Harvinho

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 20 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Actual Service Charge 2023-24 #7445
    Harvinho
    Participant

      Fantastic. When there has been an error with their system that makes them think that I might not pay their service charge on time they instantly send me a threatening e-mail, however, they’re happy for the money they owe me to sit in their account accruing interest for them for an indeterminate amount of time.

      in reply to: Actual Service Charge 2023-24 #7439
      Harvinho
      Participant

        I’ve just checked my invoices and I have received one dated 11th September which seems to suggest that they over charged me £964. Does anyone know how to get this money off Camden as quickly as possible?

        in reply to: Extortionate service charges #7238
        Harvinho
        Participant

          I also received the letter (dated August 7th). I would have thought that it would apply to all leaseholders although the letter was personalised. I don’t see why the reduction wouldn’t apply to all. 1Allingham did you withhold the amount detailed in the letter and have you recently received a letter demanding that you pay the withheld amount (if you did withhold it)?

          in reply to: Extortionate service charges #7224
          Harvinho
          Participant

            I received a threatening letter from Camden today, demanding that I pay £783 that is outstanding from my 23-24 service charge. This is the exact amount I was told, by them, to withhold as a result of their having conducted a mid-year review of heating charges and an earlier decision to put a cap on management charges. Has anyone else experienced the same thing? Are these people really this incompetent or is it that they are trying to squeeze every last penny out of us?

            This has incentivised me to double down on my attempts to get these extortionate charges investigated.

            in reply to: Extortionate service charges #7203
            Harvinho
            Participant

              Unfortunately I’ve got flu so wasn’t able to attend. I’m going to e-mail James Slater (again) about my issues.

              in reply to: Extortionate service charges #7194
              Harvinho
              Participant

                I just received the following from my local coucillor James Slater:

                Good evening,

                I hope you are well.

                I’m writing to you because you are a leaseholder I have had casework with and I would like to invite you to attend one of the “Listening to Leaseholders” sessions which I will be running throughout Camden this December.

                This year I have been appointed as Cabinet Advisor for Improving Services to Camden Leaseholders and, as part of my report, I want to hear from leaseholders across the borough on what is going well, what could change and what needs to improve. These will guide the recommendations I make in my report to Camden Council in the spring.

                I will be in attendance as well as members of Camden’s Leaseholder Services team to answer questions and hear feedback.

                The sessions will be held on:
                Thursday 7 December 2023 – 6:30pm-8pm – Swiss Cottage Library
                Tuesday 12 December 2023 – 6:30pm-8pm – Camden Town Hall
                Thursday 14 December 2023 – 6:30pm-8pm – The Greenwood Centre, Kentish Town
                You must RSVP to the sessions in advance by emailing me at james.slater@camden.gov.uk – please include both your home address and which session you wish to attend. Places will be issued on a first-come, first-served basis.

                I hope you will be able to attend one of these sessions, and I really look forward to hearing from you – please also pass this on to any other Camden leaseholders you know. And I’m happy to answer any questions.

                All the best,
                James

                Councillor James Slater
                Labour & Co-operative Councillor for Kentish Town North
                Cabinet Advisor on Improving Services to Camden Leaseholders and Advocating for Leaseholders
                London Borough of Camden

                Tel: 020 7974 2792 (Casework support)
                Mob: 07971 757241
                Email: james.slater@camden.gov.uk
                Camden Town Hall, Judd Street, London WC1H 9JE

                I am going to attend the session at the town Hall. I would suggest that this is a good opportunity for more of us to make our voices heard. At this point Leaseholder services are no longer responding to my requests for a breakdown of the calculation for my apportionment and an explanation of the £700 charge for electricity that makes up part of my charge.

                in reply to: Extortionate service charges #7019
                Harvinho
                Participant

                  Further progress: I have had a response from someone on Keir Starmer’s team. He mentioned in his response that the council might be considering “some form of exceptional disapplication of the utility element” in regards to the service charge. I don’t really know what that means but it sounds like a good thing and I think it is probably more likely to happen if more people contact him to complain about the service charge. The e-mail address is: keir.starmer.constituency@parliament.uk

                  in reply to: Extortionate service charges #7018
                  Harvinho
                  Participant

                    Hi all

                    I have contacted leaseholder services 6 times now to try to get them to send me the calculations they used to figure out the apportionment for my flat. They have failed to do this so far, however, the person I’m in contact with seems to have attempted the calculation himself and the figure he came up with is £700 less than what I’m actually being charged. When I questioned this he sent me the following response:

                    This is for the electricity consumption associated with the boiler and includes usage for pumps, boilers, pressurisation units, lighting in the boiler rooms etc.

                    There are 57 flats on my estate. If they’re all contributing £700 or therabouts to the electricity being used by the boiler, this would suggest that the boiler is using £30000+ worth of electricity in a year. Even taking apportionment into account a figure anywhere near this much would be ridiculous.

                    I would be interested to know if anyone else has asked them to actually run through the calculations for their apportionment and whether there have been similar discrepancies in the figures received.

                    in reply to: Extortionate service charges #7002
                    Harvinho
                    Participant

                      Leigh day, the Law firm I mentioned in my previous post, is considering a group claim on behalf of heat network customers paying excessive bills. They believe that there is a lack of transparency in the billing process and issues around the efficiency of heat network systems, that could represent a breach of contract by the heat providers. There is a very simple form to fill in if you would want to be involved in this group action here: https://www.leighday.co.uk/our-services/group-claims/heat-networks-group-claim/ The blurb that comes up after having filled in the form seems to suggest that the more interest they receive, the more likely it is that their claim will go ahead, so I would urge as many of you as possible to fill in the form (took me about 5 minutes). You will need a copy of your invoice for the previous year’s service charge (22/23) and the current one (23/24).You can download these as a PDF if you go to your Camden Account then locate the invoices within ‘Housing’ then send them to print to be able to save the PDFs. They request a copy of the lease/contract but i haven’t been able to get leaseholder services to send this to me yet.

                      in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6990
                      Harvinho
                      Participant

                        No lull in enthusiasm here! Would just like to point you all towards an article published in the Guardian today on this very matter: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2023/may/19/uk-households-with-communal-heating-facing-350-rise-in-energy-costs. There are nearly half a million people across the country currently in the same position as us and also clearly not happy about it. Heat networks, which are currently unregulated, are going to be regulated by Ofgem from 2024 onwards, so there clearly is some recognition by the government that heat network providers aren’t acting in everyone’s best interests. Whilst there’s very little we can do about the greed driven inflation caused by multinational food and energy suppliers, I feel like local councils present a very ‘winnable’ battle if enough of us get involved. With that in mind, I’ve taken the following actions and I would urge others to do the same (I’m more than happy to provide the text I sent as a starting point for others with less time on their hands):

                        1: Contacted alex.lawson@theguardian.com and sarah.marsh@theguardian.com (the journalists responsible for the article)to share the plight of Camden leaseholders and describe my own situation in case of a follow up article to the one published today.

                        2: Contacted https://www.leighday.co.uk/forms/contact-leigh-day/ the law firm mentioned in the article to find out whether they think that we might have grounds for some form of joint action against Camden Council.

                        3: Contacted the following consumer affairs programmes to see if they might be interested in a piece about Camdens exorbitant service charges:
                        -The Martin Lewis Money Show (itv) martinlewis@itv.com
                        -You and yours (radio 4) youandyours@bbc.co.uk
                        -Rip Off Britain (bbc) https://www.bbc.co.uk/send/u19921092?ptrt=https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00wck32
                        -Watchdog (bbc) watchdog@bbc.co.uk
                        The message I sent them was along the lines of:
                        Dear Sir/Madam,

                        I am writing to you in the hope that you might be willing to investigate extortionate leaseholder service charges that Camden leaseholders have just received for the coming year. These service charges have always been extremely high and incorporate work that is never completed in many cases; I’m charged annually for work on ‘roads and pathways’ of which there has never been any maintenance on my estate, however, my service charge has more than doubled for the coming year 2023/24. A large portion of this massive increase has come from gas/heating/hot water that has risen from £1186 to £3184. Whilst I appreciate that the cost of energy supplies has increased, British Gas state that the average gas bill for a 3 bedroom house this year is £1386 whereas I live in a small 2 bedroom apartment, and have switched my heating on only when temperatures have been below freezing but am paying more than double that figure. The amount that we are being charged does not equate to how much Camden is paying for gas and how much energy is used by the whole estate. I have a four year old daughter and another baby on the way in July and am now not sure how I am going to make ends meet with childcare costs, the increased cost of groceries and bills and now a £500 a month service charge to pay. I feel that an investigation by [insert name of consumer affairs programme] might help to shed some light on how Camden can justify these charges and encourage them to create more parity for leaseholders on heat networks at a time when many of us are facing financial hardship. Thank you for considering my request.

                        Yours faithfully
                        Adrian Harvey

                        4: I have previously written to james.slater@camden.gov.uk and sylvia.mcnamara@camden.gov.uk my local councillors, but wasn’t getting anywhere with them so have started e-mailing keir.starmer.constituency@parliament.uk directly. He has yet to respond but I feel like he might if we all e-mail him. I think I previously copied in the content of my letters to my local councillors; my correspondence with Keir Starmer has been along similar lines.

                        5: As well as contacting the Guardian today, I also wrote to the Camden New Journal editorial@camdennewjournal.co.uk and the Ham and High simon.murfitt@newsquest.co.uk urging them to investigate this story. The Ham and High has previously run a story on extortionate service charges in the local area.

                        I have continued to try to get leaseholder services to explain how they have arrived at the figure that they are charging me for gas/hot water/heating, however, they take weeks to respond every time I contact them and they don’t answer my questions when they do. Most recently they sent me a spreadsheet that didn’t contain any calculations and seemed to arrive at a figure that was £500 less than what they are actually charging me.

                        in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6958
                        Harvinho
                        Participant

                          I agree with the last poster. With the amount that we are all going to be forking out every month the sooner we can meet and try to get this resolved the better.
                          After waiting for several weeks for a response from the Camden leaseholders forum they sent me another reply in which they didn’t answer any of my questions and stated that they have sent my enquiries to other departments. One piece of information that they sent that is fairly helpful is the estimated gas use for the coming year for my estate (and the estimates for the previous 2 years – impossible to get the actual usage figures for 2021/22 out of them). They estimate that the estate is going to use 1,059,638 kWh of gas in the coming year, which when divided by 57 (the number of flats on my estate – Charlton Court) gives a figure of 18,590 kwh per flat. I haven’t taken into account apportionment because Camden aren’t able to clearly explain how it works but being a small 2 bed, my flat is around average for the estate. 18,590 kwh at a rate of 8.53 pence per kwh (the price Camden has paid for gas means that I should be paying £1585 for gas not the £3196 they have charged me. Leaseholder services sent me a breakdown of costs for 21/22 and in that year there were £500 worth of maintenance costs per flat for the heating/gas/hot water systems (which is incredibly high and there does seem to have been a lot of repair work done to the gas/heating/hot water infrastructure that year). Adding that figure to the figure I should be paying for gas still leaves a £1000 discrepancy between what they are charging me and what the costs should be. It is worth also considering that 18,590 kwh of gas is more than the average use for a four bedroom house according to Ofgem.


                          @Traveller23
                          : Good to see another Charlton Court resident on here. Do you know if there is or has ever been a residents association for the estate?

                          in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6842
                          Harvinho
                          Participant

                            @manager Who would I actually contact for the Inspection File? is it leaseholderservices@camden.org.uk. Regarding gas consumption, I don’t think it is a problem of the level consumption so much as a miscalculation in how much gas Camden estimates that estates/residents are using. It would be interesting to hear from someone who has already had a heat meter fitted by Camden (if they’ve actually fitted any to this point) to ascertain how much gas they are using and what their annual charges are. Not surprising that Camden don’t seem to have installed many heat meters yet, despite the legislation requiring all properties on a heat network to be metered being passed nearly ten years ago.

                            in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6841
                            Harvinho
                            Participant

                              I have written to James Slater and Sylvia Mcnamara (my local councillors) and have included the text below: please feel free to use and adapt. Local councillors can be found here: https://www.camden.gov.uk/find-your-ward-and-ward-map . I am going to encourage more leaseholders on my estate to do the same and feel that the more voices being heard in regard to this issue, the more likely it is to at least be investigated. I’ve also written to the Camden New Journal and Ham and High (who ran a story on this in 2021) requesting that they consider an investigation into Camden service charges.

                              Letter to councillor:
                              Dear [insert councillor’s name]

                              I am writing to you today to express my deep concern over the exorbitant council service charges that are being imposed on leaseholders in our local area. As someone who has been a resident in Camden for several years, I have noticed a disturbing trend of rising service charges, which is placing a heavy financial burden on many of us. The service charge bill I have just received for 2023/34 is £[insert figure] compared to £[insert figure] the previous year

                              In particular, I would like to draw your attention to the astronomical increase in the cost of gas, which has trebled since last year. This sudden surge in prices has hit many leaseholders hard, and it is becoming increasingly difficult for them to keep up with the payments. The cost for gas/heating/hot water has risen from £1186 to £3186, which is well above the average for a two bed flat, despite the government energy price cap remaining in place. British Gas states that the average gas bill for a 3 bedroom house currently is £1383 per annum yet I am being charged more than £3000 for a small 2 bed flat at a time when wholesale prices for gas are dropping and the government support is set to remain in place. This is extortionate and I would request that this is reviewed immediately and that leaseholders are charged in line with actual projections for energy costs rather than this seemingly arbitrary figure. Camden Council widely advertises their supposed support for its’ residents during the cost of living crisis, however, their willingness to charge these inflated prices clearly demonstrates a complete lack of care and empathy for Camden residents.

                              These exorbitant service charges also render all leaseholder properties unsaleable for at least the next year as the service charge is over £500 per month as well as mortgage rates being particularly high at the moment.

                              It is my belief that the council has a duty to provide its residents with services that are affordable and sustainable, and I am deeply concerned that these recent increases are not in line with that principle. As someone who has been elected to represent the interests of the people in our area, I urge you to investigate this matter thoroughly and to take action to ensure that the council service charges are fair and reasonable.

                              I would like to request that you take the following actions:

                              · Conduct a thorough investigation into the recent increases in council service charges for leaseholders, including the sudden surge in gas prices.

                              · Ensure that the council is transparent in its charging policies, so that leaseholders can understand how their fees are calculated and what they are paying for.

                              · Work to develop a fair and sustainable charging policy for council services, which takes into account the needs and financial constraints of leaseholders in our area.

                              I believe that it is imperative that our local government takes steps to address this issue, and I hope that you will use your position to help bring about positive change.

                              Thank you for your attention to this matter.

                              Yours sincerely,
                              [Insert name]

                              in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6838
                              Harvinho
                              Participant

                                @manager how can I get hold of this inspection file? I asked leaseholder services for it and they sent me the last fire risk assessment on my estate (not helpful). They have also responded to my initial e-mail to them without answering any of the questions I posed.

                                in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6817
                                Harvinho
                                Participant

                                  @manager If the fact that so many leaseholders with 1/2 bedroom flats are being charged for the amount of gas that would normally be used in a 5+ bedroom house than there very clearly is a problem here that Camden needs to investigate and set right. I don’t believe that you or any of us should be happy to settle for these astronomical charges; if, as you state, this is as a result of boiler and/or building inefficiency than Camden needs to urgently fix its boilers. I very much doubt that it is as a result of thermal efficiency of the building when you take into account the thermal efficiency of the average 5+ bedroom house, many of which are older properties. Whatever the circumstances are that have led to leaseholders being charged for such disproportionately high gas usage, need to be investigated and set right by Camden, in my opinion.

                                  in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6796
                                  Harvinho
                                  Participant

                                    @manager forgive me if I’ve calculated this wrong but if the unit price has increased to 8.53p per kw/h and I’m being charged £3186 Camden are estimating that I’m going to use 37,482 kw/h equivalent of gas. Ofgem has the average gas use for a 4+ bedroom house at 17000 kwh per annum. This then suggests that I’m being charged for the gas that would be used to heat an 8 bedroom mansion (I live in a 2 bed flat). I’m not sure how much the daily standing charge is but do seem to remember seeing that it could account for up to a third of the charge, which would mean that I’m still being charged for 25,000 kwh of gas use (more than double the national average).

                                    in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6789
                                    Harvinho
                                    Participant

                                      Whatever the system Camden uses for purchasing and apportioning costs for gas is clearly broken if leaseholders are being so many thousands of pounds for gas when many of us are using so little of it in reality. I intend to fight this every step of the way and hope that others wlil to.

                                      in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6772
                                      Harvinho
                                      Participant

                                        Hi

                                        I have just sent the following e-mail to the leaseholders e-mail address (camdenleaseholderservices@camden.gov.uk. Please feel free to adapt and use. Hopefully, they might act on this if enough people get involved. I’m going to draft a letter to my local councillor tomorrow and will post the contents of that on here too:

                                        Dear Sir/Madam,

                                        I am writing to express my deep concern regarding the leaseholder service charges that have doubled since last year. As a resident of the Charlton Court Estate on Brecknock Road, I am appalled by the fact that we are being charged for services that do not take place, such as cleaning and maintenance. Moreover, the cost for gas/heating/hot water has risen from £1186 to £3186, which is well above the average for a two bed flat, despite the government energy price cap remaining in place. British Gas states that the average gas bill for a 3 bedroom house currently is £1383 per annum yet I am being charged more than £3000 for a small 2 bed flat at a time when wholesale prices for gas are dropping and the government support is set to remain in place. This is extortionate and I would request that this is reviewed immediately and that leaseholders are charged in line with actual projections for energy costs rather than this abritrarily massive figure that seems to have been plucked from the air. Camden Council widely advertises their supposed support for its’ residents during the cost of living crisis, however, their willingness to charge these inflated prices clearly demonstrates a complete lack of care and empathy for Camden residents.

                                        I find it very unfair that we are being charged for services that are not being provided to us. The cleaning and maintenance services that we are being charged for have not been carried out, and it is not justifiable for us to pay for them. We have been paying for these services in good faith, and it is unacceptable that we have not received them. Some of the questionable work is described below. I look forward to receiving a detailed account from you in regards to how these costs were incurred:

                                        £415 block cost for TV aerial: No work has been done to tv aerials on the estate. What is the predicted cost here for?
                                        £16,560.53 block cost for Caretaking Services: There is a notice up on the estate describing daily caretaking services that should be being carried out. They are not happening and there are parts of the estate that have never been cleaned in the 6 years I have lived here
                                        Block (£3656) and Estate (£1779) charges for electricity: The estate only consists of one block so why are we being charged twice for estate wide electricity? What are these charges for?
                                        Tree Maintenace £5012: In the six years that I have lived on the estate the only work ever done on any trees was 2 small trees being planted at the front of the estate. What specific work is the council predicting that is going to cost £5012
                                        Lighting costs for block and estate: Same as the electricity above, where is the estate wide lighting that isn’t part of the one block?
                                        Refuse £1436: The bins are permanently overflowing and only ever removed when the bin men, who we pay for through council tax, clear them. What is this charge specifically for?
                                        Estate Roads and Footpaths £964.62: No roads on the estate and no work has been compoleted on any footpaths in the time that I have lived here. What is this predicted charge for specifically?

                                        I urge you to take immediate action and investigate the reasons behind the increase in service charges. It is our right as leaseholders to receive the services that we are paying for, and we should not be charged for services that are not being provided. We also expect transparency in the billing process, and we should be able to see a breakdown of the costs that we are being charged.

                                        I am a member of the Camden Leaseholders Forum and I know that this problem is widespread across Camden. I and many other members of the forum will be contacting Local Counsillors as well as the local press in order to expediate a prompt and thorough investigation and review of these most recent Camden Leaseholder charges.

                                        In conclusion, I kindly request that you take our concerns seriously and take appropriate action to resolve the issue. I hope that you will do everything possible to ensure that leaseholders are treated fairly and that we are charged only for the services that we receive and that we are charged a fair price for our gas, heating and hot water.

                                        Yours faithfully,

                                        [insert name]

                                        in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6754
                                        Harvinho
                                        Participant

                                          Similarly have just received a service charge bill for the coming year that has more than doubled, largely as a result of the gas/heating rising from £1186 to £3196! Small 2 bed flat and all the flats on the estate are fairly well insulated and south facing. No way the figure should be this high. Also concerned that the council are going to try to charge us the same amount for gas for the year just gone, when they figure out the shortfall (normally in September). Would be great if someone with a bit of experience in challenging the council could suggest the best way to do this. I would also be interested in joining any joint action being planned.

                                          Adrian
                                          Charlton Court Estate

                                          Harvinho
                                          Participant

                                            I would be interested in observing the hearing as expensive Major works are being planned for my estate (Charlton Court). How can I get involved?

                                          Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 20 total)