billmurray

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 29 posts - 1 through 29 (of 29 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6980
    billmurray
    Participant

      Hi Carolyn,
      Thanks. How do we get on the agenda the leaseholder’s right to change to individual heating/hotwater systems?
      Best, Bill

      in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6976
      billmurray
      Participant

        Thanks Carolyn,
        How do we get on the agenda the leaseholder’s right to change to individual heating/hotwater systems?

        in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6964
        billmurray
        Participant

          OK. We’re all whinging about how something must be done. Someone needs to step up and offer to spearhead our complaints, otherwise they will just, as always, just run into the sand. I’d be happy to chip in for this if required.

          in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6932
          billmurray
          Participant

            I don’t know how these things work, but can we get Council agreement at the next Leaseholder Meeting to the proposal that we have the right to opt out of communal hot water/heating systems in favour of our own properly fitted electric systems? Perhaps Camden could be permitted to keep a central heating pipe going through a flat en route elsewhere, with radiators removed. Or they could remove the pipe at their expense.

            Anyone got any ideas how to secure this right?

            Best,
            Bill

            in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6925
            billmurray
            Participant

              Yes, this is definitely the point where we extract the right to put in our own electric or gas hot water/heating systems. Perhaps Camden could be permitted to keep a central heating pipe going through a flat en route elsewhere, with radiators removed. Or they could remove the pipe at their expense…
              Best,
              Bill

              in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6854
              billmurray
              Participant

                Thanks daugs, I suppose I should know…..but I don’t know what this useful-sounding “18m rule” is?

                in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6760
                billmurray
                Participant

                  Or will our Councillors (sp?) do this effectively?

                  in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6759
                  billmurray
                  Participant

                    Many thanks gingerbbm.

                    “We then added 50% to the expected 2022/23 out turn as a means of forecasting the prices for 2023/24.”

                    Since energy prices are falling, does anyone know an experienced solicitor who could represent leaseholders, for a fee, in seeking the Council’s removal of the 50% addition from the “expected 2022/23 out turn” and the revision of our Service Charge bills?

                    Or any other ideas?

                    in reply to: Extortionate service charges #6755
                    billmurray
                    Participant

                      Strange coincidence that bills land just after the forum….

                      Where does the £2,500 cap fit in here?

                      Energy prices are falling, and may have been significantly higher when these bills were prepared. Bearing in mind this unique and desperate situation, is there any means by which we could jointly request an extraordinary ad hoc re-assessment after say 4 months? Or can we only resort to a petition of some kind?

                      in reply to: Contacting Camden leaseholder services #6518
                      billmurray
                      Participant

                        Yes complaints to Complaints might well be completely unacknowledged.

                        in reply to: Weedington Estate heating and hot water #6392
                        billmurray
                        Participant

                          A good proportion of leaseholders will be renting out, so unlikely to see flyers…..

                          in reply to: Weedington Estate heating and hot water #6387
                          billmurray
                          Participant

                            Camden won’t give you a list of leaseholders – it’s a secret… One way of identifying them is via online property sites.

                            in reply to: Weedington Estate heating and hot water #6209
                            billmurray
                            Participant

                              If you can get a copy of the Options Report, which will have considered alternative solutions, you can probably tear it to shreds, in which case Camden would very likely back off. I’d be happy to help (no charge!). Requesting via your Councillor will probably be quicker.

                              in reply to: Weedington Estate heating and hot water #6053
                              billmurray
                              Participant

                                Hi,
                                We had this problem a few years ago, but managed to fend them off.
                                It will be good to get tenant support also, rather than relying on a few “greedy fat cat leaseholders”. They will be unhappy about the massive disruption inside their flats, particularly if renewing the distribution system is not really necessary.
                                Get hold of their options report – it is likely to be rubbish which you can tear to shreds.
                                We punted for individual electric radiators. Failed, but this must be the way to go, so you’ll have more chance this time.
                                Bon chance,
                                Bill

                                in reply to: legal challenge #5997
                                billmurray
                                Participant

                                  Yes, I’m interested. But charges for works are more of a rip off…
                                  Best,
                                  Bill

                                  in reply to: Cost of Camden External Building Work #5375
                                  billmurray
                                  Participant

                                    Here at Millman Place WC1 we are about to be hit again by Camden’s Major Works steamroller. Peter Wright makes useful points above about employing a surveyor. We have done this in the past to a limited extent. Obviously we should be organising ourselves to pool this service, but this is beyond our capabilities. It is not inexpensive and one could perhaps end up paying even higher costs. Does anyone have any advice or surveyor recommendations?

                                    in reply to: Major Works 2017/18 Bill Extortionate #5166
                                    billmurray
                                    Participant

                                      Hi,
                                      It’s good that you raise this.
                                      We are not currently under the sword, having successfully rebuffed a major attack. But surely will be again soon.
                                      Yes the two things we all need are access to lawers and surveyors; and the barrier is the cost of these. We need some mechanism whereby resources are pooled at levels affordable to us. Our leases and the charges are largely common, so that there must be enormous savings in pooling. A few of us have shared the cost of a surveyor for our particular estate problems on a one-off basis. It would be good if the services were available on a Camden-wide retainer basis. However I don’t think we can manage to arrange this…..

                                      We have also found it very useful to involve Councillors and of course to work with affected tenants.

                                      in reply to: Leighton Grove major works #5039
                                      billmurray
                                      Participant

                                        Hi,
                                        Millman Street/Place leaseholders face these same issues. Several threads under this Major Works-Estmates have the same difficulties. How can we co-ordinate?
                                        Best,
                                        Bill

                                        in reply to: Bourne Estate Major Works £20000 bills for leaseholders #4476
                                        billmurray
                                        Participant

                                          Hi,
                                          Yes in Millman Street / Millman Place we have been struggling with window issues for years. As well as prospective threats we have replacements that are riddled with serious defects. I believe one of the Councillors is taking an interest in this.

                                          in reply to: heating and hot water charge calculation #4233
                                          billmurray
                                          Participant

                                            Re oakshott’s message above: figures only relevant if you have significant non-residential consumers on your district system. (I’ve posted about this somewhere else on the Forum..)

                                            Yes Councillors can help a great deal – we have found Councillor Vincent to be particularly good – but they need co-ordinated support.

                                            Best,
                                            Bill

                                            in reply to: heating and hot water charge calculation #4227
                                            billmurray
                                            Participant

                                              I did recently, and after years of wrangling, manage to get to some real numbers – and even a writeback and annual future reduction. I think this was down to refusing to pay the service charges for heating and hot water to the point of threats by Camden’s solicitors. There seems to a need for a further level of leaseholder representation – more aggregated than this Forum – which can engage Camden on behalf of leaseholders from more than one estate, and if appropriate suggest widespread withholding of charges until Camden fulfills its legal obligations regarding charges justifications.

                                              in reply to: Backdated Service Charge Correction? #4211
                                              billmurray
                                              Participant

                                                After several years wrangling the Council have finally rebated £250 against overcharging for heating/hot water etc with a reduction of about £50 per year going forward. If you have significant non-residential accommodation on your district heating system – in our case a nursery school and community centre – it might be worth checking that connected leaseholders are not paying for this.

                                                in reply to: Backdated Service Charge Correction? #4153
                                                billmurray
                                                Participant

                                                  Are the Council mandated to explain the full calculations underlying individual charges or only the principles which are applied?
                                                  Best,
                                                  Bill

                                                  in reply to: Heating Replacement (Specifically at Millman Street) #2605
                                                  billmurray
                                                  Participant

                                                    Updating the position on this particular project – this was received by leaseholders on 1st March 2016: “In order for us progress this work to the satisfaction of the resident’s at Millman Place & Millman Street we have decided not to deliver the scheme through Apollo. We will instead look for a new contractor to carry out the work by going through the tendering process, which is where registered companies compete for the work to ensure best value for money. We are also looking at the design again to confirm it is the best option for the estate.”

                                                    in reply to: Heating Replacement (Specifically at Millman Street) #2073
                                                    billmurray
                                                    Participant

                                                      I don’t know if anyone reads this…..but if so they may be interested in hearing that, in the face of resident pressure, Camden have withdrawn their heating proposals for Millman Street for the time being. The fact is that the proposals were badly conceived, apparently by greedy Apollo, and, because of overstretched Council resources, were not processed in the most sensitive manner. The residents’ “success” in defeating the proposals was achieved by active residents – both tenants and leaseholders working closely together – making written and face-to-face objections, submitting a petition and fully involving key Councillors.

                                                      in reply to: Heating Replacement (Specifically at Millman Street) #2033
                                                      billmurray
                                                      Participant

                                                        Following up on leasehlder’ request for a revised Options Report – the Council have now arranged this, via their partner Apollo. It does now include the currently proposed works – which, surprisingly, emerge as the winner! whilst a proper analysis of the available material woukd find a more restrained approach to be better.

                                                        in reply to: Heating Replacement (Specifically at Millman Street) #1686
                                                        billmurray
                                                        Participant

                                                          Thanks again Paul.

                                                          Consultation observations closed last Thursday. Both the TRA and an informal group of leaseholders “observed” the discrepancies between Options Appraisal and construction proposal and asked for clarification etc. The differences are not only of cost but also of engineering structure – current proposals are for two commpletely separate systems, a possibility not previously entertained.

                                                          Following your comments I will suggest to the TRA and leaseholders that this is followed up by a clear “demand” for a new appropriate Options Report.

                                                          in reply to: Heating Replacement (Specifically at Millman Street) #1684
                                                          billmurray
                                                          Participant

                                                            Thanks Paul, that’s very useful.

                                                            Communal systems ought to be cheaper and more environmentally friendly…….but the Council’s capital cost estimates are absurd, and some five times those estimated in the 2012 Options Report for our estate!

                                                            In fact the current proposal for our estate bears no relation to the Options Report. Does anyone know if there is a requirement (of any kind) that there should be a discernable continuity from the Options Report to the subsequently implemented system? Or is the Council in order in constructing something that was not considered in the Options Report?

                                                            in reply to: Heating Replacement (Specifically at Millman Street) #1682
                                                            billmurray
                                                            Participant

                                                              Thanks Paul,

                                                              Yes but the draft Policy – para 7 on page 2/10 – says

                                                              However residents will not be permitted to opt out of the bulk gas network for their heating as this would not provide a cost benefit to either the Council or the resident.

                                                              I suppose “opt out of the bulk gas network for their heating” does provide for individual systems accessing this fuel source, but I’m not sure that the Council would not insist that this excludes individual systems.

                                                              Do you have a view?

                                                            Viewing 29 posts - 1 through 29 (of 29 total)