrepresenting their interpretation of the lease, you could try LEASE, the leasehold advisory service, there is a Pre-Action Protocol for Housing Conditions Claims that courts would expect to be followed as I understand it, there are articles on the LEASE website giving more details
David
short answer no, Camden are busy demonstrating that their complaints process has not improved despite the warm words to the ombudsman
David
those impacted may want to read up on the First Tier Tribunal case London Borough of Camden v The leaseholders of 46 flats, Harben Road Estate LON/00AG/LDC/2014/0123 which was a dispensation case involving boilers and Camden so may give some insights on Camden’s thinking and how the issue of not the cheapest option was considered by the Tribunal. You can find it on the bailii.org website which is a database of a legal cases, and do a search
it makes interesting reading
David
15th December 2024 at 15:43 in reply to: Cleaning and Gardening Services from Camden via service charges #7527to answer if anyone has such arrangements, I think the answer is very few, or at least this is what Camden told me.
In my case I had a problem tenant in my building many years ago and lot’s of correspondence with Camden. This post has some of my experiences https://www.leaseholdersforum.org.uk/Discussion-Board/discussion-post/actual-service-charge-2023-24/
The terms of the lease set the responsibilities, and communal areas are Camden’s but they denied it. They knowingly denied it, as a copy of internal correspondence showed. My lease says:
4.3 So far as practicable
4.3.1 To keep reasonably clean and lighted the passages landings staircases and other parts of the Managed Buildings enjoyed or used by the Tenant in common with others andCamden’s internal memo stated:
The critical question being who should be obliged to clean and maintain the common parts of the property, which is retained to the Council’s ownership, not part of the lessee’s demise, and over which the Council had already given express covenants to be responsible for. I do not see the Court answering this in favour of the Council.
But Camden’s letter to me stated:
Our interpretation of the lease, as you know from previous correspondence, is that the term – where reasonably practical – does not mean we are obliged to provide a cleaning service to street properties.
Camden deliberately misquotes the lease and misapplies the word “reasonably”.
However, Camden’s argument that providing the services will come with service charges has to be taken seriously. And only individual leaseholders can assess whether the effort and cost of enforcing the lease in this regard, in the absence of other disputes, is worthwhile and whether private alternatives are more practical.
In buildings where there are only leaseholders then Camden is looking at disposing of the freehold given recent statements by Camden so even a solution with Camden may not last anyway.
In the interim, without accepting Camden’s interpretation, we look after our building ourselves although Camden has started charging us for garden services that it does not actually carry out. I feel another trip to the court building is looming…..
David
my original reply does not seem to have posted so redone below
Jeremy, I doubt anyone who has not experienced something similar could understand. A couple of thoughts.
1) A friend had their basement flat flooded by sewage water coming up from drains during a storm. He had to move out for weeks, there are health and safety issues. His was dealt with eventually by insurance company. New floors, kitchen, furniture etc. I’d speak to insurance company.
2) We are on the G and LG, and suffered with our basement patio area being filled with sewage but not enough to get over the door step with the back door fortunately. The drains had been blocked, but the manhole had been forced loose by the pressure so the patio area filled up rather than the soil pipe backing up. The blockage was due to newspaper being put down the loo in one of the other flats by a tenant. Camden denied responsibility, and there were lots of other issues, and all wrapped up together so not particularly helpful for you. But one thing, one of the most useful pieces of evidence we had was the acceptance by the Council Tax dept at Camden that our flat was uninhabitable, we had had to rent somewhere else due to the other issues and the way the Council Tax works, Camden wanted to charge us double for a second home but there is (or was) a 100% deduction for uninhabitable homes while repairs are undertaken. Camden Home Ownership struggled to argue with something on Camden letterhead. We were suing them for our alternative living costs and they were initially refusing to accept our home was uninhabitable and hence their liability.
3) The only other thing is that Camden deny everything it seems almost as a matter of routine, even when they know they are liable or responsible so don’t be surprised. I’d check your own insurance for legal cover, as well as buildings insurance that Camden arrange. The issue with the buildings insurance is that there may be an exemption for lack of maintenance, but if that is their determination then again useful with Camden. We were flooded from above and eventually after I spoke to Zurich directly there was no issue with a claim, the entire ceiling had come down, but initially Camden had said there wasn’t even a claim, the only reason I could think of was that it put their premiums up ? The cost of a new ceiling was £8k and that was 20 years ago, all the original period mouldings had to be renewed as well, which may have been an issue for Camden.
Good luck, David
on my lease the demise of my flat has a red outline, I’m on the G and LG of a street property, and there are communal areas on the G level leading to the flats upstairs as you would expect, and also the LG floor with old historic LG entrance blocked off making a small room only accessible from outside which has the various utility meters. Both are not within the red line, all very clear. The Garden is shaded on the plan in red with an accompanying note stating in the demise of my flat. Again very clear. Since the only access to the garden is through my flat nothing else would make sense.
I presume in your case the access to the garden is from the communal area, so it may not be clear, but I would think that if part of the garden was for the sole use of any of the flats then it should be on the various leases. On mine, it’s not clear from b&w photocopies, I have the coloured version.
None of this stopped one of the tenants trying to gain access to the garden, and when I pointed out the lack of access they demanded rights of access through my flat. This was robustly defended and they gave up after I threatened them with legal action.
My lease dates from 1990, its an old A type lease and even then Camden did not leave any ambiguity in my case. While I cannot advise as not a lawyer I would ask them for copy of the plan that shows the demise and seek clarification from Camden. However if the garden is not shown in your demise then it may well be communal or demised to one of the other flats.
It is not clear from your post as to who is demanding you accept the demise of half of the garden to Flat A, if it is Camden, is this part of their negotiating to seek to resolve outstanding the issue of their demising part of the garden that was communal to another flat effectively removing it from something you enjoyed ?
David
PS yes, I’ve been to tribunal on service charge issues, see my other posts
- This reply was modified 1 year, 11 months ago by daugs.
To All
Pictures of new doors, wired alarm systems as well as emergency lighting that has been fitted would be helpful particularly if the building is listed and / or in a conservation area and especially if any period features have been disturbed or removed or impacted. Having seen what’s been installed upstairs I am deeply concerned. Checking with English Heritage something far less damaging that still complies with the legislation is perfectly possible.
thanks
David
John, is it just 2 flats in a street property, sounds like converted period house ? do you know what they have done in the tenanted flat below, wired LD3 or wireless LD2 system. Have they said what they would like to do in yours, since you don’t mention I presume they’ve not done anything yet ?
David
Who is suggesting you need a certificate, if there is no supply, no gas meter and you don’t have any gas appliances then nothing to check ? I have not heard (but maybe wrong as I have a gas supply, my own boiler and a gas fire), essentially as Patrick suggests
Sounds like a letting agent maybe doesn’t understand the rules and it’s just on their checklist ?
Many leases include a clause that requires Camden’s consent to let so I would try there, and if you do need a certificate then if it were me I would put Camden on notice of you seeking compensation for lost rent for any unreasonable delays.
David
VR, I am not saying you can or cannot do anything, this will depend on specifics relating to your service charges, terms of your lease and I cannot advise on that. One thing my lawyer told me was to make sure I always paid the ground rent whatever, mine is only £10pa.
Not paying service charges is a breach of the lease but there may be legal arguments that can be used. The question I asked myself was what I would say when in court to defend my position. The Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 (as amended) states that a service charge is only recoverable by a landlord so far as the costs have been reasonably incurred. Also, it states that it is only recoverable if works carried out for the charge are of a reasonable standard. The reasonableness can be challenged at Lands Tribunal (was LVT). see LEASE https://www.lease-advice.org/fact-sheet/service-charges/. When I was challenged by the Judge as to why transfer to LVT, this was my answer, to seek a determination of reasonableness. It should be noted that if an unsuccessful challenge is made at LVT, then Camden could seek to recover its legal costs !
Completely separately, in my case I had a claim for damages against Camden for their breaches. I was very confident of the legal interpretation as I was fortunate to have got a copy of Camden’s own legal analysis for some of it at least, but any claim would need to demonstrate not only the breach but also quantify what the damages are and how do they compare to Camden’s demands. Hence the equitable set off in my case, but my annual charges are less than £1,000 pa in a street property, the big bills are the periodic redecoration/repairs. Last one was nearly £40k split between 3 flats, my share 40%.
But as I said before the first steps are to understand what you are being charged and what your lease says. Any estimated charges depend again on the terms of the lease. I had legal advice on this, as in my case, how Camden raise their invoices, annually with quarterly payments is not reflected by how Camden asked for the money, which was annually and what’s in my lease which refers to quarterly on account payments. I had missed this particular nuance but my barrister picked it up when he came on board for my first case, and we were refiling my defence and counterclaim document to take account of more recent events in the case.
s22 of The Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 (as amended) details ability to ask for supporting documentation, again the LEASE website has some info and templates. Asking for the information costs nothing.
As the old saying goes about eating an elephant, one bite at a time. Lots of the lawyers/barristers websites have interesting articles. Gatehouse Chambers is one and one of their articles notes “I was recently involved in LB Camden v Olaniyan and Oshibote, Central London County Court, January 2014 which concerned a leasehold property which suffered from water penetration shortly after the leaseholders exercised their right to buy. The claim settled for £40,000 which was approximately 18% of the notional market rent for the 9 year period.” Well done them.
The sad reality is that in many cases, using a lawyer to challenge service charges unless a group of you is not economically worthwhile as it costs as much as the disputed charges. Which is why I did most of it myself. Yes, a nightmare but the alternative was to pay some large unjustifiable bills as well as the other impact on our lives, so for us, not really an option. While Camden definitely lost at least 3 of the cases, I wouldn’t say I won, although I definitely didn’t lose. In some respects I was fortunate as the effort was spread over many years and for part of that I either had a job where I spent a lot of time travelling, mainly to US, and I did a lot on the plane or in the airport, or I wasn’t working so I had time. So again any decision is based on personal circumstances. It also depends on whether other leaseholders can or will help. I have met a number of leaseholders who have ended up accepting that they are going to pay their charges, despite concerns as they don’t have the time or resources to fight. This is fine and one of the reasons I share my story, because I fear the worst result is going through the challenge but being ill prepared or badly advised, and then losing. But it is very possible to do. It does take time and a logical mind definitely helps.
Feel free to send me a PM if anything specific occurs to you.
David
There are legal mechanisms to challenge service charges, and a full answer is beyond what can be done here, LEASE can advise of rights, and I am not a lawyer but I have been a Camden leaseholder for over 25 years, and while my circumstances will not be the same, if I can share what I have done, that may be helpful.
I took legal advice over 20 years ago and was referred to my lease and the relevant legislation applicable, particularly the 1985 Act and 2002 Act. Please note I am in a street property and the “estate” is only our building, so it’s much simpler. No communal heating.
I sought a detailed understanding of what exactly Camden had charged and how the individual amounts were calculated. I also looked at breaches of the lease by Camden and gained understanding of how I might claim against Camden. External redecoration was long overdue. Richard Oleszewski was a Regents Park Ward councillor but no help as he was rather easily fobbed off by Council Officers. I put Camden on notice of their breaches and my right to claim equitable set off against service charges. Camden eventually filed claims in County Court for unpaid service charges before I took the matter to the Leasehold Valuation Tribunal (LVT) now Lands Tribunal which is the jurisdiction for challenging unreasonable service charges. This has happened 4 times, ie 4 separate legal claims filed in Court by Camden. The last was about 2018.
For each, in response to Camden’s claim for unpaid service charges I filed a Defence and Counterclaim in court. Camden then filed or should have filed a Reply (to my defence) combined with a Defence to my Counterclaim. I then filed a Reply (to Camden’s Defence to Counterclaim). Not all my cases got this far. The first 2 cases (over 15 years ago) got as far as directions hearings where I argued successfully that the cases should be stayed and transferred to LVT to consider the reasonableness of the service charges in the first instance. This was after various motions to the Court.
A brief word on this experience. At this point we had had to move out and lived in Hampshire. The case had been transferred from Central London County Court to Basingstoke. It was in front of a Judge. Camden turned up with 2 staff and solicitor and a Barrister. I was on my own which annoyed the Judge who thought I should have a lawyer etc but accepted I had a right to act as a litigant in person. Camden said their bit trying to keep the LVT out of it and in County Court no doubt so they could force the issue of costs etc. I argued specific points of law as to purpose of LVT and accessibility to people in an informal setting without lawyers and played on fact I was on my own etc. The Judge said it pained him to admit that I was right and according he did transfer it to the LVT. Meanwhile Camden were quite happy to tell me of their ever spiralling legal costs, to which I pointed out that legal costs fighting legal motions that they lost would hardly be considered reasonable, they should have known better.
My early cases were complicated by the fact we were forced to move out due to disrepair and matters escalated. In my first two cases, Camden dropped their initial claims entirely, but only just before the LVT hearing, and the court cases (now combined and transferred to Chancery Division of the High Court) just continued with my Counterclaim and Camden ultimately settled my counterclaim as well as all my legal costs after we made a Part 36 Offer. By this time the unpaid service charges were dwarfed by my alternative living costs and legal fees.
The third case was a negotiated settlement (with considerable write offs by Camden and some service charges paid by me) just before the directions hearing, and my 4th case again was settled before court appearances, all claims and counterclaims were withdrawn. It’s been expensive for Camden and extremely time consuming for me. I acted as a litigant in person for all of the 3rd and 4th cases. This was partly because it became clear to me and my lawyer that Camden were more than happy to engage my solicitor in endless pointless correspondence and wait for me to suffer fee fatigue as the legal costs I was incurring mounted. As I have said previously on this forum, I also became aware that Camden was happy to engage in correspondence with a position they knew had no basis in law just to try and wear me down. I was also lucky in that my legal fees in the first 2 cases had been significant, and by this time my lawyer and I knew each other quite well, so in the latter cases I acted as a litigant in person but had access to legal advice on an ad hoc basis on specific points of law but avoided the cost of having a lawyer draft a 20 page “Defence and Counterclaim” document for example. Of course the downside is that I had to draft the 20 page document, even if double spaced.
My experience was that Camden’s departments were very bad a talking to each other, and it was only late on in the legal process that Camden actually looked at what had been done and charged rather than just relying on departments saying they had done it properly and the service charges were reasonable. I have always made sure of my facts before filing anything in court to minimise the risk of being hit with Camden’s legal costs.
If service charges are not paid then my experience is that Camden do take legal action and it gets unpleasant. The alternative I was told is to get in first with a legal ruling from the LVT / Lands Tribunal that the service charges are unreasonable before Camden start the legal process, and if successful, court action by Camden is avoided. Camden also threatened me with “huge” legal fees.
For 23/24 I am going through my final bill from Camden on a line by line basis using the data from the online account and asking myself:
1) Was the repair actually done ? One item so far definitely not.
2) Was the repair carried out to a reasonable standard ? One item so far definitely not.
3) Was the cost of the repair reasonable ? this is a legal thing and may be so even it seems huge, how has it been calculated ?
4) Was any s20 consultation done properly in accordance with rules
5) When did Camden incur costs if item is old, does 18m rule apply
6) How have management and supervision fees been calculated, and getting a copy of the calculation from Camden
7) When were meter readings obtained and what were they ? while for me it’s only communal electricity, but why not check ?
And finally what claims do I have. Moorjani v Durban Estates 2015 in Court of Appeal makes interesting reading for “shabby” communal areas for example. Some might argue that finding claims against Camden to reduce large service charge bills is somehow unreasonable but after what Camden has put us through, I have absolutely no problem in insisting that Camden honours its legal commitments given when it signed the lease and I respond very badly to Camden’s “bully” tactics that we have experienced.
I appreciate all this is possibly a bit daunting, but ultimately my thinking is that I can pay or I can challenge, and the first step is a clear picture of exactly what the charges are and how have they been calculated. This is what I have done, your circumstances will be different and realistically proper advice needs to consider your situation.
firstly it has been my personal experience that Camden, on occasion, lies about it’s obligations and interpretations of the lease. I caught them at it blatantly in 2003 and never trusted them since.
I was told that I too would need a wired alarm in our flat. We are the G and LG of a street property, with a bedsit flat on 1st and a third flat on the 2nd and 3rd floors. It’s a period building converted in 1976. The proposal was surface wiring and to cut through the mouldings and period features. To cut a long saga short I insisted on being provided the details of the legislation requiring this. Eventually I received the below….
“Please see attached info you requested regarding flat front door (fire door) and domestic alarms.
Your flat is classed as being in a building converted into self-contained flats so Lacors guidance is used.
See page 25
Three- to six-storey house converted to self-contained flats (prior to Building Regulations 1991, approved document B standard)
GRADE A LD2 coverage in the common areas and a heat detector in each flat in the room/lobby opening onto the escape route (interlinked)
Grade D LD3 coverage in each flat (non interlinked) smoke alarm in the room/lobby opening onto the escape route) to protect the sleeping occupants”
ie there was no legal requirement for a wired LD2 system in my flat.
My advice would be to politely demand details of what rules they are using and their interpretation. It’s a reasonable request. Obviously your flat may have different circumstances.
There have been similar discussions about the flat door. They have demanded access to do annual safety checks but this is a necessity for buildings in excess of 11m, so I have asked for how and when they assessed the height, since our estimates are around 9m, not even close, but the way the exact measurement is complicated with where the measurements are taken from and to.
One last thing, don’t be surprised if you get various threats including forfeiture, I have. This is obviously escalating the stakes but there are several hurdles. Make sure you get discussions in writing so you can demonstrate everything you have done is reasonable.
David
local govt ombudsman after Camden Complaint process but in my experience the ombudsman doesn’t get involved as leaseholders have legal redress under terms of lease.
In my experience, can wait for Camden to take you to court, and then argue for transfer to First Tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) ie what was LVT to determine reasonableness of service charges, after which gets transferred back to court. Or you can apply direct to FTT for a determination of reasonableness yourself. The rules around what is reasonable come from Landlord and Tenant Act and there is a lot of case law. The reasonableness can be on quality and price. HOWEVER, be careful, the view on reasonableness is about alternatives, NOT just proving a cheaper alternative, so advice is often needed depending on the issue. You don’t need legal representation for FTT, but may well need expert witness. Well worth speaking to Leasehold Advisory Service and reading previous decisions.
David
PS judges don’t appear to like people representing themselves at the early stages in court, I did several years back and argued for transfer to LVT. Represented myself at the directions hearing against Camden + lawyer + barrister, after 10 minutes of being belittled by the judge I was allowed to put my request that it be transferred to LVT which the judge begrudgingly accepted as appropriate given my case (as filed in the defence document) was a resonableness issue, but Camden did oppose it…..In the end case never got before the LVT as Camden withdrew their claim before the hearing (ie capitulated) but they did drag it out.
Harvinho, you could try an FOI for the meter readings taken and the calculation of the final charge for 21/22 included in the service charge adjustment invoice in September 2022. Also were these certified by a Camden officer (mine were) and in which case, how if they don’t know the actual readings unless estimates ? but when were last readings ?
In relation to the metering programme and questions raised at DMC meetings, just received an email from Camden as follows
“Dear DMC rep
At a recent DMC round of meeting there was a request for our Capital Work Team to share with you information on the Heat Meter Programme. Attached is a spreadsheet which lists all the properties that either have heat meters or will receive them in the near future. Many of you may ask why certain blocks are or aren’t included in the programme – below is an explanation.
1. Why are certain estates selected over any other properties and what was the selection criteria?
Camden began its heat metering retrofit programme in 2009 at Kiln Place, followed by other sites in later years (known internally as Phase 1, Phase 2 and Phase 3 sites). The heat meters in these phases of the programme were retrofitted in two stages – first a meter installation by a general contractor, and second the connection of the meter communications by a specialist heat metering engineer to get the resident’s heat data to Camden’s systems for charging purposes. This informed our retrofit programme content and order up until 2020 as the meters had been fitted in resident’s homes so we wanted to connect them up.
These phases covered certain homes and blocks at the following estates: Chalcots, Kiln Place, Ampthill, Henderson Court, Kenbrook, Kennistoun, Snowman, Casterbridge, Churchway, Doric, Hampstead Rd (partial), North Gower, George Mews, Mary Green, Hastings House, Penshurst, Rothay, Waxham, Ludham, Una House, Templar House, Seymour House, Somers Close, Platt St, Purchese St, Constable House, Tolmer Sq. We are currently approaching the end of Phase 3.
In addition during these years we retrofitted meters as part of several Capital Works projects (where an estate was having a bigger heating upgrade) and also for regeneration projects so the meters were fitted as part of the new build development. These estates were: Bacton, Bourne, Netley, Maiden Lane, Agar Grove, Regents Park, Abbey, Chester Balmore, Holly Lodge, Central Somers Town, Charlie Ratchford, Harben Road, Monica Shaw and Mansfield Road. These works are currently underway at St Silas, Highgate Newtown and Maitland Park.
The Heat Network (Metering and Billing) Regulations 2014 required us to meter homes where technically and financially viable, but the government put their tool for assessing viability on hold for several years while they redesigned the tool so it was fit for purpose. In the meantime we continued with the above phases of our heat metering programme.
The Heat Metering Regulations were amended in 2020 and a new cost effectiveness tool published. We applied the tool to all the remaining homes on our heat network, with the result that 157 homes still needed to be metered. The rest were either exempt from metering under the Regulations (including Camelot House) or deemed not cost effective through the tool.
These 157 homes are going to be prioritised under the next phase of our heat metering programme (Phase 4) as they are the ones we are legally required to meter. These are certain homes at Sanderson Close, Cressfield and Woodyard Estate, Lymington Road Estate, Netherwood Estate and Bacton Estate. This part of the programme is in procurement phase and we intend to do the meter installs later this year.
We still have plans to meter as many other homes on our heat network as possible, including those we are not legally required to meter. However the speed of the rest of the programme will depend on budget, resource, supplier constraints and resident access issues. We may also decide to change our retrofit approach and install meters as part of bigger heating upgrades as estates, rather than as standalone work. These are all decisions that will be made in the future by senior management.
It should be noted that for all residents in a block / estate to switch to heat meters we require at least 70% take up otherwise we can’t switch residents over to this new way of billing.
Kind regards”
In response to my post and Bill’s question (apologies for the delay) re 18 month rule
Under Section 20B of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, a landlord has 18 months within which to notify you of service charge costs being incurred or demand payment from you. If they fail to either notify you or demand payment within 18 months they will not be able to recover the charges from you. There are various rules for the information required in the notification.
Part of the problem I think is that the communal heating systems are so inefficient compared to boilers in individual flats, and I guess are on and provided heating available to all even if some turned down…….
I’m in a street property so fortunately don’t have to deal with the communal heating system costs, but The Heat Network (Metering and Billing) Regulations 2014 (amended 2015 and 2020) make interesting reading and I would be asking camden the following if I were:
1) does the heating etc supply one or more than one building
2) what were the meter readings at start and end of each year for the meters on communal system and for flat ie calculation of the volume element of cost calculation. What were the dates and readings of any other readings.
3) What work has been idenfified as required to heating system/boiler in stock condition survey and elsewhere. What has been done.
4) Has heating system/boiler been maintained in accordance with manufacturers specifications and all proper lagging in place for pipework
5) Copy of feasibility study for installation of meters in flat per regulations and what plans were and are for meter installation
6) Copy of service charge calculation estimate and actual for 2021/2022 which was invoiced and certifed in September 2022
7) If meter readings based on estimates then whether invoices for “actual” were based on estimates and identified as such. Dates of payments by Camden as to when payments by Camden actually took place and maybe 18m rule maybe applicable.As an aside, in my experience Camden frequently falls foul of the requirements for the 18m rule for capital works. Somewhere I have a very good presentation Camden gave to other LA on requirements, shame they don’t follow their advice. Further shame for Camden they rejected my £10k offer for £16k “ish” overpriced/substandard capital works, took me to court instead and then I found that “none” was payable as 18m rule applied. Camden then dropped their claim after reading my defence document I filed in court. I never even had to apply for change of jurisdiction to Tribunal to consider reasonableness.
If leaseholders want a meeting happy to participate, but someone needs to make it happen, I would also argue the meeting should be in person not online, hybrid meetings don’t work and far better in person, very hard to chair otherwise if any more than dozen.
Per the lease, costs incurred by Camden can be recharged, and the basis is set out in the lease. However sometimes how Camden split the costs are “questionable”. Finding out what Camden has done can be challenging…..but not unrewarding.
It’s worth checking out the breakdowns in the online account for leaseholders/tenants that Camden has online. Lots of detail how repairs etc broken down by item and direct/indirect costs.
Unfortunately the legal defences that ultimately can be successful are that costs are “unreaseonable” as determined by tribunal based on quality and/or quantity and whether legally enforceable under the lease or statute eg 18 month rule under s20B(1) LTA 1985.
As to gas bills, I’d be checking out what all the various meter readings were and how costs apportioned between flats, whether flats have meters and if not working then when notified etc and why not repaired. Unfortunately where individual properties are not metered there is limited incentive if some people’s bills not based on usage for people to be mindful of wasteful behaviour.
Just received an estimate for next year, new line items and repeat of similar items that have already been challenged. This should not be surprising given Camden’s statements at the rent setting meeting that they are seeking recovery of more from leaseholders. This would seem to include the charging of allocated overheads for contracts that are not even relevant (grounds / tree maintenance where street property and Camden don’t maintain and there are no trees!) even if amounts small. And don’t get me started on how much it costs to maintain an electricity meter. Our “switchroom” has 2 switches, one for the light and one on the electricity meter but somehow it costs £114 to maintain.
In my experience Camden are quite happy to charge even when they know uncollectibe and accept payment if paid as was the case a few years back when I showed the charges were uncollectable due to 18m rule (which meant the poor quality and over pricing no longer relevant) but my fellow leaseholder had already paid.
Has anyone had estimated capital works invoices in the last few years and know the basis of preparation. I would be interested as looking at relationship between estimates invoiced and whats on the stock condition survey?
All this means that in challenging bills ultimately everyone has to be prepared to go to Tribunal or seek transfer thereto if Camden lodge claim at County Court. The First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) considers reasonableness of service charges amongst other things.
A few years back when ACCL was active we used to have regular meetings going through how to do this. Maybe we need another similar meeting. I would be quite happy to go through my experience and share some insights if people were interested. Was any of this covered at meeting earlier this week ?
David
do let us know how you get on
-
AuthorPosts